One of our team's personal favorites - we HIGHLY recommend Aiello's! Variety and deliciousness, what more do you need?! YUMMM!
Rachel Boehm
Awesome sandwiches! Great food!
Sara Grenier Harvey
I am not one to write reviews, I've maybe only done it once before, but I'm just hugely disappointed. I've tried this place THREE times. The first 2 times were "ok" not great. My husband wanted to try it today. I was hesitant. At one register there was a woman talking so loudly on the phone, the other staff member could barely hear us to take our order. I asked for chili, and she said "anything else", I asked if they could make a simple croissant sandwich with ham and cheese. The worker stood there staring at the menu on the wall for a long time, and said "I don't know if we can do that". After waiting some more i said "nevermind, it's ok, just the chili". "That's it"? She asked. I said..I guess so 😔. I was frustrated. I'm also type 1 diabetic, my bloodsugar was going down, and I was starving. Good thing I grabbed a Sprite to drink to get some sugar in my system, because I couldn't eat the chili either. I didn't mind that it had black beans in it, but the bean flavor was overpowering, masking the taste of the other ingredients. The stools are also tiny and metal, making them very uncomfortable (Im not even a large person). I don't understand the appeal. It's not an issue of me having a poor taste palette either, I've eaten at establishments all over the country and 3 different countries. like I said, I don't leave reviews often, but 3 visits is enough for me.
Austin S
Had their soups to stay, fantastic food and very nice server
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shane Ray
Finally, a restaurant in Eagle River that's doing something different.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Godfather Salad
Jerrod Aiello
Authentic Italian deli just like my mom use to make, literally.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Decker
Been several years since I wrote a review. This place warranted it. 1:30 in the afternoon and there was a line out the door. Worth it!! Had the chicken, cranberry, pecan wrap and the wife had chicken, pesto, burrata. Both were as big in flavor as they were in size! Delish! Son had the Neopolitan Pizza. Get to go back to try it myself since it was so good he finished it solo. Good food - Good tunes - Good vibes! Thanks Aiello's!
Such great food! From the sandwich choices to the homemade soups and sides... all amazing!! Great service with the friendliest staff. Super thankful we have such a quality place in the area. Great job guys!
Ace Christensen
Such a cute shop! The employees are very nice and service is pretty fast. Their pizza is amazing and their bread is to die for. The classic caprese sandwich had me meeting God it was so good. 10/10 you should definitely visit if you are in the area and are wanting to get lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Baguette, Classic Caprese, Neapolitan Pizza
Delicious lunch option in downtown Eagle River. Grinders are huge. Fresh and great value for the money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Van Raalte
Pizza is very good. Pepperoni are very thin and huge. Milwaukee pizza is very good. All pizza are Italian style. Neopolitan also great. The curry chicken sandwich is my fave but I substitute french bread.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bevy D
Have visited several times. The selections are wonderful and the food is delicious. It's our favorite dining place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela Anderson
Aiello’s catered my daughter’s graduation party. They were easy to work with and the food was outstanding. We had a pasta bar with bread and everything was delicious! Thanks, Aiello’s!
The Paulding Light Channel MelIssa G
My only go to for a sandwich in Eagle River! I keep wanting to try the pizza * (great prices) but always end up getting one of their many delicious sandwiches! Bailey is the best! Thanks for making great sandwiches!
One of our team's personal favorites - we HIGHLY recommend Aiello's! Variety and deliciousness, what more do you need?! YUMMM!
Awesome sandwiches! Great food!
I am not one to write reviews, I've maybe only done it once before, but I'm just hugely disappointed. I've tried this place THREE times. The first 2 times were "ok" not great. My husband wanted to try it today. I was hesitant. At one register there was a woman talking so loudly on the phone, the other staff member could barely hear us to take our order. I asked for chili, and she said "anything else", I asked if they could make a simple croissant sandwich with ham and cheese. The worker stood there staring at the menu on the wall for a long time, and said "I don't know if we can do that". After waiting some more i said "nevermind, it's ok, just the chili". "That's it"? She asked. I said..I guess so 😔. I was frustrated. I'm also type 1 diabetic, my bloodsugar was going down, and I was starving. Good thing I grabbed a Sprite to drink to get some sugar in my system, because I couldn't eat the chili either. I didn't mind that it had black beans in it, but the bean flavor was overpowering, masking the taste of the other ingredients. The stools are also tiny and metal, making them very uncomfortable (Im not even a large person). I don't understand the appeal. It's not an issue of me having a poor taste palette either, I've eaten at establishments all over the country and 3 different countries. like I said, I don't leave reviews often, but 3 visits is enough for me.
Had their soups to stay, fantastic food and very nice server
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finally, a restaurant in Eagle River that's doing something different.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Godfather Salad
Authentic Italian deli just like my mom use to make, literally.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been several years since I wrote a review. This place warranted it.
1:30 in the afternoon and there was a line out the door. Worth it!!
Had the chicken, cranberry, pecan wrap and the wife had chicken, pesto, burrata. Both were as big in flavor as they were in size! Delish!
Son had the Neopolitan Pizza. Get to go back to try it myself since it was so good he finished it solo.
Good food - Good tunes - Good vibes!
Thanks Aiello's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious salmon salad. Cute place. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such great food! From the sandwich choices to the homemade soups and sides... all amazing!! Great service with the friendliest staff. Super thankful we have such a quality place in the area. Great job guys!
Such a cute shop! The employees are very nice and service is pretty fast.
Their pizza is amazing and their bread is to die for. The classic caprese sandwich had me meeting God it was so good. 10/10 you should definitely visit if you are in the area and are wanting to get lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Baguette, Classic Caprese, Neapolitan Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious lunch option in downtown Eagle River. Grinders are huge. Fresh and great value for the money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is very good. Pepperoni are very thin and huge. Milwaukee pizza is very good. All pizza are Italian style. Neopolitan also great. The curry chicken sandwich is my fave but I substitute french bread.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have visited several times. The selections are wonderful and the food is delicious. It's our favorite dining place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aiello’s catered my daughter’s graduation party. They were easy to work with and the food was outstanding. We had a pasta bar with bread and everything was delicious! Thanks, Aiello’s!
My only go to for a sandwich in Eagle River! I keep wanting to try the pizza * (great prices) but always end up getting one of their many delicious sandwiches! Bailey is the best! Thanks for making great sandwiches!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...