We ordered the Sicilian chicken salad and Hawaiian pizza for take out last week. The food was delicious and our four year old loved the pineapple slices on the Hawaiian. It is a bit pricey, but the quality is good and the large salad is easily enough for three people. Per serving, the price is quite reasonable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salads
James Marsh
Always good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natalie Rodgers
This is the second time within 6 months that we have found hair in our food. We’ve been loyal customers of Pagliacci over the years, however I question the food handling practices at this location in particular. We’ve never had this issue before and question ordering from them again. It’s disgusting and management at this location needs to address it.
Food: 1
William Zhang
PAGLIACCI used to be my fav pizza shop, I usually order pick-up but today I’m super disappointed!! Should pizza over $30 be like this?? Attaching 2 photos for same customized pizza, one is the order from last month and one I got today, ridiculous!! Basically gave me a cheese pizza this time!![Update] Reached out to the customer service, they’re responsive and responsible, addressed my concern very quickly and refunded me with a coupon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Ivy Malia
The place was very welcoming and chill, it's a lovely place if you want to just sit down and grab a slice or if you want to pick up a whole pizza to go.
Great pizza, friendly staff, strongly recommend. It’s a bit more expensive but it’s great pizza so it’s worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kenya Tate
Pagliacci has been my go to favorite since moving here! I used to eat in and never had a bad pizza, salad, pasta, or beer! My issue is with ordering out. I order online and wait to tip cash in the store. The last two times that i've ordered (last two months) my pizzas were tragically cut! I am not upset enough to stop eating here but I am aware enough to order my pizzas uncut from now on!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Al D.
Food is good. But ordering pizza should be easy. I should be able to order something on my way home from work to pick up without having to stop the car to use an app. How do you use the app if you're driving. Then I should not be coerced into paying a tip for an order I'm picking up at the counter. Overall, the pizza is good and better than most in the area but the experience is poor.
alvaro cervantes
I enjoy this place after a bike ride on Soaring Eagle park, their ginger beer and pizza with garlic, cherry tomatoes, and cheese is my favorite choice.
This is our go to pizza spot. Order is always correct & on time. We love the slice bar but often order the Brooklyn Bridge & it's delicious. Our son likes the Margherita. Amazing crust & fresh produce. Must try!
Great pizza. We love a crust that’s done a little more. Pagliacci seems to listen and fulfill our request.
Ana Mae F.
One word WOW! if I could eat Pagliacci pizza every day I would! The quality of the food is off the charts, and they use primarily fresh locally sourced ingredients. The service is spectacular, you can get a whole pizza within 15-20 minutes, the employees are absolutely WIG at their jobs and are masters at tossing out the dough. I love the fall decorations it makes for a nice ambiance, super clean and simple, but overall, will definitely continue to eat here, also TIP YOUR PAGLIACCI EMPLOYEES! They deserve it!
Gabriel Condrea
Been getting pizza here for quite a while. I wish they had the Lil Woody's year round, so if you get a chance, you better get it!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
LisaAnne H.
This review applies 2 both CapitolHill & Sammamish. My husband and I visited CapitolHill this past Saturday afternoon and then we visited Sammamish last nite (Tues) - 2 locations within 4 daze?!?! We ordered the exact same 3 pizzas (smalls) both times. Flawlessly identical! PAGLIACCI is a sleek-positively-vibed-well-oiled machine. We have lived in Snoqualmie for 5 years from SanDiego & we had been passing by the CapitolHill locale once a month on "salon day" @ Bowie which is a short stroll away. The staff treated us like rock stars knowing it was our maiden-voyage-visit. They have a coupla rotating specialty pizzas. We fell madly&deeply in love w/ the PEACHZA PRIMO: thinly sliced peaches/roasted pork loin/balsamic drizzle/arugula tossed in olive oil and sea salt. YUMMY!!! Also, best veggie pizza of our lives and perhaps best pepperoni of our lives. So many scattered locations (21) - seemed like both places had mostly regulars who engaged in spirited exchanges w/ staff as they awaited their full pies. Definitely set aside some time, this is not some "churn&burn" chain pizza. Also, eating everything freshly outta the brick oven in the dining room is my humble advice. There must B something unicorn-like going on w/ their breadsticks?!?! We R totally gonna give those breadsticks a whirl the next time I plan 2 create a massive Italian feast in my own kitchen. Salads looked substantial. Also available: calzones/pastas/cookies/gelato/etcetera. Bottled MexicanCoke&Sprite/OrangeFanta soda-pops sure make pizza taste even better plus root beer/flavored SanPellegrino/cream soda/ginger beer... Off-the-beaten-track beer&wine options. PizzaByTheSlice seems 2 fly outta the door. Pleeze click on their website and behold: about a billion types of pizza 4 y'all 2 choose from - really JUST 29 and that is a heckuva lot in my book. Lastly, this place ain't cheap. Grand example of: UGetWhatUPay4... BRAVO!!!
