Food can be pretty good. But definitely over priced. If you're picking up beware they're regularly behind on their eta. Folks at the counter are often short on manners. If you're late in the kitchen. It might be a good idea to be kind to your guests.. Pizza is pretty good but honestly not worth the huge price tag.
T Lowe
Very disappointed in the hot wings. If you want unseasoned chicken and tons of fat this is for you. 🤬 I'm scared to go back and try the pizza 🤷🏽♀️
Kari T
I had a personal size pizza. The crust was under cooked in the middle. There were only minimal toppings. They are way over priced for what you get. The staff are great. I'd recommend as a sports bar.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Haylee Meeker
Chole was a sweet heart! Best Service 10/10. Food was amazing when my food was even a little burnt girly got me a whole new one to go I didn’t even have to say anything! They are also so kid friendly were so sweet to my son !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charles Aanderud
Always friendly and polite, always greeted nicely when arriving, food is always made correctly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Genasia Marie
I really like this place, especially as a vegetarian, there’s many options for me to pick from, but for the price of certain dishes (mainly pastas) it definitely isn’t worth it. The portion size of the pastas could be for a young kid and they ask for $20 a plate..
Em Johso
so delicious 😋😩
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Peluso
I enjoyed the meat eater pizza along with the cold mugs of beer. No wait to sit in the bar, along with severial large screen TV's to watch the Mariners pre game.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Crook
Great pizza, great service. Our server, Sam, was kind, helpful, and made the experience excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beth Dempsey
Trinity L gave us the best service! She made my birthday so special and was very accommodating with my food allergies! She is so sweet and kind, and went above and beyond for us!
We had dinner this evening at Farrelli's in Puyallup off of 176th it was the worst meal I have ever had there there's spaghetti is no longer spaghetti it's some Twisted elbow macaroni the pizza was wonderful but they use the exact same pasta in every pasta dish so they're fettuccine alfredo is not fettuccine they're spaghetti and marinara is not spaghetti and their mac and cheese is an elbow Twisted macaroni that they use in place of spaghetti and fettuccine this is disgusting my husband loves their spaghetti and meatballs but will never eat there again because this horrible Twisted elbow macaroni that they're passing off to go with their meatballs is terrible their prices haven't gone down they've gone up but their food quality has declined to the point where there were four of us at the table and not another one of us would ever come there to order anything besides a Pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Andrew Fitzgerald
Went with wife and child. Multiple arcade machines were broken, did not get crayons with kids coloring paper and we were offered used dirty ones because they ran out. The one drink my wife wanted was not available, they were out of anchovies, had to ask for parmesan like it was a special offering, did not receive any of the items that come with the kids meal pizza and when we asked about it she said she didn't include or offer it because most parents don't want it. She brought them out after we were finished. We asked for a to go personal pizza when we were finished and she forgot about it. We didn't make a big deal about any of it. Great pizza but that will be our last time there due to poor customer service and lack of inventory. Waitress was very nice, but poorly trained.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Jared
Amazing staff, but sadly some poor corporate standards for food.
It was my birthday and I wanted to try a new place with my wife and kids. And since Farellis had good reviews, I thought I would go.
I was craving something Fatty and Savory, so I ordered a Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. It had chicken, all the veggies, ranch base. The pizza tasted good. However they're was only a tiny sliver about 5mm wide and 15 mm long on each slice of my 12 inch pizza.
They had literally taken a single small slice of bacon cut into tiny pieces and put one single sliver on most of the slices. 2 of the slices didn't even have bacon.
I don't normally make complaints, but when I order a chicken bacon pizza, I do expect to have bacon on all the slices and more than a sliver per slice. I have never ordered a pizza with bacon that had so little bacon.
Luckily I asked the waitress if it was at all possible to get a little bit of bacon for the pizza so that I could at least have a sliver for the pizzas with no bacon. She said that the amount there on my pizza was up to the standard set by corporate. But she understood my concern about how some of the pieces didn't even have bacon.
She did ask the kitchen to make 2 slices and cut them up so I could put it on the pizza. And honestly it was great after that. I really appreciated her understanding my possibly petty concern.
Besides that, the red rod the experience was great. My wife loved her pizza and Mac and Cheese. The kids loved their meals, and playing with the dough balls and drawing with crayons. We played a few arcade games in the back and won some candy from the candy crane.
I would come back again, but now I know that I shouldn't order anything with bacon since the corporate portions set are insanely stingy. Which is sad because bacon bought in bulk come out to maybe $0.10 for a piece of bacon. No need to get greedy when a 12 inch pizza is nearly $30.
Jeff Summers
Chloe is an awesome server, I'm thankful she gave me time to run home and grab my wallet since I forgot it like a moron. Made sure to tip her a lil extra for being super gracious about it.
Christi Thoroughman
Hadn't had Farrelli pizza in a long time. It waa yummy.....spendy but yummy. We got the crab ragoon Stix, they were amazing. Thursday at this location is trivia night, seemed fun but we didn't stay for much of it.
