Mama Stortini's Restaurant & Bar
3207 E Main Ave, Puyallup
(253) 845-7569
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Wait time was good , did not have to wait long Waitress was great very polite and attentive Love that you have 3 meal course now Food tasted great Was nice and hot , when it came to the table Portion could have been a little bigger for the main dish Desert tasted delicious We had Tiramisu , yummy Overall experience was great
Always amazing food and service! Love the all day happy hour on Sundays and Mondays. Great reward program as well!
We had reservations at 5:45. They sat us at 6:10. Seemed like they were sitting people that didn't have reservations before us but I could be wrong. When they did sit us down. The table was wet with sanitizer. When I asked to get a dry towel to dry the table off the host said we just wiped it down that is why it's wet. I had to explain to him I didn't want to sit at a wet table can I please get some napkins to dry the very wet table off. He clearly didn't understand my issue with the wet table but he did go get me napkins. The dining room was cold. There clearly were not reading the room. When I looked around everyone was wearing their coats. It's not a good dining experience if you are cold and having to eat dinner wearing your coat. I got the 3 course dinner and added a couple of soup. First my soup was not even lukewarm and tasted like canned soup. The starter I got was the Zucchini crisp. Guess im not used to there version. I'm used to the thin sliced zucchini disk. These were long thick sticks and were mushy on the inside. Kind of off putting to me. The main course was the chicken parm. This was good. It was a huge portion and it was hot. But I was wishing I had gotten the salmon at this point. The desert was the Crème Brȗlée. It was ok tasted like the ones I get at Costco. Nothing to write home about.
Excellent food and service. Salmon is so good, not too dry. Seafoods fettuccine amazing, remember to add mushrooms.
Wonderful menu, great food, and a very delightful server. No wonder why the place was packed.
Great all day happy hour on Sundays! Service was excellent! Always enjoy the food and wine!
Our waitress could not remember our order and kept coming back and asking. We waited over an hour for our food. I understand it gets busy, but we should have been told it might be a long wait. It didn't seem busy, but maybe low on staff or something. It was a birthday celebration and it really put a damper on the evening.
They had a great special of the day for Father's Day and we were seated promptly at our reservation time. Enjoyable service and atmosphere!
The servers are wonderful! The food is great and they give you good sized portions! They serve your orders quickly! Its my go to place when I want to eat out! It can be a little noisy. It is almost always busy.
The appetizers we had were good, but it went down hill from there. I had the small Caesar salad and requested anchovies, when the salad arrived there were no anchovies and was told they didn't have any? What authentic Italian restaurant doesn't have anchovies? I had ordered the the spaghetti and meatballs and when it arrived I was surprised it doesn't come with any kind of bread? The entire dish was so salty I could barely eat it, and the sauce was so over simmered it was like tomato paste. The meatballs were so-so, but way over seasoned and salty. My wife had the chicken cannelloni for $17 which was about the size of two small hotdogs and didn't come with any sort of bread either. Service was okay, but not great. Needless to say, the food was horrible and the atmosphere and service don't make up for the poor quality food. We won't be going back!
Restaurantji Recommends
I got the salmon with honey pistachio butter. It was amazing. My family thought the portion was small. I chose the large option. I think the salmon portion was fine I wish there were more vegetables. My fiance got the lasagna he said it was good it didn't have heavy tanato taste which is a plus for him. There was hair on the plate which he didn't tell me until later. Love their cheesy garlic bread. So good. Nice portion. Tirimisu was definitely the highlight for me and they give you a big piece assume it's meant for sharing.
We were lucky to sit in the area overlooking the beautiful rhododendrons - and it cut down on the noise from the main restaurant. Our server, Toni, was exceptional, fun and very helpful in making our choices.
Had appetizers and a few happy hour drinks. Everything was very good. Wish they could turn up volume of the TV in the bar area to hear sporting event that’s being televised.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Love the food and our waitress Sonya.
Great service.
We go for lunch every Friday.
Love the fact we can park in handicap parking as my husband is a wheelchair.
Food was just ok, nothing to write home about. Pasta entrees tasted very average/mediocre that you could probably make better at home. Prices for the food did not match the quality. For the prices they are charging, you should get bread and salad included. Drinks were expensive too. Probably would not return to again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Loading...