Food has always been pretty good but multiple times my pick up order has been wrong. Partially my fault for not checking before I left. They have never offered to deliver or compensate for their screw up. It’s going to be a long time before I go to Gallagher’s again.
Julie Young
Seated and didn’t get drinks until mid way through meal (wasn’t told drinks were included so some got waters). Buffet pizza was duplicates. Never asked if we wanted refills and didn’t even come give bill while we sat waiting after done eating. Finally had to go to bar and asked to pay, where they acted like they didn’t know what to do. Then finally paid, was no physical bill to look at until I gave a credit card. No where did it say there would be a surcharge so asked to pay cash after looking at the copy to sign. They said it was voided, hopefully it was. For $14 it just didn’t seem put together.
Decided to take the family out for a rare sit down dinner somewhere. 2 adults 2 kids. We sat at Abbey for 15min, several servers looked at us, none ever approached us or offered anything, we walked over to Nikkis Restaurant, hey we were at least greeted and told there would be a wait on food. We said np!! 15min later the waitresses had given us a look several times but we never saw a menu or were offered even water.
We decided to walk into Gallghers, within 5min we were seated with drinks, within 20 we had food.
It sucks that the bar is that low but regardless, we appreciated just getting service. Thanks immensely for providing a professional establishment.
SHANE PEIK
Excellent pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Cheese Bread, Deep Dish Pizza
John Dalluge
Been to this Gallagher's twice. The first time was dine-in. The dining area was not very busy, but the wait was long, It took at least 45 minutes to get a pizza. Decided to give it another try with an online take-out order. Went into the store at the pickup time. The cashier went back to the kitchen. This took a while. Then she informed me it would be 5 more minutes. Again, not very busy. 25 minutes later we got our 3 topping pizza. I told the manager, " Next time, if you forget to make a customers pizza you should give them an option for a refund". A family was walking out while we were waiting. The cashier asked how their experience was. The little boy said, "that was a long wait for the pizza". That's when you know there's a recurring problem with the kitchen. I gave a 15% tip online, wish I was offered that back. This is my first negative review on Google.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Thomas Czekala
Lunch Buffet was delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Sticks
Sam Salewski
First I will say, I am sure their pizza is way better than what we had for dinner tonight but I’m not sure we would even go back to try it.
We ordered chicken alfredo with garlic bread and side salads. The salads were on par with what you’d expect for a basic salad. The pasta was extremely overcooked, the sauce tasted as what my boyfriend named it as “milk water” with no flavor. The chicken had no seasoning other than what tasted like chewy, burn grill. Honestly Fazzoli’s is better and to me that says something because I can’t stand their pasta either. Olive Garden is like fine dining in comparison. When you have so much on your menu you can’t only be good at pizza. We’re De Pere locals and really wanted to love Gallaghers but unfortunately it’s barely a 1 star for us.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
cricket ernst
I have had good pizza at other locations. This place was dirty, tables uncleared, food on floor and no bar tender. Waited 15 mins....no service at bar. The one sad waitress running trying to keep up. Poor management, allowing this to happen.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Tracey Fuller
Posting
"I had an amazing experience at Gallagher's Pizza De Pere! The service was impeccable, and Katie Michelle truly stood out. She was incredibly patient, kind, and knowledgeable about everything on the menu. Her recommendations were spot on, and she made sure we had everything we needed to enjoy our meal. Gallagher's Pizza is lucky to have someone like Katie Michelle on their team—she made our visit unforgettable. Highly recommend!"
This place came recommended by a few people, boy where they wrong.
When you place an order on your website, an hour ahead and show up on time you kind of expect what you ordered to be ready when you get there, not over a half an hour later. When one of the pizzas is sitting there under a heat lamp for all of that time while the other pizza is eventually getting made, guess what that first pizza is disgusting. I don’t know why you think it’s OK to let people sit there and wait without getting their food ready when they’ve already paid you, Absolutely terrible service.
At that point you should be remaking the first one or offering a refund, not just sending people on their merry way.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
cynthia floodstrand
Great staff, location, amazing pizza !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Anderson
We sat outside at Gallagher’s East last night. Everything was perfect. Had great service and even better was the food. Highly recommend this location.
