Sally's Sweet Shoppe
S42 W31238, WI-83, Genesee Depot
(262) 968-1803
Recent Reviews
Sort by
S42 W31238, WI-83, Genesee Depot
(262) 968-1803
Sally was great and our cake and cupcakes were perfect. The cake was moist and full of flavor. Overall easy ordering, just filled out a form and she went from there. Thanks again.
She did it again! Excellent customer service. Beautiful cake & cupcakes. Mel you out did yourself thank you 🧡
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cakes, Cupcake
I have been craving old fashioned style turtles with caramel and chocolate on the bed of pecans or cashews and they had exactly what I was looking for old fashioned style, not those pretty shaped and painted designs but the yummy good old fashioned stuff. They also sell brownies and cookies and cinnamon rolls and cakes of all kinds cupcakes. It's a lot more. Everything is so yummy and they're such friendly, sweet people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cakes, Cupcake
Sally and her team have been AMAZING to us the last 3 years we have been using them!
We had the most beautiful first fiesta cake for my daughter’s birthday. It was beyond my expectations and everyone raved about it. Thank you so much!!
Everything I’ve ever had from Sally Sweet Shoppe has been absolutely incredible! A co-worker frequently brings in an assortment of their sweet treats, and every single time, they’re a hit with the entire team. The quality, flavor, and creativity in their desserts are unmatched—truly a must-try for anyone with a sweet tooth!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The strawberry rhubarb pie is phenomenal
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sally's doesn't miss. We've only lived in the area for a year, but we've used Sally's for every birthday in the family this year.
The cakes are absolutely delicious. They simply nail it on the custom orders. The devil is in the details, as long as you fill out their custom order form and provide as much detail as possible, they can accommodate most requests and designs. Give them a reasonable time frame and they gotchu!
Don't miss out on their ham and rolls Sundays, perfect grab and go. Plenty of other delictables as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Doughnut, Sheet Cake, Cupcake, Birthday Cake, Cakes
We had purchased a customized Disney Frozen cake. Was a beautiful cake. My daughters smile that was provided was amazing. The cake flavor itself was pretty bad. Lacked flavor and the cake was dry. No one in my family would eat it. We brought it to other families houses to try it to make sure it wasn't us and they agreed it wasn't good. We ended up throwing the cake away. Appearance was amazing but for the price of the cake and it being well cake, I wouldve expected my kids and other kids to want another piece. Instead they didn't finish one slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Sally’s Sweet Shop did a fantastic job on my Mother in Law’s 90th birthday cake and mini cupcakes. Her favorite cake is carrot cake, it was so beautiful and delicious, there were no leftovers! Sally’s Sweet Shop was easy to work with and definitely high quality cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely fantastic assortment of baked goods and confections, from cupcakes to candy bars. We tried a little of everything, cookies, crumb cake, and a hot cup of coffee. Laura, who was baking fresh cookies while we talked, was extremely friendly and informative. We drove 2 hours to get here and were not disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Cakes
Our family ordered a cake to serve at our 70th wedding anniversary and 90th birthdays celebration. Truly it was the most delicious cake we could have asked for ‼️The cake was beautifully decorated and such a treat for us all. Thank you for helping to make our family time together PERFECT?‼️?
Food: 5
Cupcakes were delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came across Sally's as we were researching bakeries for our wedding. We loved what we read in reviews and saw on their website so we decided to reach out and I am glad we did. Sally is AMAZING to work with and has insanely quick response times (and I thought I was fast at responding). It was a great experience working with her for how many cakes we wanted (we decided to do a cake table) and in what flavors as well as getting the Gluten Free Friendly cupcakes.
Everything was an absolute hit and people couldn't stop raving about the deliciousness of the cakes and cupcakes! There wasn't a single crumb left!
We did stop in and get a variety of cupcakes to take home and try as well and we still can't decide which flavor was our favorite.
We will definitely be life long customers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Wedding Cake
We came across Sally's as we were researching bakeries for our wedding. We loved what we read in reviews and saw on their website so we decided to reach out and I am glad we did. Sally is AMAZING to work with and has insanely quick response times (and I thought I was fast at responding). It was a great experience working with her for how many cakes we wanted (we decided to do a cake table) and in what flavors as well as getting the Gluten Free Friendly cupcakes.
Everything was an absolute hit and people couldn't stop raving about the deliciousness of the cakes and cupcakes! There wasn't a single crumb left!
We did stop in and get a variety of cupcakes to take home and try as well and we still can't decide which flavor was our favorite.
We will definitely be life long customers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Wedding Cake
Loading...