Probably the best crispy chicken sandwich you can get in the state when it's available on certain days. Really cool place in historic downtown cedarburg. They offer dine in or carryout, with ample seating and a bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eli Redman
Had a late lunch/early dinner in what is now called Dorsey's (the son of Settlement Inn owners took over and renamed the place). This fish wrap was pretty tasty, though I would recommend they take it up a notch by warming the wrap beforehand. What I received instead was warm contents in a cold wrap. Also, the homemade chips, which are usually quite good, were under- cooked leaving many of them in raw soggy potato form. A bit more attention to quality, details, and customer service would make all the difference.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Brunilda Gjylameti
Decent good and quiet ambience.Vegetarian options: Yes. Some veggie options.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendlyParking: Street parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Seasonal Baked French Toast
Charles Kay
Went for lunch with family. Prices were good and food was great . We had the Italian heros with fries and wife had the home made chips. The sandwiches were both full of flavor and both fries and chips were great . Daughter had a burger and fries also she loved it. Customer service was great and polite. We definitely recommend to stop in and have a bit. We definitely will be making a regular trip for lunches in the future. We done .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Curnutt
High quality food that tastes great and leaves one satisfied. The place was empty the few times I ate here, but there are nice tables by the windows that offer a view of daily town life.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tom Stanton
Great food, Great Times with Great Friends!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Kommer
Really nice restaurant- good food. Home made items.
Bruce Danek
Very good home-made food. Awesome service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Judy Munger
My family was very pleased with the lunch catering service from Settlers Inn for our mother's funeral. The food was delicious and delivered on time. Joan worked with us to create a meal that fit our wishes. I would highly recommend!
Krystal P
First time in Settlers Inn, and it was a great experience! Staff are extremely friendly, knowledgeable, and make great recommendations. I ordered two different fish fries with two different sides, and everything tasted delicious. Their tartar sauce was excellent too. I also had to try a piece of their German Chocolate Cake, and it was to die for! I cannot wait to go back and try more of their food.
I have never had a bad meal here. I love their food!! It’s so heartwarming and delicious. I love the space — unique, comfortable, very spacious and perfect for lunch with a group/family or just a couple. I also love that they have a bar if you’re feeling like a cocktail with brunch, good coffee and such a great menu. I can’t say enough about this special place in Cedarburg.
Jennuine
Very good, light breakfast of quiche and coffee. Excellent scone to finish it off. Friendly and attentive staff! KISS
Tyler Ng
This place is soooo dope. We came in and got one of the best sandwiches we’ve ever had, and even got some fresh pasta salad with it. The bloody Mary’s are delicious and are served with a Spotted Cow beer chaser.
Emily Marthaler
Love this place!!! While enjoy a lot of what they offer - the best and most amazing are their pies!!!! Amazing crust reminds me of my grandmother and mother's! They are so good I served 30 of them at my wedding!
scott j
Best fish fry! Best tartar sauce and the most delicious raspberry squares as dessert, this is a gem in Cedarburg , great homemade food!
Probably the best crispy chicken sandwich you can get in the state when it's available on certain days. Really cool place in historic downtown cedarburg. They offer dine in or carryout, with ample seating and a bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a late lunch/early dinner in what is now called Dorsey's (the son of Settlement Inn owners took over and renamed the place). This fish wrap was pretty tasty, though I would recommend they take it up a notch by warming the wrap beforehand. What I received instead was warm contents in a cold wrap. Also, the homemade chips, which are usually quite good, were under- cooked leaving many of them in raw soggy potato form. A bit more attention to quality, details, and customer service would make all the difference.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Decent good and quiet ambience.Vegetarian options: Yes. Some veggie options.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendlyParking: Street parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Seasonal Baked French Toast
Went for lunch with family. Prices were good and food was great . We had the Italian heros with fries and wife had the home made chips. The sandwiches were both full of flavor and both fries and chips were great . Daughter had a burger and fries also she loved it. Customer service was great and polite. We definitely recommend to stop in and have a bit. We definitely will be making a regular trip for lunches in the future. We done .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
High quality food that tastes great and leaves one satisfied. The place was empty the few times I ate here, but there are nice tables by the windows that offer a view of daily town life.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great food, Great Times with Great Friends!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really nice restaurant- good food. Home made items.
Very good home-made food. Awesome service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family was very pleased with the lunch catering service from Settlers Inn for our mother's funeral. The food was delicious and delivered on time. Joan worked with us to create a meal that fit our wishes. I would highly recommend!
First time in Settlers Inn, and it was a great experience! Staff are extremely friendly, knowledgeable, and make great recommendations. I ordered two different fish fries with two different sides, and everything tasted delicious. Their tartar sauce was excellent too. I also had to try a piece of their German Chocolate Cake, and it was to die for! I cannot wait to go back and try more of their food.
Restaurantji Recommends
I have never had a bad meal here. I love their food!! It’s so heartwarming and delicious. I love the space — unique, comfortable, very spacious and perfect for lunch with a group/family or just a couple. I also love that they have a bar if you’re feeling like a cocktail with brunch, good coffee and such a great menu. I can’t say enough about this special place in Cedarburg.
Very good, light breakfast of quiche and coffee. Excellent scone to finish it off. Friendly and attentive staff! KISS
This place is soooo dope. We came in and got one of the best sandwiches we’ve ever had, and even got some fresh pasta salad with it. The bloody Mary’s are delicious and are served with a Spotted Cow beer chaser.
Love this place!!! While enjoy a lot of what they offer - the best and most amazing are their pies!!!! Amazing crust reminds me of my grandmother and mother's! They are so good I served 30 of them at my wedding!
Best fish fry! Best tartar sauce and the most delicious raspberry squares as dessert, this is a gem in Cedarburg , great homemade food!