Food has always been pretty good but multiple times my pick up order has been wrong. Partially my fault for not checking before I left. They have never offered to deliver or compensate for their screw up. It’s going to be a long time before I go to Gallagher’s again.
Seated and didn’t get drinks until mid way through meal (wasn’t told drinks were included so some got waters). Buffet pizza was duplicates. Never asked if we wanted refills and didn’t even come give bill while we sat waiting after done eating. Finally had to go to bar and asked to pay, where they acted like they didn’t know what to do. Then finally paid, was no physical bill to look at until I gave a credit card. No where did it say there would be a surcharge so asked to pay cash after looking at the copy to sign. They said it was voided, hopefully it was. For $14 it just didn’t seem put together.
Parking: In front 50 spots
Kid-friendliness: Games, colors
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Sticks, Onion Rings, Thin Crust Pizza
Decided to take the family out for a rare sit down dinner somewhere. 2 adults 2 kids. We sat at Abbey for 15min, several servers looked at us, none ever approached us or offered anything, we walked over to Nikkis Restaurant, hey we were at least greeted and told there would be a wait on food. We said np!! 15min later the waitresses had given us a look several times but we never saw a menu or were offered even water.
We decided to walk into Gallghers, within 5min we were seated with drinks, within 20 we had food.
It sucks that the bar is that low but regardless, we appreciated just getting service. Thanks immensely for providing a professional establishment.
Excellent pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Cheese Bread, Deep Dish Pizza
Been to this Gallagher's twice. The first time was dine-in. The dining area was not very busy, but the wait was long, It took at least 45 minutes to get a pizza. Decided to give it another try with an online take-out order. Went into the store at the pickup time. The cashier went back to the kitchen. This took a while. Then she informed me it would be 5 more minutes. Again, not very busy. 25 minutes later we got our 3 topping pizza. I told the manager, " Next time, if you forget to make a customers pizza you should give them an option for a refund". A family was walking out while we were waiting. The cashier asked how their experience was. The little boy said, "that was a long wait for the pizza". That's when you know there's a recurring problem with the kitchen. I gave a 15% tip online, wish I was offered that back. This is my first negative review on Google.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Lunch Buffet was delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Sticks
First I will say, I am sure their pizza is way better than what we had for dinner tonight but I’m not sure we would even go back to try it.
We ordered chicken alfredo with garlic bread and side salads. The salads were on par with what you’d expect for a basic salad. The pasta was extremely overcooked, the sauce tasted as what my boyfriend named it as “milk water” with no flavor. The chicken had no seasoning other than what tasted like chewy, burn grill. Honestly Fazzoli’s is better and to me that says something because I can’t stand their pasta either. Olive Garden is like fine dining in comparison. When you have so much on your menu you can’t only be good at pizza. We’re De Pere locals and really wanted to love Gallaghers but unfortunately it’s barely a 1 star for us.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I have had good pizza at other locations. This place was dirty, tables uncleared, food on floor and no bar tender. Waited 15 mins....no service at bar. The one sad waitress running trying to keep up. Poor management, allowing this to happen.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Posting
"I had an amazing experience at Gallagher's Pizza De Pere! The service was impeccable, and Katie Michelle truly stood out. She was incredibly patient, kind, and knowledgeable about everything on the menu. Her recommendations were spot on, and she made sure we had everything we needed to enjoy our meal. Gallagher's Pizza is lucky to have someone like Katie Michelle on their team—she made our visit unforgettable. Highly recommend!"
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
In the top 5 of my all time favorite pizza places
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Pizza
One word Family okay 2 words Family Fun.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place came recommended by a few people, boy where they wrong.
When you place an order on your website, an hour ahead and show up on time you kind of expect what you ordered to be ready when you get there, not over a half an hour later. When one of the pizzas is sitting there under a heat lamp for all of that time while the other pizza is eventually getting made, guess what that first pizza is disgusting. I don’t know why you think it’s OK to let people sit there and wait without getting their food ready when they’ve already paid you, Absolutely terrible service.
At that point you should be remaking the first one or offering a refund, not just sending people on their merry way.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Great staff, location, amazing pizza !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We sat outside at Gallagher’s East last night. Everything was perfect. Had great service and even better was the food. Highly recommend this location.
Loading...