This restaurant is a gem. Unique house that has been fitted up as a restaurant. Excellent boiled fish bit the chicken and ribs are exceptional too.
Definitely worth a try. I will be back.
Colleen Bragg
This place has great food with a great atmosphere! If you are looking for a fancy upscale place, this is not it, but they have great food in a historic house. I enjoyed their fish, which was fabulous in their melted butter. Their potatoes and onions are great, as well as their cole slaw. My friends and husband enjoyed their chicken and ribs. They said it was great!!!
They do NOT take credit cards, so remember your cash!!!
John C
Phenomenal. Good is great. Service is good. I love their corned beef and the fish is always amazing. Highly recommend getting here early. Great outdoor seating as well.
andrew vaughan
Such great food! We will always be back!
Amanda R Duncan
I have been there several times over the past 25 years, and the food has changed a bit. The night we went, they didn't seem to have enough food or staff. We left full though and the food was okay, but I feel it was better in the past. Could have been because we came the last 2 hours they were open.
Tania Gerken
It worth the visit
Marianne Jensen
This is the best Fish Boil ever.
Scott Detienne
Amazing fish boil! Ribs and chicken are delicious too. A steal for all you can eat.
Stanley Nienhaus
The boiled fish is awesome. It's all you can eat,fish,small red potatoes,whole onions, coleslaw with as much butter poured on it as you want with an apple type dessert. Believe me, your stomach feels like it's going to bust when you're finished. For different prices, you can also get BBQ chicken and ribs.
Ray Lewandowski
It’s a unique experience especially if it’s your first time there, watching the cook perform the fish boil outside was very interesting and entertaining. Huge thumbs up to the cook it’s a lot of work.
I'm not sure why there are so many 5 star reviews about this place. I went there last evening for the fish boil, my daughter got ribs and my wife got the fish and chicken. I got one tiny piece of fish, one potato, a part of an onion and coleslaw. The fish was bland, my daughters ribs were charcoal, and my wife got a chicken leg that was so sad and pathetic, that I nearly went back to ask for a refund. If you want more variety and slightly better food, the Fire Pit is a much better choice. We walked away very disappointed. At least we gave it a try.
Also, there is no refills on non-alcoholic drinks!
Copcar Ranch
YUM! Fish boil is wonderful, and the ribs and chicken are excellent! We'll be back.
Noonereally
Great food, very reasonably priced, good service. You won’t be disappointed!!! I highly recommend
Pierce Barker
This is the second time we’ve been to Fitzgerald‘s. People are great. The prices are reasonable, and the food is wonderful. More than a 1 Hour drive for us and worth every mile.
Michael Koziol
This place was fantastic, a great Wisconsin feel and experience. The atmosphere in this old house with old time wall paper and an early 20th century feel was special. The food was wonderful and at such a low price point. We were very happy and will continue to come back next time we visit the area!!
This restaurant is a gem. Unique house that has been fitted up as a restaurant. Excellent boiled fish bit the chicken and ribs are exceptional too.
Definitely worth a try. I will be back.
This place has great food with a great atmosphere! If you are looking for a fancy upscale place, this is not it, but they have great food in a historic house. I enjoyed their fish, which was fabulous in their melted butter. Their potatoes and onions are great, as well as their cole slaw. My friends and husband enjoyed their chicken and ribs. They said it was great!!!
They do NOT take credit cards, so remember your cash!!!
Phenomenal. Good is great. Service is good. I love their corned beef and the fish is always amazing. Highly recommend getting here early. Great outdoor seating as well.
Such great food! We will always be back!
I have been there several times over the past 25 years, and the food has changed a bit. The night we went, they didn't seem to have enough food or staff. We left full though and the food was okay, but I feel it was better in the past. Could have been because we came the last 2 hours they were open.
It worth the visit
This is the best Fish Boil ever.
Amazing fish boil! Ribs and chicken are delicious too. A steal for all you can eat.
The boiled fish is awesome. It's all you can eat,fish,small red potatoes,whole onions, coleslaw with as much butter poured on it as you want with an apple type dessert. Believe me, your stomach feels like it's going to bust when you're finished. For different prices, you can also get BBQ chicken and ribs.
It’s a unique experience especially if it’s your first time there, watching the cook perform the fish boil outside was very interesting and entertaining. Huge thumbs up to the cook it’s a lot of work.
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm not sure why there are so many 5 star reviews about this place. I went there last evening for the fish boil, my daughter got ribs and my wife got the fish and chicken. I got one tiny piece of fish, one potato, a part of an onion and coleslaw. The fish was bland, my daughters ribs were charcoal, and my wife got a chicken leg that was so sad and pathetic, that I nearly went back to ask for a refund.
If you want more variety and slightly better food, the Fire Pit is a much better choice.
We walked away very disappointed. At least we gave it a try.
Also, there is no refills on non-alcoholic drinks!
YUM! Fish boil is wonderful, and the ribs and chicken are excellent! We'll be back.
Great food, very reasonably priced, good service. You won’t be disappointed!!! I highly recommend
This is the second time we’ve been to Fitzgerald‘s. People are great. The prices are reasonable, and the food is wonderful. More than a 1 Hour drive for us and worth every mile.
This place was fantastic, a great Wisconsin feel and experience. The atmosphere in this old house with old time wall paper and an early 20th century feel was special. The food was wonderful and at such a low price point. We were very happy and will continue to come back next time we visit the area!!
Loading...