Fiddleheads Coffee Cedarburg

This place was VERY busy when we walked in, we had to wait for a while to get my drink. The ladies, however, were friendly and efficient. Considering how busy it was, and figuring this must be a really great place to get coffee, I was hoping the Pumpkin cheesecake latte was going to be outstanding; it was mediocre. It was not nearly as flavorful as I thought it was going to be. I could taste the oat milk more than anything else.

A word of caution to anyone who is not from this town, like myself; if you don't like small, intimate spaces, do not sit inside, especially if it's busy. It's a cramped place. Cute but small.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

My family and I a party of 7 walked in around 6:30 pm to grab some hot drinks and bagels. Everything went smooth until my husband poured sugar into his cup, however the sugar jar cover was loose and all sugar went inside his cup splashing him with hot coffee and also lots of sugar fell on the area mat. The girl behind the desk who took our order was constantly laughing as she found the scene hilarious. We got another replacement and sat inside next to the register area. The ight in front of our faces they kept laughing while looking at us and talking about us. Mind you, this was 3 steps away from us. I walked up to one of them and asked her what was so funny! I asked if she found it he situation funny as my husband burned his hand with their sugar jar being opened and she said “YES, it was funny!” And “We don’t know how to clean the sugar off the mat because we don’t have a vacuum!” This was so upsetting to me. I would never return. That was pure ignorance, rude and quite frankly she was very lucky I was there with my senior parents otherwise she would’ve been very disrespected! 10/7/25

Service: 1

Great BLAT and really fresh, crunchy, salad.

The girls working here are always super kind, coffee and food is always amazing and comes out fast. Would definitely recommend the iced French vanilla latte!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is a cute and cozy coffee shop in downtown Cedarberg. Even though it's cozy, there's plenty of indoor and outdoor seating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always good coffee and friendly people.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great coffee. I didn't sample any food, but the muffins others were getting looked delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Can someone please explain to me where the value is in a $14 sandwich that has 3 slices of turkey on it? When is this price gouging going to stop? The insanity of this country has reached a breaking point.

Ordered a cold brew here today and the girl at the register charged me 85 cents extra just to swap out one of the syrups for sugar free. Why? One drink was over 8 dollars. This is insane. Never coming back.

It was a discovery, everything was very rich. Very good attention from the staff, very friendly and patient. I’ll come back to taste the local desserts.

The staff is so accommodating and friendly, and the drinks are addictive!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The staff were so kind and the lattes tasted great and were the perfect temperature. Will definitely visit again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely love the vibe of this cafe! SO cute, great customer service and delicious drinks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

(August 2024) The food and service were great, but the staff ripped me off afterwards. I signed the credit card receipt for $16.67 and tipped cash. When I received my credit card statement at the end of the month, my card was charged $20.62. Shame on the employee who did this. I'm never coming back.

EDIT: Upon reading the owner’s response, I too am disappointed to report this episode. I think the owner's “belief of an issue with my CC” is wrong – of the 100+ transactions on my credit card statement that month, including 18 in the Cedarburg area, only two didn’t match the receipt (here and Mequon Pizza). And I would never seek a refund or credit or a handout or a gift certificate.

I was hoping the owner would explain why the amount charged to my credit card was higher than the amount on my receipt, but no sufficient explanation was given in the response.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was looking for a quiet place to work recently and happily settled into a little table in a shady spot in the courtyard here with a matcha lemonade and pastry - perfection!

Dietary restrictions: There were a few baked good options made without wheat, not specifically labeled as gluten free, but I enjoyed a scrumptious rhubarb crumble bar with oat flour and had no reaction.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5