Everly's Ice Cream

3108 6 Mile Rd, Caledonia
(262) 456-2348

Recent Reviews

Sort by
mike soeth

Very friendly owners. Can't remember the name of the treat that I had but it was awesome.

Justin kumorkiewicz

Super friendly and kind. This place is a community gem that we all need to support as they give so much back. The community events and outreach they do is so great. They offer food options for everyone’s taste. It does get pretty busy sometimes so make sure you’re not in a hurry but it’s always worth the wait.

Cliff Beyer

Super cozy little place. Everything is impossibly good. If you have a sweet tooth you'd be hard pressed to find something on the menu you don't like. I've heard a few complaints about their prices but respectfully I feel like those people are comparing the prices to 10 years ago. With all the ingredients/products being high quality and the fact that they take everything to the next level I feel like the prices are fair. My two favorites are the caramel apple cookies, and cinnamon muffins. If your going to Cliffside park for a game you gotta stop here afterwards. Sprinkles are for winners!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream, Ice Cream Pints to Go, Coffee Flight

Damian Valentine

Great Experience, six of us stopped in and had a Great Time!! Fast Service, Smiles all around and everything made fresh. Will comeback again!!!!

Amanda

Love the staff, we love coming by for ice cream

Michael M

Great shakes and sundaes. Great service

Taj Lane

The most delicious ice cream thing I've ever had and the only ice cream that doesn't give me a headache and make me feel like crap after I eat it, so I'm guessing that's because it's better quality than other places.

tammy johnson

Small but good

Adam Morris

Love the vibe and the treats!

Joanna Sarrett

The Big Muddie ice cream was delicious! Dark chocolate, brownie bits, and caramel swirl..The prices are very affordable too. It was a pleasure to support this local gem.

Peter Ramon

I used to like this place. But the selection of ice cream has become boring.

David Lessard

Alway have great customer service and friendly staff working there always a pleasure stopping there

Christine Rivers

This is a wonderful place to enjoy a delicious treat. They offer cookies, ice cream, coffee, ice cream cakes, and donuts, with dairy-free and gluten-free options available. The pictured treat also supported Veterans Outreach of Wisconsin.

Danny Corcoran

They have great ice cream treats! My wife is allergic to gluten and they have GF cones! Highly recommended!!!

Kelly Taylor

Great place, wonderful service! And great ice cream, we will be back. Big sundae for 6.00 great value. Flavor of the month was wonderful ( banana cream pie)

Loading...