AMAZING FOOD GREAT SERVICE.. the original the one in Olympia is not affiliated with them.
Drew Jacobs
Probably the best pizza place in the county. They have a great selection of specialty pizzas and service is always top notch.
P. Veldhuis
Love the food here, but tonight we sat at the bar (they were very busy) where we were great by a great gentleman, and he did a great job getting our order and drinks entered. As we sat there, we were overrun with Nats, too much to enjoy sitting there trying to eat our food, so when a table came open, we requested to be moved, which they obliged. Food arrived and great as always, but soon after, the push to leave. We felt rushed because we hadn't asked yet for a box but was offered one, and then our food was picked up and the box closed before we could say anything. Very weird.
Mark Terekhin
I went here two times, second time didn't work out though because they have a ridiculous rule that you must show your ID to even eat there. Inconvenient nonsense
Crista Thompson
The waiter was very rude. We came during the farmers market and was declined service. I asked for a manager and she said there was no manager. She was very sassy, rude and just walked away from us. I will never come back to this place again. She was a young girl with young black hair.
Mason Longnecker
Absolutely incredible pizza!! Fantastic menu and great cocktails!
Alyssa Forque
Everything on the menu is worth trying.
kitkat kamp
These people are so nice and make the best pizza my husband and I have ever had. We drive from Lakewood to come here. The crust is crispy and inside tastes like soft homemade bread. Delicious. I’m wondering if they have gift cards I can give for birthdays and Christmas Oh and the waitress Destiny is so friendly and fast, even bringing my dog water.
Karen Turner
My order was take-out. It wasn't quite ready when I arrived, and that wasn't a big deal. However, it was pretty cold when I got it to the car. I took a risk and ordered The Chosen One. I would not order again - they don't tell you what's on it and I was feeling adventurous. Heads up - it has chicken and white sauce. I didn't find it very flavorful, and since it was kind of soggy it was less appealing. A few minutes in the oven helped.
Joseph S
2 stars for the service ONLY because of the pricing. The original pricing of the pizzas, and then the pricing to sub/add toppings is kind of wild. That makes this place one that I'd only go to about once a month.
The pizza itself tasted pretty good. Probably about a 7.9/10. The leftovers tasted great still while cold about 6 hours later.
The atmosphere was nice! So if we can just lower prices, please. Or provide days with deals for more than just two basic pizzas. ?
Dietary restrictions: They do provide Gluten Free options.
Nothing more we can add to the already stellar reviews about Wicked pie- We had a small Caprese, an order of the meatballs and a margherita pizza. All were excellent! Destiny was a great server and we couldn’t be happier with our experience. ALSO…Kudos to the dough masters for creating an excellent pie for us! We visit Puyallup several times a year and now have a go to pizzeria awaiting our next visit!
Omg! The meatball appetizer was delicious! It’s was so much food that I could have just had that for my lunch. Definitely good for sharing. The pizza was fresh out of their brick oven ? Everything about it was fantastic! Stretchy mozzarella cheese, wood fired crust, zesty homemade sauce…mmmm!
Ok, now for other deets. No one under 21 years old may enter. It’s a bar. I actually love that atmosphere! Not that I don’t like kids (I have 5 of my own), but it’s a great ADULT place for a date or just hanging out with friends. They display the brick oven and pizza chefs making the pizzas in view of the dinning area. Amazing! I went during Sunday happy hour, just before it started getting busy, so I was seated right away. The staff were attentive and friendly. The food arrived in a timely manner and was displayed perfectly.
The website describes the restaurant exactly…it’s an ADULT pizza place with ADULT toppings/styles, ADULT drinks, and an ADULT atmosphere. I don’t count how many times the description mentions the word “ADULT!” Lol
All in all, I will definitely be returning. This may just be my new “food pick-up” on my way to work! ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball, Pie, The Classic Pepperoni
C Barron
Amazing pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mob Boss
J Dorso
Delicious. One of the better pizzas I’ve had.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
jaMM Anoa'i
The wait time went by quick. It's loud & bustling inside but still a great experience... pizza was so good!!! Salad was SO fresh!!! Cheesy bread was BOMB! Even my margarita was delicious!!! Definitely need to come back & try the rest of the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous Cheesy Bread, The Chosen One, Caprese
AMAZING FOOD GREAT SERVICE.. the original the one in Olympia is not affiliated with them.