Food can be pretty good. But definitely over priced. If you're picking up beware they're regularly behind on their eta. Folks at the counter are often short on manners. If you're late in the kitchen. It might be a good idea to be kind to your guests.. Pizza is pretty good but honestly not worth the huge price tag.
Very disappointed in the hot wings. If you want unseasoned chicken and tons of fat this is for you. 🤬 I'm scared to go back and try the pizza 🤷🏽♀️
I had a personal size pizza. The crust was under cooked in the middle. There were only minimal toppings. They are way over priced for what you get. The staff are great. I'd recommend as a sports bar.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Chole was a sweet heart! Best Service 10/10. Food was amazing when my food was even a little burnt girly got me a whole new one to go I didn’t even have to say anything! They are also so kid friendly were so sweet to my son !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always friendly and polite, always greeted nicely when arriving, food is always made correctly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I really like this place, especially as a vegetarian, there’s many options for me to pick from, but for the price of certain dishes (mainly pastas) it definitely isn’t worth it. The portion size of the pastas could be for a young kid and they ask for $20 a plate..
so delicious 😋😩
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I enjoyed the meat eater pizza along with the cold mugs of beer.
No wait to sit in the bar, along with severial large screen TV's to watch the Mariners pre game.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, great service. Our server, Sam, was kind, helpful, and made the experience excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trinity L gave us the best service! She made my birthday so special and was very accommodating with my food allergies! She is so sweet and kind, and went above and beyond for us!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We had dinner this evening at Farrelli's in Puyallup off of 176th it was the worst meal I have ever had there there's spaghetti is no longer spaghetti it's some Twisted elbow macaroni the pizza was wonderful but they use the exact same pasta in every pasta dish so they're fettuccine alfredo is not fettuccine they're spaghetti and marinara is not spaghetti and their mac and cheese is an elbow Twisted macaroni that they use in place of spaghetti and fettuccine this is disgusting my husband loves their spaghetti and meatballs but will never eat there again because this horrible Twisted elbow macaroni that they're passing off to go with their meatballs is terrible their prices haven't gone down they've gone up but their food quality has declined to the point where there were four of us at the table and not another one of us would ever come there to order anything besides a Pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Went with wife and child. Multiple arcade machines were broken, did not get crayons with kids coloring paper and we were offered used dirty ones because they ran out. The one drink my wife wanted was not available, they were out of anchovies, had to ask for parmesan like it was a special offering, did not receive any of the items that come with the kids meal pizza and when we asked about it she said she didn't include or offer it because most parents don't want it. She brought them out after we were finished. We asked for a to go personal pizza when we were finished and she forgot about it. We didn't make a big deal about any of it. Great pizza but that will be our last time there due to poor customer service and lack of inventory. Waitress was very nice, but poorly trained.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Amazing staff, but sadly some poor corporate standards for food.
It was my birthday and I wanted to try a new place with my wife and kids. And since Farellis had good reviews, I thought I would go.
I was craving something Fatty and Savory, so I ordered a Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. It had chicken, all the veggies, ranch base. The pizza tasted good. However they're was only a tiny sliver about 5mm wide and 15 mm long on each slice of my 12 inch pizza.
They had literally taken a single small slice of bacon cut into tiny pieces and put one single sliver on most of the slices. 2 of the slices didn't even have bacon.
I don't normally make complaints, but when I order a chicken bacon pizza, I do expect to have bacon on all the slices and more than a sliver per slice. I have never ordered a pizza with bacon that had so little bacon.
Luckily I asked the waitress if it was at all possible to get a little bit of bacon for the pizza so that I could at least have a sliver for the pizzas with no bacon. She said that the amount there on my pizza was up to the standard set by corporate. But she understood my concern about how some of the pieces didn't even have bacon.
She did ask the kitchen to make 2 slices and cut them up so I could put it on the pizza. And honestly it was great after that. I really appreciated her understanding my possibly petty concern.
Besides that, the red rod the experience was great. My wife loved her pizza and Mac and Cheese. The kids loved their meals, and playing with the dough balls and drawing with crayons.
We played a few arcade games in the back and won some candy from the candy crane.
I would come back again, but now I know that I shouldn't order anything with bacon since the corporate portions set are insanely stingy. Which is sad because bacon bought in bulk come out to maybe $0.10 for a piece of bacon. No need to get greedy when a 12 inch pizza is nearly $30.
Chloe is an awesome server, I'm thankful she gave me time to run home and grab my wallet since I forgot it like a moron. Made sure to tip her a lil extra for being super gracious about it.
Hadn't had Farrelli pizza in a long time. It waa yummy.....spendy but yummy. We got the crab ragoon Stix, they were amazing.
Thursday at this location is trivia night, seemed fun but we didn't stay for much of it.
Loading...