Jimmy John's

1540 W James St, Columbus
(920) 623-3000

Recent Reviews

John Mazzuca

You order food to your specific because you are allergic to items or you just don't like certain items!! The last month and a half I Specifically order a sandwich with NO ONIONS!! EVERY SINGLE SANDWICH IN THE LAST MONTH AN A HALF EITHER HAD A CHUNCK OF ONION OR THE TOMATOES AND LETTUCE TASTE LIKE ONION BECAUSE THE EITHER HAVE THEM NEXT TO EACH OTHER WHEN MAKING SANDWICHES OR THEY ARE STORED BY THE ONION!! I have complained several times and all they do is give me a free sandwich which is very rich in onion flavor or has a chunck of onion on it. THIS IS HOW PEOPLE GET SICK OR HAVE A MAJOR ALLERGIC REACTION!! PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT YOUR DOING!!!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Ruby Gerber

Good food. Friendly staff. Delivery times can really vary (by 30 minutes) so I have switched to ordering ahead and pick it up myself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

deb m

I order a bootlegger and was not given the correct sandwich. When i got home and realized i had the wrong sub i called. They said they would credit my account. That was 8-13-23 and i still have not got a refund.

Jade Duguay

So, I haven't personally dined here but my mom does. She lost her partner of 13 years suddenly. Tonight, she had called a local pizza place that wouldn't deliver to her because her order was 12 cents shy of what they require for delivery. They weren't willing to budge either. So, she called Jimmy John's. Not only did the girl in the phone show her kindness and care, they bought her meal, delivered it, AND included a card and flowers. I'm 800 miles away from my mom right now, so someone showing her this kind of kindness in her time of grief is so very appreciated. Thank you to the staff of this store.

Kenzer Dilley

I use to love Jimmy John's but they are rude especially the so called owner and they are so slow more then once I have had this happen that I have waited over a half hour to almost a hour for my my

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

richard hinkley

Not having changed to break a 100-dollar

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Brittney Christianson

I ordered a sandwich for delivery and when I opened it the bread was hard as a rock. I called and they sent a new one right away and even included a free brownie for the trouble. It was very nice of them. Usually have good food/service from Columbus, WI location.

Mellissa Withrow

The food was great, store was clean. The staff were having loud conversations, with some curse/swear woords.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

ME

Great! Fast, friendly service. Will go back!

Jessica Habenicht

I have always had a great experience here til tonight. Ordered my typical unwich and it came a GIANT mess..i was shocked ?

Jessica B

I ordered a large catering order for a conference from this Jimmy John’s location. The order was accurate and delivered on time.

Kassie Korbal

Will never order from this Jimmy Johns. Super rude customer service never received my order.

Kassie Marie

Will never order from this Jimmy Johns. Super rude customer service never received my order.

Autum Kunz

I ordered a J.J.B.L.T from there and I’ve never had problems with them before and this one time I ordered I paid with cash and first of all the guy had to ask me what I get back and second I open my sandwich and all that is on it is Tomatoes, Bacon and Mayo and I did not say no Lettuce. How can you possibly mess this up! Not happy at all!!

Brent Smith

Just went there before 7pm and was told they were closed.

Load More