Ryan LaRue
one of the best pizzas ive ever had, it was delivered fast and hot
We ordered the Sicilian chicken salad and Hawaiian pizza for take out last week. The food was delicious and our four year old loved the pineapple slices on the Hawaiian. It is a bit pricey, but the quality is good and the large salad is easily enough for three people. Per serving, the price is quite reasonable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salads
Always good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the second time within 6 months that we have found hair in our food. We’ve been loyal customers of Pagliacci over the years, however I question the food handling practices at this location in particular. We’ve never had this issue before and question ordering from them again. It’s disgusting and management at this location needs to address it.
Food: 1
PAGLIACCI used to be my fav pizza shop, I usually order pick-up but today I’m super disappointed!! Should pizza over $30 be like this?? Attaching 2 photos for same customized pizza, one is the order from last month and one I got today, ridiculous!! Basically gave me a cheese pizza this time!![Update] Reached out to the customer service, they’re responsive and responsible, addressed my concern very quickly and refunded me with a coupon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
The place was very welcoming and chill, it's a lovely place if you want to just sit down and grab a slice or if you want to pick up a whole pizza to go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Primo, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Great pizza, friendly staff, strongly recommend. It’s a bit more expensive but it’s great pizza so it’s worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pagliacci has been my go to favorite since moving here! I used to eat in and never had a bad pizza, salad, pasta, or beer! My issue is with ordering out. I order online and wait to tip cash in the store. The last two times that i've ordered (last two months) my pizzas were tragically cut! I am not upset enough to stop eating here but I am aware enough to order my pizzas uncut from now on!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Food is good. But ordering pizza should be easy. I should be able to order something on my way home from work to pick up without having to stop the car to use an app. How do you use the app if you're driving. Then I should not be coerced into paying a tip for an order I'm picking up at the counter. Overall, the pizza is good and better than most in the area but the experience is poor.
I enjoy this place after a bike ride on Soaring Eagle park, their ginger beer and pizza with garlic, cherry tomatoes, and cheese is my favorite choice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Primo, Veggie Pizza with Artichoke Hearts, Margherita Pizza
This is our go to pizza spot. Order is always correct & on time. We love the slice bar but often order the Brooklyn Bridge & it's delicious. Our son likes the Margherita. Amazing crust & fresh produce. Must try!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza. We love a crust that’s done a little more. Pagliacci seems to listen and fulfill our request.
One word WOW! if I could eat Pagliacci pizza every day I would! The quality of the food is off the charts, and they use primarily fresh locally sourced ingredients. The service is spectacular, you can get a whole pizza within 15-20 minutes, the employees are absolutely WIG at their jobs and are masters at tossing out the dough. I love the fall decorations it makes for a nice ambiance, super clean and simple, but overall, will definitely continue to eat here, also TIP YOUR PAGLIACCI EMPLOYEES! They deserve it!
Been getting pizza here for quite a while. I wish they had the Lil Woody's year round, so if you get a chance, you better get it!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
This review applies 2 both CapitolHill & Sammamish. My husband and I visited CapitolHill this past Saturday afternoon and then we visited Sammamish last nite (Tues) - 2 locations within 4 daze?!?! We ordered the exact same 3 pizzas (smalls) both times. Flawlessly identical! PAGLIACCI is a sleek-positively-vibed-well-oiled machine. We have lived in Snoqualmie for 5 years from SanDiego & we had been passing by the CapitolHill locale once a month on "salon day" @ Bowie which is a short stroll away. The staff treated us like rock stars knowing it was our maiden-voyage-visit. They have a coupla rotating specialty pizzas. We fell madly&deeply in love w/ the PEACHZA PRIMO: thinly sliced peaches/roasted pork loin/balsamic drizzle/arugula tossed in olive oil and sea salt. YUMMY!!! Also, best veggie pizza of our lives and perhaps best pepperoni of our lives. So many scattered locations (21) - seemed like both places had mostly regulars who engaged in spirited exchanges w/ staff as they awaited their full pies. Definitely set aside some time, this is not some "churn&burn" chain pizza. Also, eating everything freshly outta the brick oven in the dining room is my humble advice. There must B something unicorn-like going on w/ their breadsticks?!?! We R totally gonna give those breadsticks a whirl the next time I plan 2 create a massive Italian feast in my own kitchen. Salads looked substantial. Also available: calzones/pastas/cookies/gelato/etcetera. Bottled MexicanCoke&Sprite/OrangeFanta soda-pops sure make pizza taste even better plus root beer/flavored SanPellegrino/cream soda/ginger beer... Off-the-beaten-track beer&wine options. PizzaByTheSlice seems 2 fly outta the door. Pleeze click on their website and behold: about a billion types of pizza 4 y'all 2 choose from - really JUST 29 and that is a heckuva lot in my book. Lastly, this place ain't cheap. Grand example of: UGetWhatUPay4... BRAVO!!!
one of the best pizzas ive ever had, it was delivered fast and hot