From Scratch Catering
N56w6287 Center St, Cedarburg
(262) 618-4661
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
We truly enjoy working with From Scratch and are grateful to have them as a preferred caterer at our venue. Their team is professional, reliable and consistently delivers great food and service. Our couples love them - and so do we!
We had From Scratch cater our wedding in November, and everything was SO GOOD. Their approach to building a custom menu for every event was really exciting to me, and it was clear at our tasting how much love and attention went into the selection. Our coordinator, Emmie, made even an aggressively Type A bride like me feel at ease on the day, which was especially important for the caterer, considering we had several guests with severe allergies. Our venue coordinator also commented that she had never seen a team set up so quickly and work so well together, so that was another plus.
The food was just as good as it had been in our tasting. We selected the tenderloin baguette, meatballs and pear crostini for our appetizers; breaded chicken, bacon wrapped pork, wild rice and carrots for the entree; and a mac-and-cheese bar for late night. We received so many compliments all night - definitely exceeded basic wedding food, and I'm pretty sure a few guests showed up just for the mac and cheese lol.
One super nitpicky note is that the turnaround window from the final invoice being issued to being due is a little tight. I don't know if there's much of a way around this with final numbers only being solidified a few weeks before the event (and even if there was, I would still give them 5 stars), but it is something to be aware of in case you have to transfer some funds, like I did.
Overall, I would absolutely recommend! The food was memorable in the best possible way, and I know I'll be getting compliments for years to come.
We had From Scratch cater our wedding on 10/11/25. They did charcuterie for our cocktail hour, our main dinner, and they made my husband and I’s cutting cake. Everything was set up so beautifully and was so delicious! Every single person enjoyed the food and so many asked who did our catering! Their garlic smashed potatoes and white wine chicken were some of our favorites. We would recommendation From Scratch to anyone looking for a caterer for any event! They were so easy to work with, had great communication, and made sure my husband and I were able to try everything despite being so busy on our wedding day!
The staff is wonderful and the food is to die for!! The pies are also a fun offering that guests enjoyed. As a Wedding Planner I definitely recommend them!!
My husband and I like to think of ourselves as self-certified foodies, so early on in our wedding planning process, food was ranked at the very top of our priority list. We researched the required caterers for our venue and came across From Scratch, who came highly recommended by a close friend's sister.
From the moment we reached out, we were met with exceptional service, including timely communication, genuine support, and incredibly honest, transparent feedback. This transparency ultimately made our decision easy. When we attended our tasting last December, our choice was completely validated. Every single bite was incredible, especially when paired with their signature almond iced tea—it was truly magic! We couldn't stop raving about the food leading up to the wedding day, and we were so excited for our friends and family to finally experience the hype.
On the day itself, From Scratch absolutely delivered. All night, and even in the coming weeks, people have been reaching out to tell us it was the best wedding food they have ever had. From Scratch genuinely raised the bar on what it means to serve high-quality, memorable food to your closest friends and family.
Beyond the meal, you could truly feel and see the passion the team invests into their craft. Coming from a big family that bonds over cooking and shared meals, the atmosphere they created felt like a wonderful, communal family dinner.
The team also did a good job navigating the inevitable small hiccups that pop up throughout the night and helping to fix the situation quickly. (Our only small piece of advice for the future is to keep the bride and groom shielded from these minor issues, but we appreciated their commitment to helping resolve them!)
Thank you so much to From Scratch for being a part of our special day. We cannot recommend you enough for all catering needs!
We used From Scratch for our wedding and WOW. We had so many people tell us it was the best wedding food they have ever had. The team there was so great to us. Flexible. Communicative. Made sure we were taken care of. And even did a little something special for my daughter. I love that they grow a lot of their ingredients and source from local farmers. Couldn’t recommend this team enough.
Writing this review as I was a guest at a wedding that was catered by From Scratch and WOW - the food was SO good. Beyond exceeded any buffet I had ever been to. Everything was delicious and fresh. Probably the best wedding food I have ever eaten. Staff was nice and went above and beyond to help my niece who is a very picky eater as well. Highly recommend for any and all of your events needing catering services!
From Scratch Catering catered our wedding this past weekend and I have not gone a day this week without a guest commenting on how good the food was. The food was fresh, well curated, and delicious - a real crowd pleaser. Every employee was attentive and professional- you won’t regret hiring From Scratch Catering for your event!
I would hands down recommend From Scratch as your wedding caterer! They were amazing to work with, communicated well and went above and beyond for my husband and I on our wedding day. The food was absolutely delicious, too, which you can't always say when you go to a wedding!! We did a pasta bar with a pre-set Cesar salad and all of our guests loved it. The meatballs are incredible, I'm still thinking about them!! I cannot thank them enough and you will not be disappointed if you choose From Scratch.
Having the opportunity to enjoy food of such great quality is beyond any catering experience I’ve had. From the appetizers, main course and the delicious pies, I was in total awe! A special shoutout for the amazing apple pie! From Scratch Catering, you are superstars!
Restaurantji Recommends
We have used From Scratch Catering for several of our events - big and small - and have always been impressed! The staff is amazing: upbeat, attentive and professional. The food is awesome: so delicious, a great variety and clearly made with love! The presentation is spectacular: beautifully displayed, professionally delivered and no detail is missed. We highly recommend From Scratch for your next catering event!
I recently coordinated a wedding where Addie and her team at From Scratch Catering catered the dinner for our client's wedding. Leading up to the wedding, Addie was proactive in her communication and was incredibly helpful during our final meeting together where we reviewed the meal choices, linens, and tableware.
The day of the wedding, Addie's sister Emmie led the on-site team. She was incredibly sweet and helpful to the bride & groom while managing the front of house, and kept her team on track in the kitchen. Emmie went out of her way to be helpful to me personally when I was in need. The ceremony was outside and it had rained minutes before guests were supposed to take their seats. The venue manager had left the premises and we had no access to towels to wipe down the chairs. Emmie grabbed some from the back that she had brought and personally helped me wipe down every chair so we could keep the ceremony on schedule. This is just one example of how the From Scratch team went above and beyond.
P.S. Their food is also fantastic (as that's what they're known for!). Their lasagna (with mini meatballs in it?!?!) was DELICIOUS and the wedding party raved about the entire dinner.
As a wedding planner, I'm always looking for catering teams that are reliable, professional, and deliver an unforgettable experience. From Scratch Catering exceeded all expectations! They created a beautiful buffet that not only looked tunning but tasted incredible. Every dish was thoughtfully prepared, and guests kept coming back for seconds. The team was punctual, friendly, and so easy to work with. I truly appreciated their attention to detail and how smoothly they coordinated with the rest of the vendors. I'll definitely be recommending From Scratch Catering to future couples.
Simply the best! The staff, the food, attention to detail top notch. Highly recommend.
When a friend lost her husband suddenly, I wanted to give her something useful, yet thoughtful. Knowing grieving people are not thinking about food, I decided to look for someplace that would deliver food to her home for a few days at a cost I could afford. So I decided on the amount of $$ I could spend and started looking. Eventually I chose From Scratch Catering. I explained what I wanted and worked out a plan. My friend had some days of excellent food and was very happy with the staff.
Loading...