Magic's Pizza Shack

309 S 1st St, Selah
(509) 697-4441

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dave M

Pretty expensive pizza. Interior needs remodeling limited menu is pretty much pizza and salad.

Brent Nierman

We discovered this Pizza place by accident and we were pleasantly surprised. We love the thin crust and excellent pizza toppings. Their salad bar is also very good. We will be returning customers for a long time!

Micheal DeShong

Great place to have a group of people hang out! Awesome food, excellent service. I personally haven't had a bad experience!!

Lawrence Thornburg

They have breakfast now. Or just go in for the pizza and salad bar.

katie tucker

Like your old fashioned pizza place from when you were a kid lus they have a salad bar and the prices are good. Plenty of space to park and their dough tastes homemade. Nothing to complain about here.

Sarah Stevens

Love the salad bar.

Branden Seymour

Great pizza, good prices and really nice waitresses. Come here!

Lloyd Jensen

It's all good, I got broccoli soup and 1/2 BLT sandwich

brenda Sweet

Always friendly service..Always good food, and affordable!

Isaac Love

Good coffee poured well

Dewayne Avery

$14 for a saucer sized pizza & a mini bowl salad from the salad bar. At least they had pickled beets. Didn’t known tell my friend told men the area was so dark. Worst little pizza. Ate there before but won’t be back. I guess I shouldn’t complain. My friend paid. LU.

Janet Griffith

Pretty good salad bar except there weren't any hard cooked eggs this time. It's pretty much a hit and miss. Soup is pretty good. Parmesan bread sticks with Alfredo dipping sauce were really good. Good pizza and sweet tea. Enjoy their food and good prices.

Dave Stai

It was a slow day, so it was a great date night. We got to relax and talk and have great food. The salad bar was terrific, and the food was great. I took my date there and it was her first time. She wasn't let down. Thank you for such great service.

Lee J

Will start by saying their pizza is definitely carrying their restaurant! A little pricey, but worth it! Some of the best pizza crust I’ve ever had—and I’m hard to impress when it comes to pizza. However, the rest of the menu items I’ve tried have been severely lacking. Their pastas and chicken taste like frozen meals, salads are strangely subpar for a pizza establishment, cheesy bread tastes like they took some sandwich bread, sprinkled cheese on it, and threw it in a microwave. Breakfast is alright, but nothing to write home about. Breakfast pizza did grow on me as I ate it. Can have a much better breakfast—for much cheaper—at Denny’s. Service is so-so, at least not rude. Atmosphere can be cozy to those who like small-town restaurant vibes. Seriously, their pizza is absolutely carrying this review AND their store!

Charlena Houck

Great locally owned restaurant. The staff, food and atmosphere is really great. Family friendly and adding the breakfast menu is great addition!

Loading...