I wasn't gonna write anything, but after getting sick eating this, I can't refrain. I will cut the cook some slack, he was the only one there on a Friday night. The wings tasted like they were fried in old oil, after eating them I immediately felt nauseous, pizza and bread is okay. I don't think any of the ill feelings are from the pizza, but I must say I'm very disappointed, I had high hopes in trying this place out...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Mark Pigman
Edited 11-30-2025 I tried the pizza again, and the carry out order was great. Glad they are back to making good Pizza,
Original review from May 2025 I used to love this place and would always stop here on the way home from hiking at Mt Rainier. However, in the last couple months the Spanaway Pizza Time seems to have changed their dough, their sauce, and their cheese. The pizza is now mediocre.
Food: 5
влад забелин
It takes a really long time to do, it's disgusting and dirty.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amy Cantwell
I have been going through a pizza time phase! It's so yummy, most the time... I try to only come on the nights that Maraiah is there. She makes the best pizza! Any other time the pizza is too thick & doughy. She's always so happy and kind! Thank you Maraiah!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chelle S
Won't order from here again, service matters and atmosphere was zero
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jeremy Allen
Lots of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crystal Krier
I ordered from this place when I was given my pizza my pizza crust looked very uncooked ... when I called and spoke to the person who said she was the manager she said she remembered my pizza. And she said she should have put it back through the oven a 2nd time And it was her fault .... she said she'd refund my $$ that never happened. ... dont LIE and tell a customer you no you messed up the pizza and your gonna refund the $$ if you do not intend to do so .... horrible horrible service and customer service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
daniel robinson
Great service for a lady who was left by herself on a holiday. Said she also bartends on 6th Ave. Employer should do something nice for that lady. Labor day is a hard day to run a store by yourself
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan Place
DVD va cut cut
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tristin Hodges
Excellent pizza at the best prices!! Love this place a ton!
6/20/25 Update to My Review of Pizza Time Spanaway I want to update my review because Pizza Time made things right.
After the delivery issue I had, the manager actually called me personally to talk about what happened. He was professional, polite, and clearly wanted to fix the situation. He offered to remake my order whenever it was convenient for me, and we went ahead and picked it up today.
The pizza was great this time, and I even got a follow-up call afterward to make sure everything was okay.
You don’t get that kind of customer service very often anymore. I really appreciated the effort they made to reach out and take care of it. Mistakes happen — but they owned it, and that means a lot.
6/13/25 This isn’t just poor service — it’s a terrible business model.
I’ve had issues with delivery from Pizza Time Spanaway multiple times now, but this most recent experience sealed it for me. I ordered at 5:16 PM and was told it would arrive by 6:01 PM. When it still wasn’t here at 6:45 PM, I called the store. The girl who answered immediately told me they “can’t track deliveries” because they use DoorDash. Seriously? You don’t even know if my food left the building?
I had to ask her to check. She put me on hold, then came back to say the pizza was still sitting there, waiting for a DoorDash driver. An hour and a half after I ordered it. I asked if I could just pick it up — she said I’d need to cancel through DoorDash. I ordered through Pizza Time’s own website. How exactly am I supposed to cancel through a third party I didn’t order from?
She puts me on hold again to ask a manager to call DoorDash. Comes back and says the manager is driving and can’t help. They offer me a free item like that makes it okay and tell me a dasher has been assigned to my order.
My food finally arrived over an hour and a half late and was cold. That’s unacceptable.
If you can’t get your food out the door or manage your delivery system, you shouldn’t be taking online orders. Until they fix this broken setup, I won’t be ordering again — and I wouldn’t recommend anyone else does either.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keri Barron
This place is hands down amazing. I love walking in always being greeted with respect and honesty. Food is great. They do their best and when they make a mistake the own up and try to make it better. Thank you for helping me put food on my table when im to tired to cook. Thank you for being fast and efficient. Will continue to support this small business. Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tracy P
Friendly staff.. the boneless parm/garlic wing were down right nasty. We literally ate in them in the car in the parking lot and they were cold.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Steven Swindall
Absolutely the worst pizza I’ve ever had. 1/4 the pizza didn’t have any toppings. The crust I don’t know where they get it but it’s unbelievably no good. And they forgot to put sauce on the pizza never go there again. Too bad Spanaway just moved here. Never eat there again.
Food: 1
Peter Maroney
I don’t usually write reviews, but after my visit to Pizza Time, I had to share the experience — especially because of an employee named Chris who went above and beyond.
From the moment I walked in, the place had this perfect balance of local charm and upbeat energy. You could smell the fresh dough and garlic before even opening the door — that’s how you know it’s real.
I had a bunch of questions about the menu (I’m indecisive, okay?), and Chris walked me through every option without rushing me or making me feel like a burden. He even recommended a custom half-and-half combo I never would've thought of: garlic white sauce with grilled chicken and spinach on one side, and a classic pepperoni with hot honey drizzle on the other.
Game changer. The crust was the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the cheese was rich without being greasy, and the toppings tasted fresh — like actually chopped fresh, not out of a bag.
But what made it even better was the customer service. Chris checked in during the meal to make sure everything was perfect. He had this energy that made you feel like a regular even if it was your first time.
I left full, happy, and already planning my next trip back.