Probably the best pizza place in the county. They have a great selection of specialty pizzas and service is always top notch.
Love the food here, but tonight we sat at the bar (they were very busy) where we were great by a great gentleman, and he did a great job getting our order and drinks entered. As we sat there, we were overrun with Nats, too much to enjoy sitting there trying to eat our food, so when a table came open, we requested to be moved, which they obliged. Food arrived and great as always, but soon after, the push to leave. We felt rushed because we hadn't asked yet for a box but was offered one, and then our food was picked up and the box closed before we could say anything. Very weird.
I went here two times, second time didn't work out though because they have a ridiculous rule that you must show your ID to even eat there. Inconvenient nonsense
The waiter was very rude. We came during the farmers market and was declined service. I asked for a manager and she said there was no manager. She was very sassy, rude and just walked away from us. I will never come back to this place again. She was a young girl with young black hair.
Absolutely incredible pizza!! Fantastic menu and great cocktails!
Everything on the menu is worth trying.
These people are so nice and make the best pizza my husband and I have ever had. We drive from Lakewood to come here. The crust is crispy and inside tastes like soft homemade bread. Delicious. I’m wondering if they have gift cards I can give for birthdays and Christmas
Oh and the waitress Destiny is so friendly and fast, even bringing my dog water.
My order was take-out. It wasn't quite ready when I arrived, and that wasn't a big deal. However, it was pretty cold when I got it to the car.
I took a risk and ordered The Chosen One. I would not order again - they don't tell you what's on it and I was feeling adventurous. Heads up - it has chicken and white sauce. I didn't find it very flavorful, and since it was kind of soggy it was less appealing. A few minutes in the oven helped.
2 stars for the service ONLY because of the pricing. The original pricing of the pizzas, and then the pricing to sub/add toppings is kind of wild. That makes this place one that I'd only go to about once a month.
The pizza itself tasted pretty good. Probably about a 7.9/10. The leftovers tasted great still while cold about 6 hours later.
The atmosphere was nice! So if we can just lower prices, please. Or provide days with deals for more than just two basic pizzas. ?
Dietary restrictions: They do provide Gluten Free options.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Nothing more we can add to the already stellar reviews about Wicked pie-
We had a small Caprese, an order of the meatballs and a margherita pizza. All were excellent!
Destiny was a great server and we couldn’t be happier with our experience. ALSO…Kudos to the dough masters for creating an excellent pie for us!
We visit Puyallup several times a year and now have a go to pizzeria awaiting our next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball, Caprese Salad, Margherita Pizza
Omg! The meatball appetizer was delicious! It’s was so much food that I could have just had that for my lunch. Definitely good for sharing. The pizza was fresh out of their brick oven ? Everything about it was fantastic! Stretchy mozzarella cheese, wood fired crust, zesty homemade sauce…mmmm!
Ok, now for other deets. No one under 21 years old may enter. It’s a bar. I actually love that atmosphere! Not that I don’t like kids (I have 5 of my own), but it’s a great ADULT place for a date or just hanging out with friends. They display the brick oven and pizza chefs making the pizzas in view of the dinning area. Amazing! I went during Sunday happy hour, just before it started getting busy, so I was seated right away. The staff were attentive and friendly. The food arrived in a timely manner and was displayed perfectly.
The website describes the restaurant exactly…it’s an ADULT pizza place with ADULT toppings/styles, ADULT drinks, and an ADULT atmosphere. I don’t count how many times the description mentions the word “ADULT!” Lol
All in all, I will definitely be returning. This may just be my new “food pick-up” on my way to work! ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball, Pie, The Classic Pepperoni
Amazing pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mob Boss
Delicious. One of the better pizzas I’ve had.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The wait time went by quick. It's loud & bustling inside but still a great experience... pizza was so good!!! Salad was SO fresh!!! Cheesy bread was BOMB! Even my margarita was delicious!!! Definitely need to come back & try the rest of the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous Cheesy Bread, The Chosen One, Caprese
Loading...