We loved it here! You'll definitely want to sit in the back area for the warmest vibe. The food and service were excellent. If I'm ever in the Green Bay area again, I'll certainly go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark P
Our favorite restaurant
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Dryer
I was in Wisconsin on a work trip 4 years ago and me and some of my work colleagues needed a place to grab some lunch and this was close so we went. Now.... My favorite movie is The A-Team with Bradley Cooper and Murdock (the pilot) makes a dish with curry tompenade in it. At this point I'd never even SEEN tompenade in real life on a menu so when I saw the Muffaletta sandwich had olive tompenade on it I went for it! Best sandwich I've ever had I think. Lucky me when my job took me back to Wisconsin and I was only 50 minutes from De Pere - I had to make the drive to have this sandwich yet again! Like before it did not disappoint! Everything about this place is always top notch! The decor, it's clean, top notch service too! Stop in and try the Muffaletta!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremy Noll
Always a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathy Harris
Had a cup of Chilli and split a Cuban Sandwich. Both good. Came out fast. Restaurant wasn't too busy. Neat architecture and history in there!
Michael Mihelich
Seating was a little cozy near the front door, otherwise an excellent dining experience.
Rich O
The food was cold. I don't know if the place was understaffed or if our server was just inattentive but it appeared a kitchen staffer was the one who ended up bringing us our food and probably because it had been sitting out a long time. By the time we got it, it was barely warm. The haddock also seemed to be overcooked. The breading was much darker than the perch and the fish was dry. I imagine it all would have been very good if it was hot and not overcooked. We also waited a very long time for our server to come back and get us our bill and to-go boxes.
Bryan
The only reason this place is missing a star and a 1 star on the atmosphere is because we had gotten there right when it opened so there wasnt anyone else there to judge it. The server was very nice and the food was also tasty would love to give this place another try on a Friday night just too see the crowd. They have alot of room and a upstairs in order to accommodate a large crowd without feeling jammed in so I'd like to come here again
Paul Reilly
Ambiance, atmosphere, are fantastic! Can't say enough good about it. Please don't pass this place up if you've never been.
Amy Warmenhoven
The fish fry is definitely more like the Wisconsin traditional than at some other places I've been lately. They close the kitchen absurdly early, 8:30, and most of their clientelle is geriatric. Despite its close proximity to SNC, this anything but a college bar, which I was told they shut down by 9:00 PM on most Fridays.
The Euro head was super salty server could have carried less cause.I was just 1 person they were busy but no attention.To detail was left for a while without any beverage or being asked if I wanted to bring you sat in the back by myself.Because there was nothing fron
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Martin Berg
Had a beer while my wife was in Improv class at Comedy City. What a quaint place. Very welcoming. Will come back for food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Jackson
Nicky's is one part funky, one part old school tavern, and one part good eats. This spot features something you won't often find in Northeast Wisconsin: unique flavors. I especially like their gumbo, though it's not for the faint of heart. It has some kick!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Eagle
The menu is small but the food is great try The Green Bay burger it's great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Brad Wery
tonight was a disaster. 1:45 wait for food and then food was cold. A few other groups left without getting their food. Brought friends in from out of town. Staff was set up to fail and I was embarrassed that I had brought my friends there. Some staff was probably feeling the same. Better off closing the kitchen when things went south but management didn’t seem to be anywhere to be found.
We loved it here! You'll definitely want to sit in the back area for the warmest vibe. The food and service were excellent. If I'm ever in the Green Bay area again, I'll certainly go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our favorite restaurant
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was in Wisconsin on a work trip 4 years ago and me and some of my work colleagues needed a place to grab some lunch and this was close so we went. Now.... My favorite movie is The A-Team with Bradley Cooper and Murdock (the pilot) makes a dish with curry tompenade in it. At this point I'd never even SEEN tompenade in real life on a menu so when I saw the Muffaletta sandwich had olive tompenade on it I went for it! Best sandwich I've ever had I think. Lucky me when my job took me back to Wisconsin and I was only 50 minutes from De Pere - I had to make the drive to have this sandwich yet again! Like before it did not disappoint! Everything about this place is always top notch! The decor, it's clean, top notch service too! Stop in and try the Muffaletta!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a cup of Chilli and split a Cuban Sandwich. Both good. Came out fast. Restaurant wasn't too busy. Neat architecture and history in there!
Seating was a little cozy near the front door, otherwise an excellent dining experience.
The food was cold. I don't know if the place was understaffed or if our server was just inattentive but it appeared a kitchen staffer was the one who ended up bringing us our food and probably because it had been sitting out a long time. By the time we got it, it was barely warm. The haddock also seemed to be overcooked. The breading was much darker than the perch and the fish was dry. I imagine it all would have been very good if it was hot and not overcooked. We also waited a very long time for our server to come back and get us our bill and to-go boxes.
The only reason this place is missing a star and a 1 star on the atmosphere is because we had gotten there right when it opened so there wasnt anyone else there to judge it. The server was very nice and the food was also tasty would love to give this place another try on a Friday night just too see the crowd. They have alot of room and a upstairs in order to accommodate a large crowd without feeling jammed in so I'd like to come here again
Ambiance, atmosphere, are fantastic! Can't say enough good about it. Please don't pass this place up if you've never been.
The fish fry is definitely more like the Wisconsin traditional than at some other places I've been lately. They close the kitchen absurdly early, 8:30, and most of their clientelle is geriatric. Despite its close proximity to SNC, this anything but a college bar, which I was told they shut down by 9:00 PM on most Fridays.
Restaurantji Recommends
The Euro head was super salty server could have carried less cause.I was just 1 person they were busy but no attention.To detail was left for a while without any beverage or being asked if I wanted to bring you sat in the back by myself.Because there was nothing fron
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Had a beer while my wife was in Improv class at Comedy City. What a quaint place. Very welcoming. Will come back for food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicky's is one part funky, one part old school tavern, and one part good eats. This spot features something you won't often find in Northeast Wisconsin: unique flavors. I especially like their gumbo, though it's not for the faint of heart. It has some kick!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The menu is small but the food is great try The Green Bay burger it's great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
tonight was a disaster. 1:45 wait for food and then food was cold. A few other groups left without getting their food. Brought friends in from out of town. Staff was set up to fail and I was embarrassed that I had brought my friends there. Some staff was probably feeling the same. Better off closing the kitchen when things went south but management didn’t seem to be anywhere to be found.
Loading...