Hilltop Resort Supper Club

Great food — over 50 items at the salad bar. Loved all the pasta salads!

Got there early last night to beat the rush. Bartender got us drinks, menus and placed a number in front of us. We were with friends so we were visiting as we watched the place fill up. After an hour and a half nobody came to take our order while others after us ordered and went in. When we asked the bartender, we were told that WE had to let them know we were ready. Ummmm, a number placed indicates we will be eating. Waitress took our order finally and said she would get us in shortly. Waited yet another half an hour and upon checking with her she said oh, another 30 minutes or so. We told them to cancel our orders we were going elsewhere. Bartender made a rude comment and walked away.

Service: 1

Absolutely amazing New Year's experience! Staff was beyond friendly. Music was on point! Drink specials, salad bar, and prime rib were top notch! Highly recommend

Service: 5

We went for dinner this evening. OMG. Was it good! We both had a 10 oz. Prime rib. So tender, so tasty. Not much fat and cook just how I like mine.
Hilltop also included the salad bar, which included hot soup, hot buttered gizzards and warm bread sticks which were mmmmmmm.
Go back? Can't wait.

We were really looking forward to the steak and salad bar. Got there at 4. We were given a number and told the waitress would start taking orders at 4:45. She took orders from at least 4 tables that came in after us. We ended up leaving and will be spending our money down the road. Very bad service. Will not recommend this place. Very disappointed. Drove 45 minutes to get there. A waste of time.

Always great food and service

Restaurant great fish salad bar

The establishment's overall quality is not in question. However, today's experience did not meet the standards set by previous visits. The current ordering system, which involves placing orders at the bar, appears to be inefficient. While it is understood that this method is intended to expedite service, there were instances where the serving staff appeared to prioritize customers who arrived later, disregarding the order of arrival. Additionally, my steak was overcooked and dry, and this issue was not addressed or acknowledged by the staff. This feedback is provided with the intention of constructive criticism and not to cause offense. It is important to note that I genuinely enjoy bringing my family to this establishment and hope that future visits will result in a more positive experience. Thank you for the opportunity to provide feedback.

Service: 2

Rooms: The hotel unit was great except for no oven rack.

Food and drinks: Great pizza everytime.

Service: 5

Supper club review:
(RUDE BARTENDER 2.5⭐️ on the bartender!)

The supper club deserves a 5⭐️

We’ve been here a few times as we have family that lives nearby. You need to know that you sign in at the bar and are given a number, then the hostess/server takes your order at the bar, & finds you when your table is ready. The nice part about that is you’re not dining with the loud noise in the bar room (there are doors that separate the dining room from the bar area). The salad bar is great, you can literally fill up on that before your meal. They also have turkey gizzards if that’s your thing, lots of choices and an Oreo fluff (like dirt cake) on the salad bar.
While we’ve had fish fry’s and steak dinners, we’ve yet to get a pizza (next time!). This part visit is what prompted me to finally write a review. Our fish fry’s were great, steaks were amazing except the medium rare came out rare & the medium was medium rare.

The owners are extremely friendly, but there is an older gentleman who bartends, who seems very rude, but I think he’s trying to be “funny” in a sarcastic way. I didn’t think he was funny when he made me feel like I was stupid for having read an item wrong on the menu, & this was at the bar where it was full, so everyone nearby heard him and he had an exasperated look on his face (like he’s dealing with an idiot). I turned and said to the lady next to me “he sure is rude” & she said “you get used to it”! Seriously?? If I had a bartender that patrons “got used to it” I’d get someone friendlier to replace him!
We all noticed it and we had a party of 8 that night. We avoided him when ordering and had a very pleasant female bartender to serve us.

Food and drinks: Great steaks and fish fry, and a lot of choices on the salad bar.
A great old fashion, one very rude bartender (older, balding gentleman).

Service: 4

Great Supper

Service: 5

This is our favorite supper club to go to in the area. Staff is supper friendly and the food is amazing. We never leave disappointed... unless the soup is pizza soup. That was odd. It can get quite busy, but it's worth the wait.

Always great food

Food & drinks: Amazing food at great prices.

Service: 4

Pizza is fantastic! Atmosphere, North woods homey.

Service: 5