This restaurant was really good. I loved the pizza and the deep fried ravioli was amazing. The service is really nice and all the staff was very friendly. The atmosphere was overall pretty good. It was a little bit loud but other than that it was fine. I got the cheese pizza and I thought it was really good. There was the perfect amount of cheese to crust tomato sauce ratio. I would definitely come here again and I would recommend anyone else who wants to come here. for drinks, we got lemonade and Coca-Cola. The lemonade is really good and I would definitely get it again if I came here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan Cain
I tried the deep dish and the thin crust. Crust was a little bland but a really good pizza either way. I'll definitely be visiting again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
L
Pizza was so good! Even to go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan Fehrenbach
sweet place. they were very busy and still got us in pretty quick and food came out fast and delicious. we'll definitely come back.
Sarah Hillestad
My grandma has been coming here since the 50s. She loves it. As a New Yorker, I’ll admit the pizza is really good, some of the best I’ve had.
Jen Marchel
My 2 friends and I visited this establishment last night. We were seated in the corner, which was no problem at all. We had to order from the bar, again, no issue at all. However there were flies everywhere, which was a little off putting. Earlier in the day, I looked up their menu as I had never been there before and I wanted to get an idea of what they offered. I saw they had delicious cheesy garlic bread (which we did end up ordering) and it was delicious. This however was the only positive. I also saw they had a daily special if you bought a 12” pizza you got a 10” cheese pizza for free. While I wasn’t sure what we were going to order I kept it in the back of my head as I have a 4 year old little boy who I figured would love it. Lo and behold we did in fact end up ordering a 12” pizza along with 2 appetizers, two other entrées, three drinks and other things that ended up being $68 in total. After we ordered everything, I remembered the daily special that I had seen online and said to the woman now named NICOLE “I saw that if you order a 12” pizza, you get a free 10” cheese pizza for free” to which she gave me a snotty reply of “no that’s only for take out”. As I didn’t have my phone in front of me I let it go. I went back to my table and pulled up the coupon which NOT say “take out only” so I went back to NICOLE and say “excuse me ma’am but it does not say take out only”. She then rudely grabbed my phone out of my hand and said “the website I was on was not the correct one”. She said she was too busy for me right now and said she would show me the correct website later and to get out of her face. Furthermore, to punish us, the table next to us, sat down a little after us but ordered their meal, ate it and finished it before we got our food. Also, my gf’s coworker goes there multiple times a week and always gets their adult grilled cheese so she was excited to try their grilled cheese for the first time but again thanks to NICOLE, they burned her grilled cheese, so it was not a good sandwich. Then while we were eating NICOLE, again very snotty brought up some fake website that said about the take out pizza. I had really high hopes. I was excited to try this place and I came here to celebrate as I had just finished my 12th and finale round of chemotherapy. But thanks to NICOLE, who today I found out was the owner, which is very unfortunate, I will never come back. Well NICOLE I have attached pictures. If you google your restaurant, click menu, scroll down to the pizza section, you’ll see the daily special of “buy a 12” pizza and get a 10” cheese pizza for free “. You may be the owner NICOLE but I have proof you’re WRONG. Checkmate. You owe me a free pizza. Thanks for treating cancer patient like crap. If there was less than a 1 star you’d get it
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Clare Boyle
This is an old style pizza place with a menu that holds a variety of entrée choices on the casual end. Love this place for a quick, yummy bite to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara M
Ordered take-out last night for the family & it was excellent! Busy place and the food was still ready in a timely manner. Generous with toppings & fresh ingredients. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Terwelp
Seriously the best pizza anywhere! Their toppings are premium grade. We go here whenever we’re in town.
It is tight inside, but has a local bar feel and friendly atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mrs Snowman
Ordered a large deep dish sausage pizza on Saturday evening and received a 12 inch thin cheese and pepperoni pizza Free! Both pizzas were delicious! I was told they would be ready in 30 minutes and Tomasos was right on time. The staff was super friendly. Best pizza in Cedarburg.
Its good to be a busy restaurant though the space was so cramped with seats and people the one time I dinned in it ruined it for me. Carryout is key here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Kristin T
A local favorite, fond memories from my high school days. Generous toppings, thin crust is perfection. Best pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Art Aiello
This is me personally, but I really don't like going to what's advertised as a restaurant only to discover it's really a bar that doubles as a restaurant. The dining space is painfully small, it was very loud and busy (although it was a Saturday afternoon, so that's to be expected), and everything was self-serve. And I gotta say, the pizza was fine, but it was hardly worth the hassle of having to squeeze past people to get your own plates and utensils and to retrieve your food from the bar when the bartenders call.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Mary J Moerbe
My favorite pizza place for 40 years or so! Can't beat the sauce and flavor. Best hot or cold.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Stephens (mr patrinkas)
Came up from central Illinois to visit family and they said this was the best so we drove another 45 min to get this pizza. Holy crap i was 100% not disappointed. Very good quality and taist. I will definitely come back for more ne t time Im up north!!!!!
