Frosty Barrel

13197 Newcastle Commons Dr, Newcastle
(425) 835-3455

Recent Reviews

Sort by
M. J.

It was not good at all. I felt sick right away.

Kim Green

Stopped by Frosty Barrel and honestly had a really good time. The vibe is super chill and easygoing — great spot to hang out, grab a drink, and relax. They’ve got a nice drink, ice cream and the staff is friendly and helpful without being over the top.
The food was solid too — fresh, flavorful, and good portions. It’s the kind of place that’s easy to come back to, whether you’re meeting friends or just want a laid-back night out.
Definitely planning to swing by again!

Megan Tee (Megs)

I've been here at least 5 times so I feel like I should finally give a review. The seasonal flavors are really good but I always end up getting the cherry amaretto. It's the perfect lil after dinner bite. Beyond that, every time I've gone, Ive been helped by different staff members and every single time they are incredibly nice and incredibly patient. I'm very happy to live near this lil gem of an ice cream place.

Rachael Amundson

Delicious ice cream! The guy working 2/1/26 around 2 pm has amazing customer service! Thank you.

Savannah Bruington

Atmosphere 10/19. Staff and service, 10/10. Icecream, best I’ve ever had. Will be back for sure.

Amanda Rose

Awesome ice cream and a nice, cozy atmosphere. The perfect place for us to drop in when in the area.

M W

They removed the Ube and it upset me. Please bring it back as a regular flavour and I'll make this 5 stars

Fennel xoxo

Such a cute spot for a ice cream night. Cozy decor and sweet staff! Their portion sizes are huge!! Bang for your buck Definitely recommend their ice creams and hot chocolate.

The Honest Reviewer

Ambience is really good. Holiday decor is adorable. Staff is very friendly and kind. You can sample different ice cream flavors. Quantity is extra ordinary. Hot chocolate was tasty and the whipped cream was tasty. I’d highly recommend this place for dessert.

K T

An ice cream shop offering unique flavors. Specialty beverages are available also. Nice fireplace keeps you warm in winter. Holiday decorations are nice too.

Tiffany G

Delicious, unique ice cream with drink pairings. Their Christmas Gingerbread house transformation and hot cocoa flight is a must try!

Cozy vibe and good people.

Hailey Fletcher

Fun, unique flavors and decorated super cute for the holidays!

Lina “Dreaming_soul”

I found this café through Instagram as a Christmas-themed place to visit, and it was a lovely experience. The space is beautifully decorated for the season and feels warm and cozy. The hot chocolate was delicious, the ice cream was excellent, and the staff were genuinely kind and welcoming. The table with the fire feature was a standout detail that made the atmosphere even more inviting.

Christina Hartman

This is such an awesome concept! I would have been content with the hot cocoa and ice cream options, but the savory food was also good!

D H

I went here with my BF on a whim because we were headed to the Blazing Onion that was right next door. It had been a while since he and I had gone for ice cream together so it was nice after lunch when he asked me if I wanted to go.
We went inside and the scene was festive and nostalgic and had so many cute Christmas decorations. There were many gingerbread men and a couple of trees and many other decorations as well. The decor was cute.
We ordered our ice cream, I got gingerbread and peppermint stick and he got raspberry sorbet. I loved the ice cream, I really liked the gingerbread one the best. After we received our order we sat at the table that had a fir pit in the center and we were just relaxing and eating our ice cream.
After a few minutes another lady came and asked if she and her friend may sit at the table too, I said sure. They ordered an interesting thing it was an ice cream and wine pairing.
We finished our order and left, it was overall really nice and the atmosphere is pleasant. I would go here again just to see what other flavors they have during other seasons and holidays.

Loading...