I had the fish fry it was okay a bit greasy. The bartender was very friendly drinks were a good pour and fairly reasonable. I thought they menu was fairly limited in selection for an Italian restaurant Will definitely go back to try something Italian
Tom Trush
Great happy hour and good.
Chris Paler
Wonderful food choices and outstanding waitress.
Karen Cameron
Stopped for a drink. Bartender was very friendly. He made a new drink he called Almond Joy martini we tried and it was delicious!
Karl Schefft
Great food.
Luke Nydam
Everything was sugary, the pasta, French onion soup, marinara. The only thing I truly enjoyed were the Rueben rolls. Also maybe it’s just me, but what is the point of bread crumbing if it’s just going be a soggy undercooked mess. The bread was amazing just took a long time to get to table. Bottom line not worth returning, too sweet no complexity, poorly cooked meats. I end my review “Was that chicken or veal.”
Seth Hofstad
Have enjoyed Galioto's on several occasions and had a wonderful experience each one. I recommend the tenderloin.
Brian Kiehnau
Nice Saturday night visit. Place was a blast from the past, no on line reservation system, call and leave a message and they use pencil and paper. They were a little busy and our server seemed busy so the meal moved slow which was fine we were in no rush. We both ordered the Filet and it tasted good but it was weird, it looked like it had been cooked and then seared, the color was very even all the way through, it was a lot like slow cooked prime rib. The meals are a complete package, soup or salad, bread, veg and potato. and its a lot to eat, most people had left overs in to go clam shells. The side salad was good but its what you would have gotten at a supper club 30 years ago less the iceberg lettuce. The prices were extremely reasonable, dinner for 2 was $133, including 2 beers, 1 glass of wine, one after dinner drink and an up grade to French onion soup. We had an expired gift certificate which they graciously accepted.
Linda Wilke
This is a great little place to check out! If you enjoy that old world feel when you walk in the door and a friendly staff that always make you feel like family this is your kind of restaurant. We keep coming back for more - a nice selection of great food, not a huge menu but I like knowing that what I'm getting is fresh and made to order. Anthony is fantastic, always willing to make sure we have a wonderful experience. Make sure you ask for him! We have invited friends and family to join us and we've never been disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vincent Falcone
The food and the place are great! Everyone there is so kind and considerate. Our waiter Anthony was absolutely fantastic, very attentive and personable!
We had the Special "Prime Rib" it was melt in your mouth good! Our server , Jane, was very attentive and friendly. At the end of the night and she Boxed up our left overs, she even marked our to go containers his and hers for us... Fantastic!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katherine Stan
Delightful restaurant, excellent food. Only problem was the older lady bartender.She was extremely rude and nasty. And she was wearing some kind of a nightgown. We will never go back to that bar again.Must have got her job through nepatism.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Rachel Maybird
Gallioto’s is, quite simply, a wonderful restaurant. The food was served piping hot, everything is fresh/scratch made, and they are very accommodating of special requests. The service was impecable, prompt, and personable. Anthony is one of the best servers I’ve ever encountered. He is so kind and friendly, and he always anticipates the need. Tonight we had one of the best Milwaukee dining experiences that we’ve had in a very long time. I’m only upset that my husband and I JUST realized that this restaurant exists just 10 minutes from our house! It’s the perfect spot for a date night.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharon Mulloy
Everything was excellent. I wish the bar would have stayed open a bit longer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg Smith
We ate as a large group. We've been going there every year when in town. The food is very good, and the atmosphere was wonderful. Highly recommend it!
I had the fish fry it was okay a bit greasy. The bartender was very friendly drinks were a good pour and fairly reasonable. I thought they menu was fairly limited in selection for an Italian restaurant
Will definitely go back to try something Italian
Great happy hour and good.
Wonderful food choices and outstanding waitress.
Stopped for a drink. Bartender was very friendly. He made a new drink he called Almond Joy martini we tried and it was delicious!
Great food.
Everything was sugary, the pasta, French onion soup, marinara. The only thing I truly enjoyed were the Rueben rolls. Also maybe it’s just me, but what is the point of bread crumbing if it’s just going be a soggy undercooked mess. The bread was amazing just took a long time to get to table. Bottom line not worth returning, too sweet no complexity, poorly cooked meats. I end my review “Was that chicken or veal.”
Have enjoyed Galioto's on several occasions and had a wonderful experience each one. I recommend the tenderloin.
Nice Saturday night visit. Place was a blast from the past, no on line reservation system, call and leave a message and they use pencil and paper. They were a little busy and our server seemed busy so the meal moved slow which was fine we were in no rush. We both ordered the Filet and it tasted good but it was weird, it looked like it had been cooked and then seared, the color was very even all the way through, it was a lot like slow cooked prime rib. The meals are a complete package, soup or salad, bread, veg and potato. and its a lot to eat, most people had left overs in to go clam shells. The side salad was good but its what you would have gotten at a supper club 30 years ago less the iceberg lettuce. The prices were extremely reasonable, dinner for 2 was $133, including 2 beers, 1 glass of wine, one after dinner drink and an up grade to French onion soup. We had an expired gift certificate which they graciously accepted.
This is a great little place to check out! If you enjoy that old world feel when you walk in the door and a friendly staff that always make you feel like family this is your kind of restaurant. We keep coming back for more - a nice selection of great food, not a huge menu but I like knowing that what I'm getting is fresh and made to order. Anthony is fantastic, always willing to make sure we have a wonderful experience. Make sure you ask for him! We have invited friends and family to join us and we've never been disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and the place are great! Everyone there is so kind and considerate. Our waiter Anthony was absolutely fantastic, very attentive and personable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We had the Special "Prime Rib" it was melt in your mouth good!
Our server , Jane, was very attentive and friendly. At the end of the night and she Boxed up our left overs, she even marked our to go containers his and hers for us... Fantastic!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delightful restaurant, excellent food. Only problem was the older lady bartender.She was extremely rude and nasty. And she was wearing some kind of a nightgown. We will never go back to that bar again.Must have got her job through nepatism.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Gallioto’s is, quite simply, a wonderful restaurant. The food was served piping hot, everything is fresh/scratch made, and they are very accommodating of special requests. The service was impecable, prompt, and personable. Anthony is one of the best servers I’ve ever encountered. He is so kind and friendly, and he always anticipates the need. Tonight we had one of the best Milwaukee dining experiences that we’ve had in a very long time. I’m only upset that my husband and I JUST realized that this restaurant exists just 10 minutes from our house! It’s the perfect spot for a date night.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was excellent. I wish the bar would have stayed open a bit longer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ate as a large group. We've been going there every year when in town. The food is very good, and the atmosphere was wonderful. Highly recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...