Good pizza, even better people. I called ahead and was treated pleasantly over the phone. Their easy pick-up option from a side door is very convenient to go along with numerous parking spaces. I hope to go inside next time!
Ravshan Ganiev
Nice place
Gisel Sandoval
My favorite thus far my go to medium Hawaiian with olives and 2 ranch and it's 🔥🔥🤤👌
Mary Mejia
Unfortunately Shy’s is pick up only. I live in Benton City and this is the only pizza that we get. The owners are wonderful and friendly and I always enjoy seeing them.
Ronald Ladd
Came in just for a slice after a eight hour shift for the first time here in Pace it’s a 20 minutes for me to notice that a slice of pepperoni wasn’t delivered in another 10 minutes for them to bring out a damn burnt slice. Yes, I was offered with them to make it again but first impressions are key when you walk into new places, I will simply go back because of the bartender And the cook that just arrived, showed interest that he would make another one.
Olivia Wooten
It was delicious
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Larry Briones
No dine in, must order thru door. Pizza doesn't taste the same as it used to. Either they are skimping on sauce and toppings and/or the crust has changed. Very dry pizza
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Jnshox
Was parking today and a bald headed employee came out to make sure to tell me the parking was for guests only. I think he right away assumed we were going to play basketball.
Drove to Mods pizza in Yakima instead to spend my money and eat.
How unfortunate for the man to assume. I also told him we would eat else where. He must be annoyed that a basketball tournament is going on 100 feet from the establishment.
He knows exactly who is he and that's too bad....
stephen greenwade
Ordered a 28 dollar pizza and asked for napkins so I was handed 3 napkins for a large pizza and on top of that I asked for parm and peppers but was told they don't carry them. Pretty lame I thought, and when I opened up the pizza box the pizza was limp and soggy. I really hope my review saves someone else from not going here. I should have went to domino's. Have a great evening and happy pizza hunting in prosser. 6/24/24 5:57 pm
This is a true Prosser Pizza institution. Before the cheap national chain pizzas came to town, this is where you came with the team after games and played the arcade games. The pizza is has a somewhat thinner crust, traditional red sauce and good amount of quality toppings. The biggest loss in town was when they shut down the smorgasbord due to people cheating the system, which is weird because a dinner plate cost $7.95 per person. I still ask the owners to bring it back a couple times a year but to no avail. Good pizza, great local owners, and childhood memories, buy some pizza and support the locals.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Sue Hord
Ordered the pizza from the window, and he brought it out to my truck. It was hot and good pizza. We will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Carlos GG
The best pizza all around and the #1 service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Consuelo Felicijan
The best pizza all around and the #1 service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hazel edwards
I came from Tricities and always remembered as a kiddo this was THE spot to be after sports or with family. I traveled through Prosser as soon as I opened the door to Shys Pizza I was welcomed with a hello! $25 for medium cheese pizza and breadsticks with ranch of course. Delicious, affordable, welcoming!
Pizza was mediocre at best.
Good pizza, even better people. I called ahead and was treated pleasantly over the phone. Their easy pick-up option from a side door is very convenient to go along with numerous parking spaces. I hope to go inside next time!
Nice place
My favorite thus far my go to medium Hawaiian with olives and 2 ranch and it's 🔥🔥🤤👌
Unfortunately Shy’s is pick up only. I live in Benton City and this is the only pizza that we get. The owners are wonderful and friendly and I always enjoy seeing them.
Came in just for a slice after a eight hour shift for the first time here in Pace it’s a 20 minutes for me to notice that a slice of pepperoni wasn’t delivered in another 10 minutes for them to bring out a damn burnt slice. Yes, I was offered with them to make it again but first impressions are key when you walk into new places, I will simply go back because of the bartender And the cook that just arrived, showed interest that he would make another one.
It was delicious
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
No dine in, must order thru door. Pizza doesn't taste the same as it used to. Either they are skimping on sauce and toppings and/or the crust has changed. Very dry pizza
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Was parking today and a bald headed employee came out to make sure to tell me the parking was for guests only. I think he right away assumed we were going to play basketball.
Drove to Mods pizza in Yakima instead to spend my money and eat.
How unfortunate for the man to assume. I also told him we would eat else where. He must be annoyed that a basketball tournament is going on 100 feet from the establishment.
He knows exactly who is he and that's too bad....
Ordered a 28 dollar pizza and asked for napkins so I was handed 3 napkins for a large pizza and on top of that I asked for parm and peppers but was told they don't carry them. Pretty lame I thought, and when I opened up the pizza box the pizza was limp and soggy. I really hope my review saves someone else from not going here. I should have went to domino's. Have a great evening and happy pizza hunting in prosser. 6/24/24 5:57 pm
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a true Prosser Pizza institution. Before the cheap national chain pizzas came to town, this is where you came with the team after games and played the arcade games. The pizza is has a somewhat thinner crust, traditional red sauce and good amount of quality toppings. The biggest loss in town was when they shut down the smorgasbord due to people cheating the system, which is weird because a dinner plate cost $7.95 per person. I still ask the owners to bring it back a couple times a year but to no avail. Good pizza, great local owners, and childhood memories, buy some pizza and support the locals.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Ordered the pizza from the window, and he brought it out to my truck. It was hot and good pizza. We will be back!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
The best pizza all around and the #1 service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza all around and the #1 service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I came from Tricities and always remembered as a kiddo this was THE spot to be after sports or with family. I traveled through Prosser as soon as I opened the door to Shys Pizza I was welcomed with a hello! $25 for medium cheese pizza and breadsticks with ranch of course. Delicious, affordable, welcoming!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...