On The Square LLC (formerly Hartman's Variety)

121 Alfred St, Athens
(715) 257-7474

Recent Reviews

Cora Karpinski - Zilly

I have eaten there several times and each time we had great service and even better food! Try it …. Bet you’ll like it also!

Becky Czarnezki

Love this family restaurant ❤️ great people and authentic Mexican

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim Arquette

Awesome place. Was quiet when we were there. Food was fresh, tasty and served with a smile. Would definitely go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul Semo

Stopped a group of 6 on a cold day and being on motorcycle was looking to warm up for a bit. That wasn't happening was pretty chilly in side. Food took awhile to get and we were the only ones in there. The steak torta was pretty good.

Chris Field

In December 2018 these people used old catering food they already had. The staff said we didnt have enough containers to take food home (they hid our own containers) and took home food.I did complain. They said sorry and no they never refunded any money.Steer clear from their catering. Yes they will wow you with testing their food. However, once they cater... that food is absolutely NOT what you tasted. We got the ham and chicken. Chicken was soggy. Ham was grey. No one was eating it. Never have been back and no I do not recommend unless they know you and they actually care about taking care of food right and not giving you someone else's leftovers.I come from a long line of cooks, bakers and confectionaries and I can do most of all.... I was told I shouldnt do my own wedding food. Instead me and my husband and my family and most guests did not eat their food. It was a severe waste of money.

Brook Wesle

Never open. Confusing signage. I now have an expired gift certificate. A lot of people work until 5 by the time you get there closed. Stopped in again today for lunch. Thought it would be safe. Closed. Not trying anymore. Not worth the gas. Stopped once. People inside. Closed for a private event.

Andrea Peche

Loved the food and the staff was great.

Dawn Marie

I used to love this place, but since picking up more business and catering I feel like they have fallen off. The chips are always burned anymore when I order and the steak is VERY greasy and chewy. My s/o has also noticed the decline in quality. We ordered from another place today and he was so excited about how good the chips were and how non runny the queso was. I gave this 4 stars before, now, two, maybe three.

Seth Johnson

Excellent food! Laid-back country atmosphere with a simple menu

Donna Vonheeder

LOVE this place! The food is good, authentic Mexican. I cannot say enough good things about the tacos and my husband loves the specials. Best place to eat in town. Definitely give two thumbs up and reccomend!

Corrine Koenig

Amazing authentic food made fresh and from scratch. I highly recommend eating here. Relaxing and fun atmosphere with a very friendly and professional staff. And you won't leave hungry. Very big portions and plenty to choose from.

Linda H

Great food!

G Wendland

Nice restaurant, very clean. Wait staff was friendly and attentive.

Brian Belsky

Good food and nice people. Fairly limited menu, but authentic. Will be back.

Curtis Balz

Best pizza and chicken. Great staff working there.

Load More

On The Square LLC (formerly Hartman's Variety)

121 Alfred St, Athens, WI 54411
(715) 257-7474