Would you like to eat a perfectly cooked fillet mignon that is better than Eddie Martini's in Milwaukee, Gibsons in Chicago, or Ruth's Chris?
Feast your eyes on the 12 oz fillet I had tonight for just $48 which included everything: a relish tray, and salad, and soup, and choice of potato. Medium rare, cooked to perfection and unbelievably tender!
Not to mention an excellent Korbel old-fashioned and all of the classic ice cream drinks you only find a true supper club.
Wherever you live on this planet, Stagecoach is worth the drive!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K Saber
Excellent food & service! Sadly they need a bigger location, as they really could use more room & a larger bar. Highly recommend trying if you have not yet!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rocky Polster
We had to wait 40+ min past our reservation to be seated, while other groups of similar size walked in and had tables moved for them. Then, we had another hour+wait for food. The relish trays left a lot to be desired. 2 of the 3 were just a vegetable in heavy mayo, and the 3rd was beans. When the food finally showed up there was no recollection or order to who ordered what, so when it was brought to the table, they just waited for someone to claim it. One steak came out well instead of medium rare, but the staff quickly replaced it with the correct temp steak. The quality of the main dishes was good. The steaks and lobster were flavorful and cooked well.
Megan Schultz
Drove 50 minutes for dinner, arrived at 4:30pm. Was told we could not be served until 8pm. We were only party of 3. If you’re going to require reservations, maybe you should post that to google or your website.
Service: 1
Burnie Bailey
Been coming here for years. They all are like family to me. Best supper club in Wisconsin as far as I'm concerned. Quality food at a reasonable price. Can't say enough good things about this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Schuett - Freight Patrol LLC
Great place to eat. Service is awesome and jenny the bartender can mix some excellent ice cream drinks
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynn Gustafson
The Stagecoach reminded me of a Wisconsin supper club with good food, friendly staff, and pleasant atmosphere. The fall decor with lots of orange lights was welcoming. The decorations and lights change with each season. We did have a reservation and were seated promptly upon our arrival. The food was not fancy or pretentious, but it was served piping hot and just as I had ordered it. I had the steak and shrimp special, and it was delicious. It came with soup or salad and a choice of potato, along with au just for the steak and cocktail sauce for the shrimp. The breading on the shrimp was just enough to make it crunchy and flavorful. The cocktail sauce was an excellent accompaniment. Our waitress Amy was pleasant and helpful, checking back with us as needed and willingly taking a couple photos of our group. We mentioned that 2 of the group were celebrating birthdays, and our dessert came with candles for those 2 people. The prices were very reasonable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Nuss
Great classic supper club, bonus points for not having the sleazy gaming machines. Great prime rib!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Luke Vrooman
So disappointed after reading all the reviews about this place. I went with a group of 5, and we all ordered something different. Only 1 of the 5 enjoyed their meal. I ordered the fish fry perch and it was overly fried--the batter was almost black. Someone else ordered the 1lb king crab and the crab they received was tiny and definitely not 1lb. Another ordered the baked cod and it was dry and bland. I also ordered onion rings but never received them.
The waitress and atmosphere was super great, but the food was a big miss, unfortunately. Which was super disappointing given we drove 45 minutes just to try this place.
Great Food and Service. Angel our server was EXCELLENT! Walleye, crab legs steak all. EXCELLENT!!!! Old Fashion and Grasshopper all GREAT.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
KerryMichelle EDM
Fantastic service and food. Old school supper club vibes
Tammy
Excellent experience food service atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon S.
My wife and I were headed home from a night of shopping. I was looking for an affordable steak house and boy did I ever find it! Our server Leslie was incredible, sweet and attentive. Our food was cooked to perfection and everything we ordered was exactly to our liking. We are so happy we found this place and will be returning. 4 drinks and 2 filet and shrimp dinners for 80 dollars is unheard of in today's market. Don't let this gem fall to the way side Wisconsin. Go try it, you won't be disappointed. This supper club is exactly what we were looking for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Au Gratin Potatoes, Steak and Shrimp Special
Great place good food decent price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Would you like to eat a perfectly cooked fillet mignon that is better than Eddie Martini's in Milwaukee, Gibsons in Chicago, or Ruth's Chris?
