Papa Don's Pizzeria & Buffet

613 Calumet St, Chilton
(920) 489-3043

Recent Reviews

Rob L

The buffet was definitely something we didn't expect. We asked for menus but we were pushed towards it by our server. We didn't press back. I guess for our first time, it was a chance to sample everything. It didn't disappoint. My drink was suspect tho. I don't think the small bar can handle off the wall recipes like an old fashioned. Our server was friendly and stopped at the table plenty times. The atmosphere was an echo. Maybe some sort of sound absorption is needed. If I lived closer I would definitely frequent the pizza. I recommend this place.

MANDAH CLARK

Never had a complaint before except now. I called for delivery for a reason.. every other time I placed an order for delivery it wasn't an issue but all of a sudden it's an issue and too far of a drive.. really....? Then the person on the phone says we'll u can pick up... Umm no I said delivery for a reason if I wanted to pick up I would of stayed that. Seriously 5 minutes is too far all of a sudden. Smh. Sorry I was being cautious and not trying to get others sick. Definitely lost my business. Really liked it when Lisa Cullen owned it.

Brian Gebhart

They don't have much of a selection for their buffet. The food was average

Karen Lee

We happened to be in the area and looked for a restaurant. We saw they had a pizza buffet which was very good! It had pizza, cheese bread, chicken, meatballs, mashed potatoes, gravy and salad bar. I forgot to get a photo of the food. I would definitely go here again.

Ben Farvour

Not a bad place to eat. If your looking for a simple but good buffet this is the place for you. Has a couple games for the kids to play on and prizes for the tickets they earn.

Jami Riley

Love the buffet! This is my kids favorite place to go. Food is always fresh

Stacey Bronk

Ridiculous buffet. Not worth the money. Pizza and iceberg lettuce. Our server was rude nachos were a complete joke

RJ McKenzie

Always great food from here. A go-to place in Chilton for pizza.

Danny Boy

Several stops Pizza so so but Salad bar yuk. Ordered off the Menu Wed the 23rd waited 45 mins and waitress said sorry forgot to put your order in, left and NOT RETURNING

Mike Niemann

Love the food. Great pizzas and friendly staff as well.

Dakota Brocker

Food was delicious as always! Had to wait a few minutes for buffet items when we arrived but it was early for dinner so that was to be expected. Service was good even as they started to get busier.

Casey Raddatz

Pizza taste good but my last pizza took at least 30 mins longer than what they promised and when i got home i realized it was barely cooked and had to throw it back in the oven. Saying i was mad is an understatement

Craig Kalies

Could use a little more hot food selection on the buffet otherwise it's a great place to eat. Food off the menu is really good also. Friendly staff and relaxed environment

Amy Brunette

Not a very big buffet at all, but the food is decent and they have a tiny arcade for the kid's.

Sarah Gracyalny

Well we are loyal customers here! Tasty buffet and they will make any suggestions within reason! Tasty salad bar and soups as well! Great customer service, a game area too! Closed on Mondays found that out after riding my ? son and I. This evening the power went out and they didn't make us pay.

Load More

Papa Don's Pizzeria & Buffet

613 Calumet St, Chilton, WI 53014
(920) 489-3043