We love Pizza Extreme, but it's not close so it is a treat. I called for two stuffed deep dish pizzas with specific toppings 1/2 and 1/2. It came out to less than $10 per serving. They were perfect! Made with care and EXCELLENT! Harry was the person we talked to and who was making the pizzas. He was so nice and helpful. Pleasant experience and we've really enjoyed our dinner.Thank you!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Derek Novotny
Hard to find and only limited hours but the best deep dish pizza in Madison! Once you try it you won’t go anywhere
Food: 5
JASON YOGERST
A blast from my past. It has been over a decade since I had a Pizza Extreme stuffed pizza and, with only few exceptions, the current day held up to the lofty memory.I highly recommend getting some Pizza Extreme.-Location: Plenty of parking, easy access by car (Fitchburg)-Atmosphere: two wood benches, good smells, and friendly staff member-Food: Sausage, spinach, pineapple stuffed pizza. Loaded with a solid tasting mozzarella, a purely unique Pizza Extreme tomato sauce, and, I suspect, butter coated crust along the perimeter. Some of you may find my topping choice suspect, but it is a rare pizza which is equally enjoyable cold as warm since each topping has a different optimal temperature zone.The pizza was perfectly cooked. No uncooked dough and no burned crust. Some parts may have been getting close to burned, but no, it was perfectly timed and tasted to match.The smell of the pizza on my drive home was causing near distracted driving levels of olfactory enjoyment. Right to the nostalgia memory cells from a decade + ago. Surprised they were still around because I haven't used them again until today.The only difference from my memory is that this time the sausage was crumbled on the bottom, while I remember small sausage balls more intermixed or perhaps on a different layer. Negative, not quite as enjoyable texture wise. Positive, no way it isn't getting cooked properly.I could certainly make this longer if you truly like to read my thoughts, but I just really really enjoyed this pizza and how it remained almost unchanged for so long.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Hotba
Haters should die, frankly speaking. There's nowhere to get great pizza in Madison, period. Pizza Extreme is the closest. Anyone who disagrees with me probably has a metal rod stuck through their brain
Forms
The 6$ lunch special is extremely convenient and delicious two slices of your choice of pizza (deep dish included) with a can of soda. Little to no wait time usually.
L
A great place to ride( PASS ) gyros was terrible Italian beef nasty Also....never again ??????????
John Shea
Cannot beat two slices and a soda for $6 weekday carryout lunch special. Great slice variety and selection. Even try one or two slices of the delicious deep dish pies. Tons of food for the cost what a great value. Always friendly service! Thanks guys!
Kim Willis
Worst experience never will order again I really enjoyed but after my experience never again
Travis Klingaman
Great pizza and stix!
Kristopher Whitaker
This restaurant is my favorite site. Of all restaurants I know I like it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to that place. everytime I feel like having a special meal, this place comes first to my mind. superb and all sorts of food and a rich menu.great crew, and agreeable atmosphere. Also important, the tariff is decent. I praise this spot with no doubt.
We love Pizza Extreme, but it's not close so it is a treat. I called for two stuffed deep dish pizzas with specific toppings 1/2 and 1/2. It came out to less than $10 per serving. They were perfect! Made with care and EXCELLENT! Harry was the person we talked to and who was making the pizzas. He was so nice and helpful. Pleasant experience and we've really enjoyed our dinner.Thank you!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Hard to find and only limited hours but the best deep dish pizza in Madison! Once you try it you won’t go anywhere
Food: 5
A blast from my past. It has been over a decade since I had a Pizza Extreme stuffed pizza and, with only few exceptions, the current day held up to the lofty memory.I highly recommend getting some Pizza Extreme.-Location: Plenty of parking, easy access by car (Fitchburg)-Atmosphere: two wood benches, good smells, and friendly staff member-Food: Sausage, spinach, pineapple stuffed pizza. Loaded with a solid tasting mozzarella, a purely unique Pizza Extreme tomato sauce, and, I suspect, butter coated crust along the perimeter. Some of you may find my topping choice suspect, but it is a rare pizza which is equally enjoyable cold as warm since each topping has a different optimal temperature zone.The pizza was perfectly cooked. No uncooked dough and no burned crust. Some parts may have been getting close to burned, but no, it was perfectly timed and tasted to match.The smell of the pizza on my drive home was causing near distracted driving levels of olfactory enjoyment. Right to the nostalgia memory cells from a decade + ago. Surprised they were still around because I haven't used them again until today.The only difference from my memory is that this time the sausage was crumbled on the bottom, while I remember small sausage balls more intermixed or perhaps on a different layer. Negative, not quite as enjoyable texture wise. Positive, no way it isn't getting cooked properly.I could certainly make this longer if you truly like to read my thoughts, but I just really really enjoyed this pizza and how it remained almost unchanged for so long.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Haters should die, frankly speaking. There's nowhere to get great pizza in Madison, period. Pizza Extreme is the closest. Anyone who disagrees with me probably has a metal rod stuck through their brain
The 6$ lunch special is extremely convenient and delicious two slices of your choice of pizza (deep dish included) with a can of soda. Little to no wait time usually.
A great place to ride( PASS ) gyros was terrible Italian beef nasty Also....never again ??????????
Cannot beat two slices and a soda for $6 weekday carryout lunch special. Great slice variety and selection. Even try one or two slices of the delicious deep dish pies. Tons of food for the cost what a great value. Always friendly service! Thanks guys!
Worst experience never will order again I really enjoyed but after my experience never again
Great pizza and stix!
This restaurant is my favorite site. Of all restaurants I know I like it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to that place. everytime I feel like having a special meal, this place comes first to my mind. superb and all sorts of food and a rich menu.great crew, and agreeable atmosphere. Also important, the tariff is decent. I praise this spot with no doubt.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love the stuffed pizza and the fried chicken wings
Excellent deep dish pizza!!
Excellent food and service I received from here will order again
Nice employees stayed open till I picked up my pizza at closing time and we appreciate them for doing so.
Great place to stop for lunch in and out, always leave full for cheap