Thanks again, Chris — you turned a simple pizza night into a five-star experience. Highly recommend Pizza Time to anyone who loves great food and even better vibes.
I wasn't gonna write anything, but after getting sick eating this, I can't refrain. I will cut the cook some slack, he was the only one there on a Friday night. The wings tasted like they were fried in old oil, after eating them I immediately felt nauseous, pizza and bread is okay. I don't think any of the ill feelings are from the pizza, but I must say I'm very disappointed, I had high hopes in trying this place out...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Edited 11-30-2025
I tried the pizza again, and the carry out order was great. Glad they are back to making good Pizza,
Original review from May 2025
I used to love this place and would always stop here on the way home from hiking at Mt Rainier. However, in the last couple months the Spanaway Pizza Time seems to have changed their dough, their sauce, and their cheese. The pizza is now mediocre.
Food: 5
It takes a really long time to do, it's disgusting and dirty.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I have been going through a pizza time phase! It's so yummy, most the time...
I try to only come on the nights that Maraiah is there. She makes the best pizza!
Any other time the pizza is too thick & doughy.
She's always so happy and kind!
Thank you Maraiah!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Won't order from here again, service matters and atmosphere was zero
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Lots of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered from this place when I was given my pizza my pizza crust looked very uncooked ... when I called and spoke to the person who said she was the manager she said she remembered my pizza. And she said she should have put it back through the oven a 2nd time And it was her fault .... she said she'd refund my $$ that never happened. ... dont LIE and tell a customer you no you messed up the pizza and your gonna refund the $$ if you do not intend to do so .... horrible horrible service and customer service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great service for a lady who was left by herself on a holiday. Said she also bartends on 6th Ave. Employer should do something nice for that lady. Labor day is a hard day to run a store by yourself
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DVD va cut cut
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Excellent pizza at the best prices!! Love this place a ton!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
6/20/25
Update to My Review of Pizza Time Spanaway
I want to update my review because Pizza Time made things right.
After the delivery issue I had, the manager actually called me personally to talk about what happened. He was professional, polite, and clearly wanted to fix the situation. He offered to remake my order whenever it was convenient for me, and we went ahead and picked it up today.
The pizza was great this time, and I even got a follow-up call afterward to make sure everything was okay.
You don’t get that kind of customer service very often anymore. I really appreciated the effort they made to reach out and take care of it. Mistakes happen — but they owned it, and that means a lot.
6/13/25 This isn’t just poor service — it’s a terrible business model.
I’ve had issues with delivery from Pizza Time Spanaway multiple times now, but this most recent experience sealed it for me. I ordered at 5:16 PM and was told it would arrive by 6:01 PM. When it still wasn’t here at 6:45 PM, I called the store. The girl who answered immediately told me they “can’t track deliveries” because they use DoorDash. Seriously? You don’t even know if my food left the building?
I had to ask her to check. She put me on hold, then came back to say the pizza was still sitting there, waiting for a DoorDash driver. An hour and a half after I ordered it. I asked if I could just pick it up — she said I’d need to cancel through DoorDash. I ordered through Pizza Time’s own website. How exactly am I supposed to cancel through a third party I didn’t order from?
She puts me on hold again to ask a manager to call DoorDash. Comes back and says the manager is driving and can’t help. They offer me a free item like that makes it okay and tell me a dasher has been assigned to my order.
My food finally arrived over an hour and a half late and was cold. That’s unacceptable.
If you can’t get your food out the door or manage your delivery system, you shouldn’t be taking online orders. Until they fix this broken setup, I won’t be ordering again — and I wouldn’t recommend anyone else does either.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is hands down amazing. I love walking in always being greeted with respect and honesty. Food is great. They do their best and when they make a mistake the own up and try to make it better. Thank you for helping me put food on my table when im to tired to cook. Thank you for being fast and efficient. Will continue to support this small business. Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly staff.. the boneless parm/garlic wing were down right nasty. We literally ate in them in the car in the parking lot and they were cold.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Absolutely the worst pizza I’ve ever had. 1/4 the pizza didn’t have any toppings. The crust I don’t know where they get it but it’s unbelievably no good. And they forgot to put sauce on the pizza never go there again. Too bad Spanaway just moved here. Never eat there again.
Food: 1
I don’t usually write reviews, but after my visit to Pizza Time, I had to share the experience — especially because of an employee named Chris who went above and beyond.
From the moment I walked in, the place had this perfect balance of local charm and upbeat energy. You could smell the fresh dough and garlic before even opening the door — that’s how you know it’s real.
I had a bunch of questions about the menu (I’m indecisive, okay?), and Chris walked me through every option without rushing me or making me feel like a burden. He even recommended a custom half-and-half combo I never would've thought of: garlic white sauce with grilled chicken and spinach on one side, and a classic pepperoni with hot honey drizzle on the other.
Game changer. The crust was the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the cheese was rich without being greasy, and the toppings tasted fresh — like actually chopped fresh, not out of a bag.
But what made it even better was the customer service. Chris checked in during the meal to make sure everything was perfect. He had this energy that made you feel like a regular even if it was your first time.
I left full, happy, and already planning my next trip back.
Thanks again, Chris — you turned a simple pizza night into a five-star experience. Highly recommend Pizza Time to anyone who loves great food and even better vibes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...