This place is truly a treasure hidden in Fort Atkinson. I've only had the pleasure of coming here a handful of times (I live out of state now) but it's always amazing when we're able to get a reservation. In some of the negative reviews people mentioned the wait time to get food, I however think that's a huge plus. The wait time was definitely longer than most restaurants I've been to but that gave my family and I uninterrupted time to catch up which can be hard when everyone is already eating. It also made me feel good knowing a lot of time and love were going into our meals. The only slight negative i could imagine is the menu can be intimidating if youre a vegetarian. Im assuming the chef is open to making items vegetarian but i didnt ask because the funghi immediately captured my attention and my heart (it was AMAZING) Our server was an absolute pleasure and meeting chef Eric made our meal that much better. If you're in the mood for delicious, comforting, amazing Italian food you must give this place a try.
Tanya S. Wilburn
Very intimate space.
Amber Meyer
This was our first time here and my husband and I had a lovely experience. We were able to get a reservation for our valentines dinner due to a cancelation which worked out great for us! The atmosphere was intimate and calming. Our server, Sam, was the only one working the front and did an outstanding job. He was very personable and worked hard to make each guests experience a positive one. Our drinks, appetizer, salad, and main course were delicious and came out fairly quick. We look forward to coming back again and trying more off the menu and some desserts too! We even bought a jar of the homemade marinara sauce and we can't wait to try it at home. Definitely recommend trying this place if you haven't yet!
Caela Brooke
Our first experience on New Years Eve was phenomenal. The atmosphere was so cozy and intimate. The service was great, our server was the only one working and he was busting his butt. The food was beyond compare… it tasted like true homemade Italian dishes. You could tell it was made with love and experience. The owner, Eric, came to every table and spoke with the patrons. He really shows his passion for his restaurant and his customers. We can’t wait to dine here again! Highly recommend the goat cheese dip and Arrabbiata pasta. SO GOOD!
Kris Dassow
Excellent food and service was outstanding !! Sam was very personable and we can’t wait to go back again 🩷
Kaiden Schneider
This place is amazing, I was in italy last year and the atmosphere and food that this restaurant reminded me of Italy. The waiter sam was very knowledgeable and definitely made the experience a 10/10
Robert Davidson
Delishish food. Never disappoints
Susan Kindschi
An intimate atmosphere to share a leisurely meal! Our dinners were delicious, generous but not overly so. Enough for take home lunch. Our waiter, Sam, was knowledgeable and attentive. Chef Eric checked on us as well to insure we were happy with our evening. Would highly recommend Mangiami's to everyone
fatty1569
The BEST Italian I've ever had. Our server Sam was beyond nice & attentive. We will be back many many times. You really need to dine here!!!
Flavors you get in Italy are served in this very fine restaurant. Presentation is lovely. Service is outstanding. Intimate atmosphere invites one to sit back, relax and enjoy fine dining.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathryn Anderson
This place is amazing! We took a large group from work here on a Thursday night for a celebratory dinner and couldn't have been more pleased. The restaurant was so accommodating, the food was fantastic, the ambiance and setting was perfect - we enjoyed everything about this visit. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!
Food is delicious and reasonably priced.
This place is truly a treasure hidden in Fort Atkinson. I've only had the pleasure of coming here a handful of times (I live out of state now) but it's always amazing when we're able to get a reservation. In some of the negative reviews people mentioned the wait time to get food, I however think that's a huge plus. The wait time was definitely longer than most restaurants I've been to but that gave my family and I uninterrupted time to catch up which can be hard when everyone is already eating. It also made me feel good knowing a lot of time and love were going into our meals. The only slight negative i could imagine is the menu can be intimidating if youre a vegetarian. Im assuming the chef is open to making items vegetarian but i didnt ask because the funghi immediately captured my attention and my heart (it was AMAZING) Our server was an absolute pleasure and meeting chef Eric made our meal that much better. If you're in the mood for delicious, comforting, amazing Italian food you must give this place a try.
Very intimate space.
This was our first time here and my husband and I had a lovely experience. We were able to get a reservation for our valentines dinner due to a cancelation which worked out great for us! The atmosphere was intimate and calming. Our server, Sam, was the only one working the front and did an outstanding job. He was very personable and worked hard to make each guests experience a positive one. Our drinks, appetizer, salad, and main course were delicious and came out fairly quick. We look forward to coming back again and trying more off the menu and some desserts too! We even bought a jar of the homemade marinara sauce and we can't wait to try it at home. Definitely recommend trying this place if you haven't yet!
Our first experience on New Years Eve was phenomenal. The atmosphere was so cozy and intimate. The service was great, our server was the only one working and he was busting his butt. The food was beyond compare… it tasted like true homemade Italian dishes. You could tell it was made with love and experience. The owner, Eric, came to every table and spoke with the patrons. He really shows his passion for his restaurant and his customers. We can’t wait to dine here again! Highly recommend the goat cheese dip and Arrabbiata pasta. SO GOOD!
Excellent food and service was outstanding !! Sam was very personable and we can’t wait to go back again 🩷
This place is amazing, I was in italy last year and the atmosphere and food that this restaurant reminded me of Italy. The waiter sam was very knowledgeable and definitely made the experience a 10/10
Delishish food. Never disappoints
An intimate atmosphere to share a leisurely meal!
Our dinners were delicious, generous but not overly so. Enough for take home lunch. Our waiter, Sam, was knowledgeable and attentive.
Chef Eric checked on us as well to insure we were happy with our evening. Would highly recommend Mangiami's to everyone
The BEST Italian I've ever had. Our server Sam was beyond nice & attentive. We will be back many many times. You really need to dine here!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Flavors you get in Italy are served in this very fine restaurant. Presentation is lovely. Service is outstanding. Intimate atmosphere invites one to sit back, relax and enjoy fine dining.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is amazing! We took a large group from work here on a Thursday night for a celebratory dinner and couldn't have been more pleased. The restaurant was so accommodating, the food was fantastic, the ambiance and setting was perfect - we enjoyed everything about this visit. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent homemade cook to order food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta, Spinach Artichoke Dip
Dined at Mangiami to celebrate two birthdays. Everyone’s meal was fabulous! Excellent wine selection and desserts are wonderful as well. Ciao!
There with a wedding rehearsal dinner group. Great place, good food. Looking forward to going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...