Macaluso's Italian Restaurant

AMAZING!! Beautiful dishes and the service was exceptional. We took leftovers and it was even better the next day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is awesome, I really love their food and atmosphere. Customer service is always awesome, I have to eat gluten free and the waitress was very helpful and did not skip a beat when I asked questions. They do have it clearly stated on the menu that cross contamination is a possibility but they do what they can, it's a mixed kitchen. I miss being able to eat the not-gluten-free pasta but I was satisfied with what I was able to eat

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cozy atmosphere and very attentive server. We told Jaimie that we needed to leave for a concert in 90 minutes, so she turned in our dinner order then took our drinks order, which was thoughtful and kept us on time without feeling rushed. We'll be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Food was 10 out of 10. My husband does not like sea food, but he ate most of our calamari appetizer. It was tender, perfectly seasoned and not over battered. His pasta dish(wish I remember the name) was perfect as well. It had chicken, sausage and mushroom with white sauce.
Service was great! It was packed, but they managed to find a seat for us. Friendly staff. When the guest at a table was done, it was cleaned up quickly, with ease (well they made it look easy) ready to seat another guest within 5mins. Our server was fantastic, she made us feel at ease.
Atmosphere not overwhelmingly noisy, dim lighting and was perfect for date night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

OOOOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUTSTANDING SERVICE , FOOD AND ATMOSPHERE!!! Excuse me if im all over the place but i have to brag about the people who made my experience amazing that had already made up my mind that i will DEFINITELY be coming back !!! Dont know not one staff from Adam and never been to this place , but tonight was my first time coming !!! Me and my guy friend came in tonight to celebrate our birthday month (proud Scorpios lol 🦂♏) and low and behold our waitress was celebrating her birthday 🎂 that day too as she also is a Scorpio!!! Her name is Jessica and i hugged her with a warm birthday hug as a she returned a warm hug aswell ! (You can just tell a genuine hug when you feel one) ❤️ I know a happy employee when i see one , Jessica was such a amazing waitress !! Very knowledgeable on the menu amd drinks , so friendly and attentive!! Engaging and sincere!!! Always checked on our table in a timely manner that felt natural and unrushed!!! I ordered this delightful sangria drink she recommended in the most detailed way (that i love ) and it was sooooo delicious!!! So delicious i asked Jessica of she could have the bartender Megan to please right down the recipe so i can make some for my homegirls back home ! Megan took time out of her busy shift to write down the recipe for such a delicious 😋🤤 cocktail she made me with LOVE !!! DRANK THE LOVE RIGHT TO THE BOTTOM EMPTY !! BRAVO 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾!!! Now for Max the tall handsome guy, boy did he catch my eye from the jump not sure what his position is i think manager!!! He was so polite and professional from the moment i walked in to the time i left !!! I love that he is so down to earth , open for laighter and naturally engaging with the customers !!! Dont laugh but i can totally see myself dating him hahahahah !!! Outstanding customer service with all staff amd tge beautiful blomde host that was very polite and professional and much of a fashionista , her outfit was very nice !!! Im very brutally honest when it comes to how food tastes and i dont let up with the TRUTH ! FOOD WAS DEEEEELISIOUS !! Even my guy date friend said his food was soooo good ! We did not get a chance to have dessert, but we will definitely be back for the dessert!!! I was told from beautiful Jessica that you guys have brunch on the weekends so i got super excited so im definitely looking forward to trying the brunch soon !! Tje host was nice enough to put me close to the door as i was on crutches , consideration goes a long way for me so thank you very very much !!!! Music 🎶🎶 and atmosphere was perfect, inviting and peaceful !!! Thank you for all of the wonderful experience with my first time coming !!! Me and my friend truly enjoyed ourselves and the wonderful, flavorful gourmet meals !! I will definitely be a returning customer and one who refers this place to others !!! EXCEPTIONAL FIRST TIME EXPERIENCE!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious food, excellenr service, my only gripe was the seating arrangement i was given on a reservation...directly infront of the front door/service desk on a cold rainy day. Made for an uncomfortable visit, i had to wear my motorcycle jacket just to stay warm.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Macaluso’s is hands-down one of the best dining experiences in Tacoma. The food is incredible! Every dish tastes fresh, homemade, and full of authentic Italian flavor. You can tell they put real care into their recipes, from the pasta to the sauces to the desserts.