Feast your eyes on the 12 oz fillet I had tonight for just $48 which included everything: a relish tray, and salad, and soup, and choice of potato. Medium rare, cooked to perfection and unbelievably tender!
Not to mention an excellent Korbel old-fashioned and all of the classic ice cream drinks you only find a true supper club.
Wherever you live on this planet, Stagecoach is worth the drive!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food & service! Sadly they need a bigger location, as they really could use more room & a larger bar. Highly recommend trying if you have not yet!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had to wait 40+ min past our reservation to be seated, while other groups of similar size walked in and had tables moved for them. Then, we had another hour+wait for food. The relish trays left a lot to be desired. 2 of the 3 were just a vegetable in heavy mayo, and the 3rd was beans. When the food finally showed up there was no recollection or order to who ordered what, so when it was brought to the table, they just waited for someone to claim it. One steak came out well instead of medium rare, but the staff quickly replaced it with the correct temp steak. The quality of the main dishes was good. The steaks and lobster were flavorful and cooked well.
Drove 50 minutes for dinner, arrived at 4:30pm. Was told we could not be served until 8pm. We were only party of 3. If you’re going to require reservations, maybe you should post that to google or your website.
Service: 1
Been coming here for years. They all are like family to me. Best supper club in Wisconsin as far as I'm concerned. Quality food at a reasonable price. Can't say enough good things about this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place to eat. Service is awesome and jenny the bartender can mix some excellent ice cream drinks
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Stagecoach reminded me of a Wisconsin supper club with good food, friendly staff, and pleasant atmosphere. The fall decor with lots of orange lights was welcoming. The decorations and lights change with each season. We did have a reservation and were seated promptly upon our arrival. The food was not fancy or pretentious, but it was served piping hot and just as I had ordered it. I had the steak and shrimp special, and it was delicious. It came with soup or salad and a choice of potato, along with au just for the steak and cocktail sauce for the shrimp. The breading on the shrimp was just enough to make it crunchy and flavorful. The cocktail sauce was an excellent accompaniment. Our waitress Amy was pleasant and helpful, checking back with us as needed and willingly taking a couple photos of our group. We mentioned that 2 of the group were celebrating birthdays, and our dessert came with candles for those 2 people. The prices were very reasonable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great classic supper club, bonus points for not having the sleazy gaming machines. Great prime rib!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
So disappointed after reading all the reviews about this place. I went with a group of 5, and we all ordered something different. Only 1 of the 5 enjoyed their meal. I ordered the fish fry perch and it was overly fried--the batter was almost black. Someone else ordered the 1lb king crab and the crab they received was tiny and definitely not 1lb. Another ordered the baked cod and it was dry and bland. I also ordered onion rings but never received them.
The waitress and atmosphere was super great, but the food was a big miss, unfortunately. Which was super disappointing given we drove 45 minutes just to try this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Always the best. My favorite supper club!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Food and Service. Angel our server was EXCELLENT! Walleye, crab legs steak all. EXCELLENT!!!! Old Fashion and Grasshopper all GREAT.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic service and food. Old school supper club vibes
Excellent experience food service atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I were headed home from a night of shopping. I was looking for an affordable steak house and boy did I ever find it! Our server Leslie was incredible, sweet and attentive. Our food was cooked to perfection and everything we ordered was exactly to our liking. We are so happy we found this place and will be returning. 4 drinks and 2 filet and shrimp dinners for 80 dollars is unheard of in today's market. Don't let this gem fall to the way side Wisconsin. Go try it, you won't be disappointed. This supper club is exactly what we were looking for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Au Gratin Potatoes, Steak and Shrimp Special
Loading...