5-Star Review: A Perfect Night Out for All Four of Us! We had an absolutely fantastic dinner to celebrate my birthday! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm hospitality and seated quickly. The atmosphere was cozy yet modern, making it a great spot for a relaxed evening out. We each ordered different dishes, and every single one was delicious - they even provide a slice of a birthday dessert with a candle on top!
Diane Krueger
Great food, friendly staff, highly recommend!
Elizabeth Borst
This is our second time at Relish Supper Club. So glad we gave it a second chance. We love the quality of the food (best in the area) and the service. What we did not like was the noise level the first time- BUT - they fixed the problem. The dining experience now is totally enjoyable. Thank you! And we will be back, again and again. Tony, our server, was exceptional.
GrantB
Phenomenal food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Relish Bar
Tamra Tamra
Fabulous food, service and atmosphere. You MUST try this restaurant, guarantee you’ll be back many times!! A++++
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nikki Werra
My boyfriend and I went out to Relish Supper Club last night for dinner. It was outstanding!! The atmosphere was beautiful, service was excellent, but the food is what shined the brightest. My boyfriend said his filet was delicious. I chose the prime rib and it did not disappoint. It was extremely flavorful all the way through, so tender, and much leaner than typical prime rib slices I've had elsewhere. Both meats were prepared exactly to our requested medium rare temperature. I also had grilled asparagus spears that were perfectly prepared and still crisp. Finally, let's talk butter. Wow! I never knew farm-fresh butter was so delicious. Extremely impressed. We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Filet
Michael Zeman
The Relish bar was awesome! Service, the cheese beer soup, and the filet I had, great. But the prime rib my friend had wasn't so good. Ordered rare, it was served grey in color. I said, "Send it back," but she said she'd cut and try it. It was a bit pink inside but the grey outside looked terrible and the taste wasn't any better. We had a 415pm reservation, so it was one of the 1st served. Not sure what caused a grey color, microwaved or what. But it shouldn't have been served. I'd try Relish again but stay away from the Saturday special, prime rib.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Relish Bar, Beer Cheese Soup
Torie Shea Lindoerfer
The crab stuffed shrimp pasta was incredible. The fish fry is the best around. This place makes me so happy, from the romantic atmosphere to the staff. Top notch everything!
Dewayne Evins
We decided to try Relish Supper Club tonight and it was truly an uplifting experience. Drinks were exceptionally good. Orders were 2 Relish Ol Fashion, a Blackberry Ol’ Fashion, and a Chardonnay, and that Blackberry Ol Fashion was 🔥!! I could have savored many more, if I wasn’t the driver. The food ordered was a filet(med rare), Sirloin (med rare), NY Strip (Med) and fried shrimp. All were outstanding. We also got their relish bar buffet, which had WI Cheese, butter, beets, pickles, and other items you’d get on a relish tray. After dinner drink was a delightful Cherry Amaretto ice cream drink, Cheese cake and Carrot Cake. I believe the ice cream drink was the favorite. Our server Tony did a phenomenal job. The place was fantastic for a party of 4, we could all have a conversation without having to shout at each other. Will have to come and try again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Relish Tray Buffet, Relish Bar
Paula Barrett
We were five friends going for dinner at 6:15 Saturday night. The service was great, the food was great, parking was easy, but the noise level made the experience unpleasant. We had to yell to hear each other. Table conversation was nearly impossible. The dining room is a large open space with all hard surfaces and a wooden ceiling in some places and metal ceiling in other places. I will not go back unless I hear they remodeled. At a supper club, I would like to be able to relax and have pleasant conversation with my friends.
I don't know what they were when they first opened, but they are NOT a supper club now. They are a crowded bar with a restaurant that is SO loud we had to yell to the person sitting next to us at the table to hear each other. It was headache inducing so I ate fast to get out of there. The only place I could hear myself think was the restroom, and once in there I didn't want to go back out in the chaos. A supper club provides a relish tray on the table. They provide a relish bar that costs extra if you want to go get stuff yourself. Disappointing.
Now to the positive.
The service was outstanding. I repeated our server's name in my head a few times, but have since forgotten it - we went Saturday night and it's now Monday morning. Probably ran from the noise...hehehe. He was charming, friendly, attentive, non-intrusive; all the things you want when spending money on a night out to eat. It was a full house, but we never had to track him down for anything. Would definitely want him as our server again.
