Very nice place to visit. Food was great. They're very friendly
Ryan Thiel
Excellent fish fry. Stopped in for the first time on a whim. Very impressed. Great service!
cowcat33
Food was good was a tad dark inside but not to where you couldn't see... has very strange hours
Margaret Demski
Great experience and Pizza. Good drinks also! Lots of friendly people!
Betz WithAZ
Must have cheesy bread! Very nice little place, nice looking restaurant/ bar area, friendly and accommodating owner.( will let it slide that he's a Lions fan since his wife is a Packer fan.)
Heidi Lenz
Owner and staff are very friendly. The fish fry and BBQ ribs are amazing.
Michelle Knox
Great fish fry - always hot and fresh! Came in to get fish tonight and saw their pizza - looked amazing!!! We’re going to have to try that too!
Jessica Wenzel
We love Randy’s pizza! Grandpa grumpys cheese sticks are my kids favorite, and I think we’ve tried every pizza and calzone and we keep going back!
Rey G
This place always delivers. They serve excellent dishes for fair rates, there is no waiting time even when the place is loaded.
Rebecca Bader
The best fish fry in town. I got the lightly beer breaded bluegill with fries. It was truly lightly breaded, seasoned so well no salt or pepper was needed. They were out of baked potatoes and cheesey hashbrowns but we didn't get there until 7:30, so that's on us. I ended up with fries and they were really good. They seemed to be seasoned with a sour cream and onion seasoning. My husband got the seafood platter with the german potato salad. It was amazing. The seafood was done perfect. The potato salad was the best I've ever had (I don't like german potato salad). You get coleslaw and marble rye with onion. The bread is the softest bread I've ever had. The staff was very friendly. I highly recommend trying them out.
Pizza was pretty decent. Very smoky from the kitchen. Owner very nice, wait staff needs work.
Kristine Hill
My review: Don't waste your time or money. Took an hour and half for frozen chicken strips, a pizza and a hamburger. He told me when I asked for my bill that it's faster to order pizza cause everything else has to be made individually. ??? Uh ya, its a MENU ??? If u just want to serve pizza, then don't out anything else on the menu.My daughter's review: Maybe it was an entirely off night that we had come in to order our food. We seated ourselves. However, I have never once left a review, but after experience my family and I encountered dining at this establishment I felt the need to leave one. It was by far the worst service I have ever literally endured. There were only a few others there. From whom I could tell were close relatives as they occasionally got up from their bar stool to go behind the bar and help themselves to their next drink. Our server was polite, but was not very helpful in terms of actually serving us. There was a lot of guidance needed on our part in order for us to not only order, but to actually receive our food, and repeatedly ask for more to drink. Randy was an exceptional business owner. All sarcasm aside. We found him extremely rude and impersonable. While ordering with the waitress he told us we should order pizza. Even though only one of us planned to order that item. Later on I overheard him telling another group of people that he can make pizzas faster than he can send out a burger. So, we should order pizza essentially because it is easier for him. I would suggest omitting food from a menu if one is simply too lazy to cook it. Upon adding up our bill stated the same thing to the individual paying that 'because we ordered separate items (all food was on the same bill) that it has to be made and added up individually and will take him longer'. Further inconveniencing him. In addition, our food took over 30 mins to be incorrectly delivered to us. We never took our leftovers because we could not stand another minute of the inside especially with the amount of smoke burning our eyes from the kitchen. Im sure he will be happy to hear that none of us will EVER step food in his establishment again.
Brett Schroeder
Best pizza and calzones around overall excellent food and prices
Gina Phillips
we'd like to try Randy's fish fry and other food, but we liked the pizza so much that we keep going back to that! worth a drive out from Appleton. looking forward to when we can go back inside (after covid) and chat with Randy over a beer while we wait for our pizza
Kim Stolpa
went in and sat down with my family. we waited about 5 minutes and someone asked if we have been helped and I said no. another 10 minutes go by and no one came to our table. another group of 3 or 4 people came in and sat 2 tables away from us and not even 2 minutes after sitting down the waitress went right to their table! my husband tried getting the waitresses attention saying "excuse me miss" but she ignored him and walked away. we got up and left. terrible customer service
Very nice place to visit. Food was great. They're very friendly
Excellent fish fry. Stopped in for the first time on a whim. Very impressed. Great service!