This restaurant was really good. I loved the pizza and the deep fried ravioli was amazing. The service is really nice and all the staff was very friendly. The atmosphere was overall pretty good. It was a little bit loud but other than that it was fine. I got the cheese pizza and I thought it was really good. There was the perfect amount of cheese to crust tomato sauce ratio. I would definitely come here again and I would recommend anyone else who wants to come here. for drinks, we got lemonade and Coca-Cola. The lemonade is really good and I would definitely get it again if I came here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I tried the deep dish and the thin crust. Crust was a little bland but a really good pizza either way. I'll definitely be visiting again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Pizza was so good! Even to go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
sweet place. they were very busy and still got us in pretty quick and food came out fast and delicious. we'll definitely come back.
My grandma has been coming here since the 50s. She loves it. As a New Yorker, I’ll admit the pizza is really good, some of the best I’ve had.
My 2 friends and I visited this establishment last night. We were seated in the corner, which was no problem at all. We had to order from the bar, again, no issue at all. However there were flies everywhere, which was a little off putting. Earlier in the day, I looked up their menu as I had never been there before and I wanted to get an idea of what they offered. I saw they had delicious cheesy garlic bread (which we did end up ordering) and it was delicious. This however was the only positive. I also saw they had a daily special if you bought a 12” pizza you got a 10” cheese pizza for free. While I wasn’t sure what we were going to order I kept it in the back of my head as I have a 4 year old little boy who I figured would love it. Lo and behold we did in fact end up ordering a 12” pizza along with 2 appetizers, two other entrées, three drinks and other things that ended up being $68 in total. After we ordered everything, I remembered the daily special that I had seen online and said to the woman now named NICOLE “I saw that if you order a 12” pizza, you get a free 10” cheese pizza for free” to which she gave me a snotty reply of “no that’s only for take out”. As I didn’t have my phone in front of me I let it go. I went back to my table and pulled up the coupon which NOT say “take out only” so I went back to NICOLE and say “excuse me ma’am but it does not say take out only”. She then rudely grabbed my phone out of my hand and said “the website I was on was not the correct one”. She said she was too busy for me right now and said she would show me the correct website later and to get out of her face. Furthermore, to punish us, the table next to us, sat down a little after us but ordered their meal, ate it and finished it before we got our food. Also, my gf’s coworker goes there multiple times a week and always gets their adult grilled cheese so she was excited to try their grilled cheese for the first time but again thanks to NICOLE, they burned her grilled cheese, so it was not a good sandwich. Then while we were eating NICOLE, again very snotty brought up some fake website that said about the take out pizza. I had really high hopes. I was excited to try this place and I came here to celebrate as I had just finished my 12th and finale round of chemotherapy. But thanks to NICOLE, who today I found out was the owner, which is very unfortunate, I will never come back. Well NICOLE I have attached pictures. If you google your restaurant, click menu, scroll down to the pizza section, you’ll see the daily special of “buy a 12” pizza and get a 10” cheese pizza for free “. You may be the owner NICOLE but I have proof you’re WRONG. Checkmate. You owe me a free pizza. Thanks for treating cancer patient like crap. If there was less than a 1 star you’d get it
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This is an old style pizza place with a menu that holds a variety of entrée choices on the casual end. Love this place for a quick, yummy bite to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered take-out last night for the family & it was excellent! Busy place and the food was still ready in a timely manner. Generous with toppings & fresh ingredients. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seriously the best pizza anywhere! Their toppings are premium grade. We go here whenever we’re in town.
It is tight inside, but has a local bar feel and friendly atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a large deep dish sausage pizza on Saturday evening and received a 12 inch thin cheese and pepperoni pizza Free! Both pizzas were delicious! I was told they would be ready in 30 minutes and Tomasos was right on time. The staff was super friendly. Best pizza in Cedarburg.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Its good to be a busy restaurant though the space was so cramped with seats and people the one time I dinned in it ruined it for me. Carryout is key here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
A local favorite, fond memories from my high school days. Generous toppings, thin crust is perfection. Best pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is me personally, but I really don't like going to what's advertised as a restaurant only to discover it's really a bar that doubles as a restaurant. The dining space is painfully small, it was very loud and busy (although it was a Saturday afternoon, so that's to be expected), and everything was self-serve. And I gotta say, the pizza was fine, but it was hardly worth the hassle of having to squeeze past people to get your own plates and utensils and to retrieve your food from the bar when the bartenders call.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
My favorite pizza place for 40 years or so! Can't beat the sauce and flavor. Best hot or cold.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came up from central Illinois to visit family and they said this was the best so we drove another 45 min to get this pizza. Holy crap i was 100% not disappointed. Very good quality and taist. I will definitely come back for more ne t time Im up north!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...