Within Reach Bar

3701 E Squire Ave, Cudahy
(414) 988-5629

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jay Francis (whatever)

Served, and charged, for a double, when I specifically ordered a single, twice. Bartender took my unfinished drink from bar when I was not looking, and made excuses when I called her on it, and later, took all of my change I'd left on the bar, not for a tip but because I was called to sing. She denied that, also and implied that it was my friend. Horrible service, horrible person. I intend to call the city of Cudahy about the over-serving. I came from Hartford, WI and had a very long drive back.Someone replies from the bar (below), implicating themselves ("you bought a" single, got a double, set it and your cash on the bar) like patrons have done in Milwaukee since the beginning of Taverns. Unless it is an untrustworthy bar.And yours is. I doubt I'm the first, but, I was somewhere near the last, because I hear the bar is toast..I wonder why...???

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Ali Voboril

My husband and I LOVE this bar. We make the drive from New Berlin often because every time we’ve gone we’ve always felt so welcomed and like we’re amongst friends, even though we don’t know anyone. Especially when you get to neighborhood bars you never know what kind of crowd you’re walking into, it’s never been the case for us here. It’s a cool place, big inside, with a nice size bar lots of seats, dart boards, machines and POPCORN. They play good music and even music videos on the side tv which, extra points!, have a lot of cool stuff to look at like an extensive hot sauce collection :’D and a wheel to spin and win things, stuff to do rather than just sit at the bar and stare at the wall which is super awesome for someone with as bad ADD as I do. We’ve had different bartenders most times we’ve gone and everyone has been great. The owner is SOOO nice, SOOO friendly and truly cares about the patrons having a great experience. I highly recommend this bar, even if just passing through, you definitely need to stop for one (or 3) and support this business. You won’t regret it!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Jay “whatever” Francis

Served, and charged, for a double, when I specifically ordered a single, twice. Bartender took my unfinished drink from bar when I was not looking, and made excuses when I called her on it, and later, took all of my change I'd left on the bar, not for a tip but because I was called to sing. She denied that, also and implied that it was my friend. Horrible service, horrible person. I intend to call the city of Cudahy about the over-serving. I came from Hartford, WI and had a very long drive back.

Alisa Burdick

The service was good for a packed bar. The bartender earned their tip and karaoke was stellar.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

QueenBia23

Always a great time?

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Kira Hagquist

Boring bar that offers shake of the day but nobody knows how to play. If you need to watch sports and drink this place will do.

craig rekowski

Rosie is an excellent bartender will definitely be returning very soon

The Prince of Nu Metal (Shadow)

Very friendly, reasonably priced and excellent work

Denise Zubic

Justin the Bartender was nice. Karaoke was so fun. The only thing I usually don't complain but womens bathroom was very dirty.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Heidi Hildeman

Nice, friendly bar that I go to for karaoke occasionally. They have a big pretzel that I really like and things like pizza and pizza of the bread. The owner is very friendly and there's a great outdoor patio in back where you can sit and smoke and chat with friends. I highly recommend this venue, especially for karaoke goers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kathleen Porter (KayP)

Darts, Karaoke & a fun crowd - great male bartender on staff - really drunk female bartender (she should have been pulled from working behind the pine)

The Prince of Nu Metal Shadow

Very friendly, reasonably priced and excellent work

Nicole Harris

Super fun ....karaoke was a blast

Amanda Albert

Awful neighbors. Apparently the owners/bartenders can't find the volume knob on the sound system, because here it is, 1am, and I'm AGAIN unable to sleep because of their music. And heaven forbid you try to call to ask them to turn it down - they just say "ok thanks!" And nothing changes. I miss when this was a quiet neighborhood.

Jocelyn Campbell

Currently a few months till of legal drinking age, but I went there for a coworker’s birthday party, didn’t order any drinks (not even water), started playing a game of darts to liven things up and got kicked out for not being 21. Which to my knowledge it wasn’t illegal to be in there, but it is the owners option to pick and choose clientele.

Loading...