The service is just as impressive. The staff is warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming without ever feeling rushed. Rachel was our server and was absolutely amazing.

If you’re looking for great Italian food, a cozy atmosphere, and top-tier service, Macaluso’s is absolutely a must-visit. I’ll definitely be coming back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My best friend and I met there for dinner. It was amazing! The warm lighting and the muffled noise from the kitchen was like donning my burgundy velvet jacket… just right. The food was delicious as well as the wine, but what I really want to talk about was the service. Taylor was our server and we were never left wanting, even though he didn’t hover. There was a cute curly haired kid with water and a sweet dark haired guy that grated cheese onto my halibut that was perfectly prepared. It’s a small, charming restaurant with great staff and delicious cuisine. I highly recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great restaurant, great food, we had a wonderful waiter who was also the son of the owner☺️ family business and cozy winter vibes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am writing to express my deep disappointment regarding my family’s recent experience at this restaurant. From the moment we arrived, we were met with an unpleasant odor reminiscent of unclean animal bedding, which created an uninviting atmosphere.

The quality of service was consistently poor. Several staff members were rude and dismissive throughout our visit. At one point, a server placed their hand directly into our water pitcher when retrieving it from the table, demonstrating a complete disregard for basic hygiene standards. The situation escalated when a member of the staff physically assaulted my brother-in-law, leaving him with a noticeable bruise. Later, our family was unjustly accused of attempting to leave without paying — an accusation that was both false and deeply humiliating.

The food itself was equally disappointing. It was excessively salty to the point of being nearly inedible, and several members of our party became ill afterward. The overall quality suggested poor preparation and handling practices.

Perhaps most distressing was the behavior of the hostess, who appeared to treat our family differently based on our race. This discriminatory conduct is unacceptable in any setting, particularly one that serves the public.

In summary, our experience at this establishment raised serious concerns about food safety, employee professionalism, and equitable treatment of customers. I strongly urge management to address these issues immediately to ensure that no other guests endure a similar experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

This food is the best in Tacoma. The service always amazing. My only complaint is there's often a wait bc it's THAT good!

Called for a reservation the same day for my 20th wedding anniversary—around 1 p.m. for a 5 p.m. dinner—and they were able to accommodate us! We were seated right away in a cozy, private corner spot. The service was amazing—Anna was our server and she was absolutely fantastic.

We started with a bottle of Sangiovese and the prosciutto arugula burrata appetizer. My wife had the Bolognese pasta, and we shared a half order of the squash gnocchi. I had the penne sausage and pancetta pasta—everything was outstanding.

We enjoyed a second bottle of the same wine, and to our surprise, the staff brought us complimentary glasses of Prosecco for a toast to our 20 years of marriage. That thoughtful touch really made the night special.

I cannot recommend this restaurant enough—for the food quality, service, ambiance, and overall flavor. As an Italian, it truly hits all the notes of a traditional family-style Italian restaurant, with the comforting flavors of your Nonna’s kitchen and the kind of service that’s rare to find these days.

I deeply regret not coming here sooner—they’ve been open since 2018, and had I known about the quality of their food and hospitality, I would have been a regular by now. I’ll definitely be back once or twice a month from now on after seeing their true colors tonight.

Thank you to the entire staff, service team, kitchen, and ownership for an amazing experience!

Thanks for making our 20 year anniversary so memorable Liam and Sarah Riley

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Macaluso's is top notch. The food was excellent and the service was superlative. If you want authentic Italian, this is the place. Two thumbs up!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Italian food in the area. Perfect atmosphere for a nice quiet dinner or weekend brunch. There was nowhere in the immediate area to have a good brunch. So if you are looking for a brunch spot, you won't be disappointed, props to the chef👏. I've had dinner here a few times and the dinner is always phenomenal so I wanted to try their brunch. For being a high-end restaurant I was pleasantly surprised with their brunch prices, and the food was incredible. The server was super friendly and attentive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food and customer service were terrific and great respectively! We'll be back again soon

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5