Jersey Mike's Subs

716 Shaw Rd E Suite C, Puyallup
(253) 268-2885

Recent Reviews

Sort by
M.A.

Had a mini club sub it was my free one with points but service was very friendly and they made it perfect! Will be back šŸ˜„

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Glen Rathier

Got 2 of 4 subs wrong

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

katty mama

These people literally stole my money šŸ’°šŸ’°šŸ’°šŸ’° I placed an order for almost $90 and didn't get my order but was still charged. Very poor customer service šŸ˜”

Liz Summers

Paid $27 for them to take 25 minutes to make a sandwich and still get my order wrong. Good thing I only have a taste preference and not a food allergy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Casey Russo

I couldn't love this staff more than I do.

They're always on point. Polite. Efficient. Never messed up an order. Patient. Will do it your way and even fix what someone else screws up.

This is the BEST Jersey Mike's between Tacoma and Bellevue and I will die on that hill.

Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

yassine H

Food is good, but manager need to hire right people and work on customer service. Once walked in, I immediately served by upset employe. No smile, not talking politely ... I'm not coming back here

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Joseph S

It's hit or miss if your sandwich is made correctly. A lot of the times your hot sandwich ends up being cold. Which makes zero sense. But as you can see from the photo, their work is very sloppy.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Alexander Schweigert

Great service from everyone at this location! Food was fresh and hot and had wonderful conversations with all the employees. Worker Ian especially had great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steve Smith

Just moved here from Kent Washington I buy from Jersey Mike every week the quality of the cure of the sandwiches from the Orting store was unsatisfactory very disappointed

Krista

Visited today to pick up an online order that I made in advance. I waited in my car to go in at the time it was supposed to be ready by. When I entered, the order was or course not ready. It was lunch time so I thought no biggie, I’ll wait. I stood and besides for another 10 mins and noticed that they were handing out hot sandwiches from the other side so I walked to that side to see it that’s where the rest of my order would come out. I was asked again by a tall gal who was working the meat slicer if she could help. I said I was just waiting ok the rest of my order and very rudely in front of other customers she snapped at me and said ā€œSHES WORKING ON ITā€. I said there was no need to be rude, If it would be longer I’d go back to th car because I had left my family in the car. She continued to berate and say she wast rude. I said yes you were, the order is late and there is no reason to yell at me like that.

Idk who runs this store - I was told manager is Tyler; but the front staff could very much use some extra training in customer service and how to speak to people like humans.

I’ll never go back here again specifically because I don’t think it’s polite to have the stash snap at me for asking for an update on my order. Terrible

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

angel

Placed our order exactly an hour ago. Have been waiting for 20 minutes for our food that they haven’t started making. They never have enough people working here. I wouldn’t be so irritated if I wasn’t pregnant and hungry.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Adam Schwindt

Fast, friendly & on time. Love coming here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kayli bentley

Got a sandwich tonight had multiple hairs in it melted in the cheese understand it happens but multiple shows the lack of cleanliness gross

JACK WIRTH

Overstaffed and no service, can't even acknowledge your there,

Stacy Buras

I am so disappointed by the staff at this location!!!!! We have been there several times since its opened, as it’s convenient for us- but the last few times we have been it hasn’t been good….. There is one particular female that is working there (no name tags so unable to say who she was) but she gives NO welcome NO eye contact when taking your order and ALWAYS gets something wrong with the order - throws a fit (appears to be a fit) and throws the cheese she just cut and put on my sandwich (after I had said no cheese) and I point it out - takes it and throws into the cooler…. God forbid you order a GF sandwich, I LOVE Jersey Mikes GF subs, we know it’s a safe place for me to eat- we visit Jersey Mikes ALOT! The attitude you get when you order one..
There was a young male, appears to be in training- he was the nicest one there, he gave eye contact when he asked you questions and smiled! Not sure there was any other employee there last night that even cracked a smile or a HELLO WELCOME IN.. For customer service I give this place 0 stars!!

Loading...