Whidbey Island Bagel Factory

Bagels are probably made in the morning, so at lunch they are a little hard. But the sandwiches are too good. I had the curry chicken sandwich and it was filling and very tasty, given it had cranberries to add a sweetness to it. For vegetarians, there was only grilled cheese option.

Food was tasty but small sized portions. 1 bagel is more of a small snack - had to eat 2 to feel somewhat satisfied.

Quite possibly the best bagels I’ve ever had. The turkey club is excellent, but don’t sleep on the regular bagels & schmear! My fav was the cranberry orange bagel with cranberry orange cream cheese. Super fast and friendly service, and a quaint little atmosphere. I will be dreaming of these bagels until the next time I visit Whidbey Island!

Bagel was meh. Nothing really special. Service at the register was meh, they were too quiet and I couldn't hear. One thing that really turned us off is 1. The bagel with kimchi had bagel that was sweet. And kimchi usually never goes well with sweet things like that. 2. The person who was making the bagel was not wearing a hat, was touching her phone the whole time without washing hands. The dirtiest thing in the world is your phone because it goes everywhere with you, and they really need to wear proper attire and wash hands for making these bagels.

Man, oh man. There's a reason this place is always busy. Fantastic bagels, huge variety of flavors and a good sandwich menu!

waited for 50 minutes to find out our orders were never put in. We went on regularly, but won't be back. Also, as a New Yorker, they are good bagels, but NOT New York style.

So good! Fast service! I go there twice a week.

Cute shop with a ton of bagel options! A little cramped and busy but honestly that probably just goes to show how good the place is. Wait was reasonable and the bagel sandwiches were great!

All I can say is YUM.

I'll start this out by stating my bagel credentials-- I'm an East Coast transplant who cried the first time they had a Franz bagel as a child. I absolutely love the bagels here, and had the pleasure of meeting the owner. I love the vibe, the staff seem relaxed, and I especially love that there's a giant sign saying he'll ban anyone rude to his workers.

The bagels are perfect, the ultimate balance between chewy and crusty, and airy and dense. I just got whole bagels, but I will definitely be back to try all the sandwiches and goodies. The jalepeno bagels are spicy but SO good, and the cheese bagels actually taste cheesy. New lifelong customer here, I just wish I lived closer.

Horrible experience. Order a hot chocolate and never got it. They skip my order and start getting other orders after I ask for my hot chocolate a second time and they completely ignore me. They were employees doing nothing and I was waiting for more than 15 minutes for a hot chocolate. Went home paying for something that never was served. There’s a sign saying “ don’t be rude at employees or we banned you” and they are the first ones being rude at you. Hopefully doesn’t happen to anyone. Horrible horrible experience. Don’t recommend.

My son loves the bagels and I devoured the Lox bagel sandwich I ordered. Also took home some salmon cream cheese and it was delicious!!! Service was great and our cashier was lovely Looking forward to our next visit

Great bagels, but every time I order a bakers dozen of plain bagels I only get 12 bagels unless I count them and remind them it’s 13. Forgot to count them today and got home with only 12. Not a huge deal but a bit irritating.

The building is beautiful, I like the rustic feel and the ambience! The bagels are so fresh, and flavorful. I had a bacon, egg, and cheese on a jalapeño cheddar bagel. 10/10 you should try it out. Delicious!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg&Cheese Bagel

I had lunch at the new location for the Whidbey Island Bagel Factory. The last time I visited was 4 years ago when they were located on Fidalgo Avenue. Now they’re located in the Log Cabin on Midway.

I chose to enjoy a Reuben sandwich on a Jalapeño and Cheddar bagel. Simply scrumptious! For my drink I opted for. 12oz coffee. I mention the coffee because it was a great tasting cup of coffee! Not acidic or heavy tasting.

The counter staff is friendly, helpful, and professional. Service with a smile ?

The new location looks very similar to the old Fidalgo location. Just smaller… on the ground floor. There are steps leading to a second floor, but they were roped off as the upstairs was closed ?.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jalapeno Bagels