Hubby and I were in Sayner camping, eBiking and ATVing. Made our way here for lunch. We will be back. LOVE the Cranberry Chicken Salad on a Croissant bun! Only downside, the place was packed. Obviously others think it is great too!!! Highly recommend a stop here! Staff is amazing!
Kimberly Janel Anderson
Everything is great! We love the Godfather sandwich! Great options ⭐️great staff ⭐️great menu!
Mike H
Everything is fresh and always tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jolee K
Get the smoked salmon salad it might be the best salad I’ve ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Will Lipske
Wonderful local business in Eagle River, WI. I ordered a family order takeout a couple of days ahead of a family function and the team here came through! At pick-up, everything was well organized and the team was super friendly... but the food itself, that was the inspiration for a review. Everyone present raved about the grinders: fresh, tasty, great bread-to-meat-to-fixings ratios. I'll be back next time I'm in Eagle River!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tim Adams
Awful service takes over 30 minutes to get a sandwich and you could hear them fighting in the kitchen
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Andrea C
Best sub we've ever had! The bread is chewy and awesome,quality meats and toppings. The Godfather was outstanding and the cheese steak and cannoli so great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak, Cannoli
Steven Sturdevant
I ordered the NYC sandwich. It wasn't awful, but it also wasn't the most spectacular sandwich ever. It was a generous portion, though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Carly
My husband and I visit every year while on vacation and cannot get enough of the cheesesteak (husband’s pick) and the chicken burrata (my pick). Do yourselves a favor and get ya one of each!
Food: 5
Jim Becker
We had a wonderful lunch experience here. Cozy environment - super nice people and excellent food - Pretty Perfect! I'll definitely be back! Love it!
We were hungry for pizza and this popped up on Google and we were NOT disappointed! The pizza crust was fantastic! Fresh ingredients were excellent! We will definitely be back! Thanks for the great lunch!
Julie Winter Paez, Realtor
One of our team's personal favorites - we HIGHLY recommend Aiello's! Variety and deliciousness, what more do you need?! YUMMM!
Rachel Boehm
Awesome sandwiches! Great food!
Sara Grenier Harvey
I am not one to write reviews, I've maybe only done it once before, but I'm just hugely disappointed. I've tried this place THREE times. The first 2 times were "ok" not great. My husband wanted to try it today. I was hesitant. At one register there was a woman talking so loudly on the phone, the other staff member could barely hear us to take our order. I asked for chili, and she said "anything else", I asked if they could make a simple croissant sandwich with ham and cheese. The worker stood there staring at the menu on the wall for a long time, and said "I don't know if we can do that". After waiting some more i said "nevermind, it's ok, just the chili". "That's it"? She asked. I said..I guess so 😔. I was frustrated. I'm also type 1 diabetic, my bloodsugar was going down, and I was starving. Good thing I grabbed a Sprite to drink to get some sugar in my system, because I couldn't eat the chili either. I didn't mind that it had black beans in it, but the bean flavor was overpowering, masking the taste of the other ingredients. The stools are also tiny and metal, making them very uncomfortable (Im not even a large person). I don't understand the appeal. It's not an issue of me having a poor taste palette either, I've eaten at establishments all over the country and 3 different countries. like I said, I don't leave reviews often, but 3 visits is enough for me.
Austin S
Had their soups to stay, fantastic food and very nice server
Hubby and I were in Sayner camping, eBiking and ATVing. Made our way here for lunch. We will be back. LOVE the Cranberry Chicken Salad on a Croissant bun! Only downside, the place was packed. Obviously others think it is great too!!! Highly recommend a stop here! Staff is amazing!
Everything is great! We love the Godfather sandwich! Great options ⭐️great staff ⭐️great menu!
Everything is fresh and always tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Get the smoked salmon salad it might be the best salad I’ve ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful local business in Eagle River, WI. I ordered a family order takeout a couple of days ahead of a family function and the team here came through! At pick-up, everything was well organized and the team was super friendly... but the food itself, that was the inspiration for a review. Everyone present raved about the grinders: fresh, tasty, great bread-to-meat-to-fixings ratios. I'll be back next time I'm in Eagle River!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awful service takes over 30 minutes to get a sandwich and you could hear them fighting in the kitchen
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best sub we've ever had! The bread is chewy and awesome,quality meats and toppings. The Godfather was outstanding and the cheese steak and cannoli so great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak, Cannoli
I ordered the NYC sandwich. It wasn't awful, but it also wasn't the most spectacular sandwich ever. It was a generous portion, though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
My husband and I visit every year while on vacation and cannot get enough of the cheesesteak (husband’s pick) and the chicken burrata (my pick). Do yourselves a favor and get ya one of each!
Food: 5
We had a wonderful lunch experience here. Cozy environment - super nice people and excellent food - Pretty Perfect! I'll definitely be back! Love it!
Restaurantji Recommends
We were hungry for pizza and this popped up on Google and we were NOT disappointed! The pizza crust was fantastic! Fresh ingredients were excellent! We will definitely be back! Thanks for the great lunch!
One of our team's personal favorites - we HIGHLY recommend Aiello's! Variety and deliciousness, what more do you need?! YUMMM!
Awesome sandwiches! Great food!
I am not one to write reviews, I've maybe only done it once before, but I'm just hugely disappointed. I've tried this place THREE times. The first 2 times were "ok" not great. My husband wanted to try it today. I was hesitant. At one register there was a woman talking so loudly on the phone, the other staff member could barely hear us to take our order. I asked for chili, and she said "anything else", I asked if they could make a simple croissant sandwich with ham and cheese. The worker stood there staring at the menu on the wall for a long time, and said "I don't know if we can do that". After waiting some more i said "nevermind, it's ok, just the chili". "That's it"? She asked. I said..I guess so 😔. I was frustrated. I'm also type 1 diabetic, my bloodsugar was going down, and I was starving. Good thing I grabbed a Sprite to drink to get some sugar in my system, because I couldn't eat the chili either. I didn't mind that it had black beans in it, but the bean flavor was overpowering, masking the taste of the other ingredients. The stools are also tiny and metal, making them very uncomfortable (Im not even a large person). I don't understand the appeal. It's not an issue of me having a poor taste palette either, I've eaten at establishments all over the country and 3 different countries. like I said, I don't leave reviews often, but 3 visits is enough for me.
Had their soups to stay, fantastic food and very nice server
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...