Food was good was a tad dark inside but not to where you couldn't see... has very strange hours
Great experience and Pizza. Good drinks also! Lots of friendly people!
Must have cheesy bread! Very nice little place, nice looking restaurant/ bar area, friendly and accommodating owner.( will let it slide that he's a Lions fan since his wife is a Packer fan.)
Owner and staff are very friendly. The fish fry and BBQ ribs are amazing.
Great fish fry - always hot and fresh! Came in to get fish tonight and saw their pizza - looked amazing!!! We’re going to have to try that too!
We love Randy’s pizza! Grandpa grumpys cheese sticks are my kids favorite, and I think we’ve tried every pizza and calzone and we keep going back!
This place always delivers. They serve excellent dishes for fair rates, there is no waiting time even when the place is loaded.
The best fish fry in town. I got the lightly beer breaded bluegill with fries. It was truly lightly breaded, seasoned so well no salt or pepper was needed. They were out of baked potatoes and cheesey hashbrowns but we didn't get there until 7:30, so that's on us. I ended up with fries and they were really good. They seemed to be seasoned with a sour cream and onion seasoning. My husband got the seafood platter with the german potato salad. It was amazing. The seafood was done perfect. The potato salad was the best I've ever had (I don't like german potato salad). You get coleslaw and marble rye with onion. The bread is the softest bread I've ever had. The staff was very friendly. I highly recommend trying them out.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was pretty decent. Very smoky from the kitchen. Owner very nice, wait staff needs work.
My review: Don't waste your time or money. Took an hour and half for frozen chicken strips, a pizza and a hamburger. He told me when I asked for my bill that it's faster to order pizza cause everything else has to be made individually. ??? Uh ya, its a MENU ??? If u just want to serve pizza, then don't out anything else on the menu.My daughter's review: Maybe it was an entirely off night that we had come in to order our food. We seated ourselves. However, I have never once left a review, but after experience my family and I encountered dining at this establishment I felt the need to leave one. It was by far the worst service I have ever literally endured. There were only a few others there. From whom I could tell were close relatives as they occasionally got up from their bar stool to go behind the bar and help themselves to their next drink. Our server was polite, but was not very helpful in terms of actually serving us. There was a lot of guidance needed on our part in order for us to not only order, but to actually receive our food, and repeatedly ask for more to drink. Randy was an exceptional business owner. All sarcasm aside. We found him extremely rude and impersonable. While ordering with the waitress he told us we should order pizza. Even though only one of us planned to order that item. Later on I overheard him telling another group of people that he can make pizzas faster than he can send out a burger. So, we should order pizza essentially because it is easier for him. I would suggest omitting food from a menu if one is simply too lazy to cook it. Upon adding up our bill stated the same thing to the individual paying that 'because we ordered separate items (all food was on the same bill) that it has to be made and added up individually and will take him longer'. Further inconveniencing him. In addition, our food took over 30 mins to be incorrectly delivered to us. We never took our leftovers because we could not stand another minute of the inside especially with the amount of smoke burning our eyes from the kitchen. Im sure he will be happy to hear that none of us will EVER step food in his establishment again.
Best pizza and calzones around overall excellent food and prices
we'd like to try Randy's fish fry and other food, but we liked the pizza so much that we keep going back to that! worth a drive out from Appleton. looking forward to when we can go back inside (after covid) and chat with Randy over a beer while we wait for our pizza
went in and sat down with my family. we waited about 5 minutes and someone asked if we have been helped and I said no. another 10 minutes go by and no one came to our table. another group of 3 or 4 people came in and sat 2 tables away from us and not even 2 minutes after sitting down the waitress went right to their table! my husband tried getting the waitresses attention saying "excuse me miss" but she ignored him and walked away. we got up and left. terrible customer service