Gallagher's Pizza - East Green Bay

I have a favorite sandwich I ordered every weekend “authentic cheese sandwich” , the last time I ordered this sandwich I look forward to eating and the sandwich beef was so fatty that I had to pull the sandwich to take a bite, I called and the manager sent me a new order and it was the same of the first sandwich

Enjoyed the buffet. Pizza, chicken wings, pasta, salad, soup and desserts.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Best pizza of the pizza options and of other Gallagher's options in the area. They use lots of quality cheese but not too greasy. The bread is quality (both hand tossed and thin) and cooked perfectly, and the sauce is flavorful and thicker. The ingredients are high quality and have good selection (a quality pizza place must offer the authentic italian topping of anchovies - even if you don't order them). When the building was at capacity, the food was made and brought out timely and hot. Price is not cheap, but honestly, it is worth the prices. Finally, the staff are friendly and fairly good at coming around with refills.
Observed they don't have any flavorings on the crust, though, it doesn't need it. I would make/ order some garlic butter sauce to dip hand tossed cust into. They also have rootbeer in cold mugs with free refills, very classy and tasty. Amazed that the kids menu is only $5!
Unfortunately, all Gallagher's Pizza google maps locations reuse images, making it difficult to know which location this is. It is the only one with parking behind it and next to Zambaldi Beer brewery.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We got the Monster pizza, and it was a mess. The sauce and toppings were on top of the cheese and all fell off when you picked up a slice.
Once the pizza was dropped off, we never seen our server again. We had to ask a different server for a box and the bill.
The restaurant was loud. The phone was constantly ringing and could hear it in the seating area. The crowd noise was very loud as well.
Very sad, I have always loved this restaurant.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We ordered delivery from Gallagher’s last night, excited to showcase this highly recommended Green Bay pizza to our cousins visiting from out of state — but it ended up being a huge letdown. Our order was scheduled for 8:00 PM delivery but arrived 30 minutes early. Normally, that wouldn’t be an issue, except we timed it for when our guests were expected to arrive.

The delivery driver was very kind, but as soon as she handed me the pizzas, I noticed one box felt wet and soggy. Remembering a less-than-great delivery experience we’d had a few years back, we checked the pizzas right away. Unfortunately, the bottom of one was completely soggy, as if it had absorbed moisture from the other box — it was like eating wet bread.

Sadly, it seems Green Bay still lacks a solid pizza standard. This just didn’t meet ours. For $65 (two 16” pizzas with delivery fee and tip), it simply wasn’t worth it. Sorry, Gallagher’s — we wanted to love it, but this was another disappointment.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

We are vegetarian & ordered Mediterranean thin crust pizza . It was delicious , very crisp crust .
Our server was Kelly,very happy joyful person to serve our food. Food cooked & served with a happy heart means a lot for our health.😊

Kelly was a good server

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food

Food: 5

Service: 5

The restaurant is a little gem in town. We loved everything we ordered. You can make your own calzone. I chose chicken, bacon, garlic and alfredo sauce. It was so amazing the crust is wonderful!
The Italian sandwich with their pasta salad is a must try so tasty!
We were from out of town but if we lived here it definitely would be our go to place.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went in for the buffet today. Everything was fresh and delicious. Service was perfect. Will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love this place for watching the Brewers and having a beer.
Say hi to Kelly. She is always a blast to talk to.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelly is THE BOMB!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My elder friend and I ate here last week and had Jazlynn as our waitress. Service was great as well their gyros and turtle pie. 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went there on Friday and had the buffet. I had to pick thru 3 or 4 plates before finding a clean one. The pizza on the buffet was old and cold and looked mostly disgusting. Waited for them to bring out fresh ones, but that never happened. Service was slow and had to wait for drink refills and I had to stand at the bar for about 10 minutes to pay our bill. There are much better places to eat and I would not recommend this place.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Great experience! Good is really good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pan Pizza, Cheese Curds