Best Chicago style pizza in the whole region, next to actual Chicago pizzeria’s ! & Best lunch special in Madison
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sammy Jo
This is only the second time we have tried pizza extreme and it was terrible. The first time was great. I'm not sure what happened this time but the stuffed Hawaiian pizza was undercooked and not cut (and we did NOT choose the half baked option) the chicken tenders were undercooked and had no seasoning, as well as the chicken wings were under cooked and the sauce tasted strange. The cookie was good but its hard to mess up cookies.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Christine Encarnacion
I loved my first experience at pizza xtreme! The pizza and wings were so delicious and fresh and our server Sam was so attentive. He was knowledgeable and the perfect example of a perfect employee. GIVE HIM A RAISE!!!
Kim Edwards
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Great prices and amazing service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Megan Novotny
Ordering online is super easy but there must be something going on this week. I ordered a pizza yesterday and it took two hours to get to my house due to them having a lot of orders which is just unacceptable. Despite that experience I ordered again the next day to give it another try. I ordered a pizza and wings however the delivery driver gave me gyros instead. I called to try and either get a refund or credit and to get the food I originally ordered. I was told I could get either an over the phone credit or wait another hour for my wings to be delivered and keep the gyros. I would gladly return the gyros to get the wings I originally ordered. I decided to simply just wait for the wings another 30min to 1 hour but this is ridiculous. Why would I want an over the phone credit (which I’m not guaranteed they would honor) when I’ve already had two back to back negative experiences? Overall the pizza is really good. I have no notes for the customer service person I spoke to before the manager. But, the pizza is not that good. Maybe the in person experience is better but be wary if you are ordering delivery.
Rachel Meyer
Food was awful nothing but grease! Buffalo wings had no sauce on them. Food was cold. Go somewhere else.
Sebastian Hjertstedt
Cannot cook a pizza or issue a refund. What a joke. Manager was bad. The owner is an amazing guy though just the manager is terrible.
Marie Maki
Great little pizza place. Excellent pizza
Samuel Poirior
First time me and the lady have ever had deep dish. Both of us have been wanting to try it for a long time. Placed order over the phone. They were pretty busy when I arrived. Minimal staff pumping out orders. Staff was super kind. They were apologetic for the wait but it was really no problem with how busy they were. 11/10 the pizza was absolutely phenomenal. Some of the best we’ve had. Would recommend to everyone. Will be ordering again soon.
Unfortunately, the manager that spoke with me was very rude when I asked why they refused to deliver. It doesn't make sense to me.The owner of the Fish Hatcery location was phenomenal! Sadly, this is not the case for the Monroe St. location. The staff is not friendly, the service is poor, and they clearly are not seeking to maintain or even create good relationships with existing customers. The other places I called all told me to call this location and indicated they did indeed deliver my location 3 miles from them. That was not the case. I am very disappointed and disheartened in the service I rec'd. The business flat out refused to take my order.
Name
the taco pizza and cheese bread were awful. filled with grease, huge lettuce chunks in a side container, and just disgusting. everything tastes the same all I taste is grease. Also, who sends a taco pizza without salsa and sour cream? plain tortilla chips too? really? no seasoning, nothing. worst pizza I've had in a long time.
pizza was not sealed with door dash tab either for anyone who orders through the app.
Recommended dishes: Hand Tossed the Taco Pizza
Talissa Chapin
The wings were absolutely delicious. The deep dish wasn’t bad either.
Marion Drummer
This place is trash they have all these drinks cocktails mixers everything on the menu on the website they have this liquor they don't have anything to mix the drinks with no cups barely any ice I don't know how this place is open like seriously and someone told me to come here I will never be back this is a mess you have all of this liquor can't make a drink no soda nothing for the customers to even enjoy with their food this is crazy and I don't know how they have a 4.4 stars it must be just from the pizza and the wings that's it crazy and I don't know how they have a 4.4 stars it must be just from the pizza and the wings that's it
The gyros are very good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Chicago style pizza in the whole region, next to actual Chicago pizzeria’s !
& Best lunch special in Madison
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is only the second time we have tried pizza extreme and it was terrible. The first time was great. I'm not sure what happened this time but the stuffed Hawaiian pizza was undercooked and not cut (and we did NOT choose the half baked option) the chicken tenders were undercooked and had no seasoning, as well as the chicken wings were under cooked and the sauce tasted strange. The cookie was good but its hard to mess up cookies.
Food: 1
Service: 4
I loved my first experience at pizza xtreme! The pizza and wings were so delicious and fresh and our server Sam was so attentive. He was knowledgeable and the perfect example of a perfect employee. GIVE HIM A RAISE!!!
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Great prices and amazing service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordering online is super easy but there must be something going on this week. I ordered a pizza yesterday and it took two hours to get to my house due to them having a lot of orders which is just unacceptable. Despite that experience I ordered again the next day to give it another try. I ordered a pizza and wings however the delivery driver gave me gyros instead. I called to try and either get a refund or credit and to get the food I originally ordered. I was told I could get either an over the phone credit or wait another hour for my wings to be delivered and keep the gyros. I would gladly return the gyros to get the wings I originally ordered. I decided to simply just wait for the wings another 30min to 1 hour but this is ridiculous. Why would I want an over the phone credit (which I’m not guaranteed they would honor) when I’ve already had two back to back negative experiences? Overall the pizza is really good. I have no notes for the customer service person I spoke to before the manager. But, the pizza is not that good. Maybe the in person experience is better but be wary if you are ordering delivery.
Food was awful nothing but grease! Buffalo wings had no sauce on them. Food was cold. Go somewhere else.
Cannot cook a pizza or issue a refund. What a joke. Manager was bad. The owner is an amazing guy though just the manager is terrible.
Great little pizza place. Excellent pizza
First time me and the lady have ever had deep dish. Both of us have been wanting to try it for a long time. Placed order over the phone. They were pretty busy when I arrived. Minimal staff pumping out orders. Staff was super kind. They were apologetic for the wait but it was really no problem with how busy they were. 11/10 the pizza was absolutely phenomenal. Some of the best we’ve had. Would recommend to everyone. Will be ordering again soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Unfortunately, the manager that spoke with me was very rude when I asked why they refused to deliver. It doesn't make sense to me.The owner of the Fish Hatcery location was phenomenal! Sadly, this is not the case for the Monroe St. location. The staff is not friendly, the service is poor, and they clearly are not seeking to maintain or even create good relationships with existing customers. The other places I called all told me to call this location and indicated they did indeed deliver my location 3 miles from them. That was not the case. I am very disappointed and disheartened in the service I rec'd. The business flat out refused to take my order.
the taco pizza and cheese bread were awful. filled with grease, huge lettuce chunks in a side container, and just disgusting. everything tastes the same all I taste is grease. Also, who sends a taco pizza without salsa and sour cream? plain tortilla chips too? really? no seasoning, nothing. worst pizza I've had in a long time.
pizza was not sealed with door dash tab either for anyone who orders through the app.
Recommended dishes: Hand Tossed the Taco Pizza
The wings were absolutely delicious. The deep dish wasn’t bad either.
This place is trash they have all these drinks cocktails mixers everything on the menu on the website they have this liquor they don't have anything to mix the drinks with no cups barely any ice I don't know how this place is open like seriously and someone told me to come here I will never be back this is a mess you have all of this liquor can't make a drink no soda nothing for the customers to even enjoy with their food this is crazy and I don't know how they have a 4.4 stars it must be just from the pizza and the wings that's it crazy and I don't know how they have a 4.4 stars it must be just from the pizza and the wings that's it
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
I love breadsticks
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...