Pizza Petes is a staple in the community... Grande cheese, local Italian sausage, homemade pizza sauce & they offer sandwiches, appitizers & desserts for a very reasonable price thats quality approved!!! This is coming from a Pizza man!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob Jacoby
Old school milw/chicago/midwest thin and chicago crust storefront, a couple tables- homemade sauce, local cheese and sausage, fresh mushrooms and red onions, good value - good community partners
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leslie Hundt
First time we ordered from this place. We ordered a veggie pizza which was very good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Dustin Rick
12/7/25 I ordered two pizzas and garlic bread, 40 minutes before the packer game today.Pizza Pete’s called to notify me that they didn’t have the Chicago style cheese pizza, so I said just do a regular cheese pizza and keep the margarita pizza and garlic bread. I showed up 20 minutes later (that’s how long they said) and the only thing ready was my garlic bread. They didn’t start any pizzas, only to hear they did not have the ingredients for my margarita pizza. From the half an hour wait, too the hour wait in the store to get only cheese pizza and cold garlic bread, which I watched sit under a heat lamp for an hour. I wasn’t satisfied and asked for some sort of compensation but got nothing. For my first time there, I don’t think I would return. 2 hours deep into one single pizza now, for my family on Sunday. Believe me, it was a waist of time. Hopefully the owner sees this and the employees relayed this message to them before they see it on here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Peter DiGaudio
Had the Italian sub. Best sandwich of that kind I've ever had.
Dean Blackburn
Was a great experience the people were very friendly the service was great and fast and the food was awesome the flavors were spot on
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristy O'Connor
We ordered food on November 23rd. We ordered a deep dish pizza. The pizza had so much sauce on it and this is coming from a please put extra sauce on it for me person, but it was like soup. The person that made the pizza said she didn't remember how to make one because it's been so long since she had. She was nice though. The pizza also had a weird taste to it like it was sour. I had one piece and we had to throw it away. We also ordered the Italian bomber sandwich and there was no seasoning, it was rubbery, and the veggies were crunchy and not cooked.
Food: 1
Service: 3
white-tailed-Deer-stalker
Overpriced & not impressive. Ur pizza kinda sucked
John Sopina
Since the newly updated menu, I love this place and it's not far away!
I highly recommend Pizza Pete!! The food was delicious and the delivery Driver went above and beyond her duties. she brought the pizza to my kitchen when she saw I was walking with a cane. I love what they do for their community and patrons. I give this place 10 stars.
Claudia Ibarra
I called Pizza Pete's earlier in spring about potentially catering for my wedding in August and they asked that I called back a week or two prior to finalize our counts, to my disbelief the manager remembered our conversation and took care of us in a timely fashion. Our food was delivered during their off hours to accommodate our wedding reception. Food temp was good and warm and plates napkins pepper parm provided. Not to mention it was amazing. 1000% recommend them!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brenda Marie
Amazing food, Amazing customer service! Definitely coming back !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry Davis
On my 2nd and 3rd trip the customer service improved greatly and the owner went above and beyond to ensure the experience and food was a great experience… support small business and remember to always support businesses that treat customers with the utmost respect… The food is Great!
Leo Larry (Leo) Davis, ABD, MSW, MPH
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zack Forsyth
The crew was kind we picked up our doordash delivery they where working really hard you can't find that nowadays
Pizza Petes is a staple in the community... Grande cheese, local Italian sausage, homemade pizza sauce & they offer sandwiches, appitizers & desserts for a very reasonable price thats quality approved!!! This is coming from a Pizza man!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Old school milw/chicago/midwest thin and chicago crust storefront, a couple tables- homemade sauce, local cheese and sausage, fresh mushrooms and red onions, good value - good community partners
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time we ordered from this place. We ordered a veggie pizza which was very good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
12/7/25 I ordered two pizzas and garlic bread, 40 minutes before the packer game today.Pizza Pete’s called to notify me that they didn’t have the Chicago style cheese pizza, so I said just do a regular cheese pizza and keep the margarita pizza and garlic bread. I showed up 20 minutes later (that’s how long they said) and the only thing ready was my garlic bread. They didn’t start any pizzas, only to hear they did not have the ingredients for my margarita pizza. From the half an hour wait, too the hour wait in the store to get only cheese pizza and cold garlic bread, which I watched sit under a heat lamp for an hour. I wasn’t satisfied and asked for some sort of compensation but got nothing. For my first time there, I don’t think I would return. 2 hours deep into one single pizza now, for my family on Sunday. Believe me, it was a waist of time. Hopefully the owner sees this and the employees relayed this message to them before they see it on here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Had the Italian sub. Best sandwich of that kind I've ever had.
Was a great experience the people were very friendly the service was great and fast and the food was awesome the flavors were spot on
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered food on November 23rd. We ordered a deep dish pizza. The pizza had so much sauce on it and this is coming from a please put extra sauce on it for me person, but it was like soup. The person that made the pizza said she didn't remember how to make one because it's been so long since she had. She was nice though. The pizza also had a weird taste to it like it was sour. I had one piece and we had to throw it away. We also ordered the Italian bomber sandwich and there was no seasoning, it was rubbery, and the veggies were crunchy and not cooked.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Overpriced & not impressive. Ur pizza kinda sucked
Since the newly updated menu, I love this place and it's not far away!
Fast, friendly and great pizza!
Restaurantji Recommends
I highly recommend Pizza Pete!! The food was delicious and the delivery Driver went above and beyond her duties. she brought the pizza to my kitchen when she saw I was walking with a cane. I love what they do for their community and patrons. I give this place 10 stars.
I called Pizza Pete's earlier in spring about potentially catering for my wedding in August and they asked that I called back a week or two prior to finalize our counts, to my disbelief the manager remembered our conversation and took care of us in a timely fashion. Our food was delivered during their off hours to accommodate our wedding reception. Food temp was good and warm and plates napkins pepper parm provided. Not to mention it was amazing. 1000% recommend them!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food, Amazing customer service! Definitely coming back !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
On my 2nd and 3rd trip the customer service improved greatly and the owner went above and beyond to ensure the experience and food was a great experience… support small business and remember to always support businesses that treat customers with the utmost respect… The food is Great!
Leo
Larry (Leo) Davis, ABD, MSW, MPH
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The crew was kind we picked up our doordash delivery they where working really hard you can't find that nowadays
Service: 5
Loading...