Jimmy John's

635 S Main St, DeForest
(608) 846-9700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matt Holicek

Maybe don't serve turkey that looks like this.

Food: 1

RealBigJim007

My one complaint about this Jimmy John's is that I always tip when I order a sub. I NEVER once got a 'Thank You' from anyone. These ingrates need to be appreciative/ better trained.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Alex B

People don't review places when they actually have good service and food, only when its bad. I got a simple sub but everything was good. Bread was fresh and lots of turkey and tasted good too. People need to hear when they do well too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Beaux

Garbage store. Ran by garbage human beings. Have watched them touch money and then touch peoples food. Go anywhere else

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Samantha C (Sammy)

This jimmy johns didn't give me the normal amount of turkey that it normally comes with. I had 2 pieces of turkey folded in half. It was see through and torn. All bread. No filling. I love JJ, wth happened?!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Jayna

As a team we order game day subs weekly.
Sometimes they are super fresh, but the next it's like day old.. very inconsistent..but the staff is super friendly
But get rid of the delivery fee already!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Tanner Ewing

Absolute horrible experience with this restaurant every single time I order. The driver always forgets things always late and the staff is extremely rude.

Jim Severson

Couldn't get my order right had me bring it back over cut it in half because one half was supposed be with everything that comes on it other half supposed be no lettuce no mayo add onions the whole thing was this way so she handle it was so bad won't go back if she's working because I'm not happy at all!! And if I get sick for handling my food twice I will sue jimmy john's

Sue A.

Ordered a sandwich with extra cheese and was charged $2.20 extra for it. When I got the sandwich home and opened it up there was NO CHEESE. Not only was it disappointing to have no cheese they ripped me off for $2.20. This isn’t the first time they’ve messed up my order. I’m done with this place.

Wendy Grunewald

Usually frequent to this store two to three times a month and every time is a positive experience. A great bunch of people working there. Thank you!

Logan Morehouse

waited 45 minutes just for my chips to be forgotten

Service: 1

Matt

Like everything, the prices are outrageous. $30+ for me and my wife to have a simple sub, chips and drink. What is really offensive is the tipping. You are not a restaurant that waits on tables. You should not tip for ordering "freaky fast" subs at the counter. The card machine throws the tip % in your face. Then to select nothing you have to hit "other," press zero, then it recalculates (to the same amount) and you have to swipe your card again. Basically in attempt to make customers feel guilty about not tipping employees who get an hourly wage to make subs. I tip good for someone who waits on me in a restaurant. Tipping is out of control in this country. Out of control. In addition, where Jimmy John's drops the ball with their food is the cheese. It is a paper thin, transparent slice. Im sure adding extra will be another $5.

rob pagnucci

When you order online, start the order when you get it. Don’t wait until the online order shows up at the door and ask what you ordered. What’s the point of using the app?

Christine Lainberger

Quick

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Lainberger

Quick service

Loading...