The food was delicious. Among the five us, three had the Prime Rib, one had the New York, and I had the Glazed Ribs. Everyone enjoyed their food. The bread put on the table was warm and inviting. My pre-dinner drink was the Mudslide. Yummy. The first course salads were more than just a typical house salad of lettuce and tomato. Interesting ingredients that I've never had, but very good and made for a very well balanced flavor profile. The ribs were very tender and fell off the bone. It was a full slab so I took much home for lunch Sunday, along with half my baked potato which I ordered loaded. One thing needing to be improved here is that each person should receive their OWN butter and sour cream when ordered as we did have to continually request more.
Wheelchair accessibility: Main entrance has stairs. Unknown if there is another entrance accessible to chairs.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ribs
Linda P
We were seated right at our reservation time, very friendly staff all around. Enjoyed delicious well made old fashions, onion rings appetizer (highly recommend), fish fry with potato pancakes and the schnitzel with mashed potatoes.....both entrees were delicious! Shout out to Becca, our server, who was very attentive and kind...treating my husband to a piece of carrot cake for his birthday 🎂.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Schnitzel, Onion Rings
Mary Neveln
The Thursday Special, Wiener Schnitzel with Spaetzle, was outstanding -- and a huge portion! My husband had the rack of ribs with the French Onion Soup. The ribs were fork-tender, and the soup tasty! Wide selection of beverages; I had the Alaskan Amber, which was so good! The beer garden next door was also open (55° in January!).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristi G.
Stopped in for drinks yesterday evening. Beautiful atmosphere; very classy, clean and warmly decorated. Ashley and Michael were both professional, outgoing, and friendly. Husband had his first whiskey old fashioned made by Ashley - excellent drink! Reviewed the menu, looking forward to visiting in the near future for dinner.
5-Star Review: A Perfect Night Out for All Four of Us! We had an absolutely fantastic dinner to celebrate my birthday! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm hospitality and seated quickly. The atmosphere was cozy yet modern, making it a great spot for a relaxed evening out. We each ordered different dishes, and every single one was delicious - they even provide a slice of a birthday dessert with a candle on top!
Great food, friendly staff, highly recommend!
This is our second time at Relish Supper Club. So glad we gave it a second chance. We love the quality of the food (best in the area) and the service. What we did not like was the noise level the first time- BUT - they fixed the problem. The dining experience now is totally enjoyable. Thank you! And we will be back, again and again. Tony, our server, was exceptional.
Phenomenal food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Relish Bar
Fabulous food, service and atmosphere. You MUST try this restaurant, guarantee you’ll be back many times!! A++++
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My boyfriend and I went out to Relish Supper Club last night for dinner. It was outstanding!! The atmosphere was beautiful, service was excellent, but the food is what shined the brightest. My boyfriend said his filet was delicious. I chose the prime rib and it did not disappoint. It was extremely flavorful all the way through, so tender, and much leaner than typical prime rib slices I've had elsewhere. Both meats were prepared exactly to our requested medium rare temperature. I also had grilled asparagus spears that were perfectly prepared and still crisp. Finally, let's talk butter. Wow! I never knew farm-fresh butter was so delicious. Extremely impressed. We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Filet
The Relish bar was awesome! Service, the cheese beer soup, and the filet I had, great. But the prime rib my friend had wasn't so good. Ordered rare, it was served grey in color. I said, "Send it back," but she said she'd cut and try it. It was a bit pink inside but the grey outside looked terrible and the taste wasn't any better. We had a 415pm reservation, so it was one of the 1st served. Not sure what caused a grey color, microwaved or what. But it shouldn't have been served. I'd try Relish again but stay away from the Saturday special, prime rib.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Relish Bar, Beer Cheese Soup
The crab stuffed shrimp pasta was incredible. The fish fry is the best around. This place makes me so happy, from the romantic atmosphere to the staff. Top notch everything!
We decided to try Relish Supper Club tonight and it was truly an uplifting experience. Drinks were exceptionally good. Orders were 2 Relish Ol Fashion, a Blackberry Ol’ Fashion, and a Chardonnay, and that Blackberry Ol Fashion was 🔥!! I could have savored many more, if I wasn’t the driver. The food ordered was a filet(med rare), Sirloin (med rare), NY Strip (Med) and fried shrimp. All were outstanding. We also got their relish bar buffet, which had WI Cheese, butter, beets, pickles, and other items you’d get on a relish tray. After dinner drink was a delightful Cherry Amaretto ice cream drink, Cheese cake and Carrot Cake. I believe the ice cream drink was the favorite. Our server Tony did a phenomenal job. The place was fantastic for a party of 4, we could all have a conversation without having to shout at each other. Will have to come and try again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Relish Tray Buffet, Relish Bar
We were five friends going for dinner at 6:15 Saturday night. The service was great, the food was great, parking was easy, but the noise level made the experience unpleasant. We had to yell to hear each other. Table conversation was nearly impossible. The dining room is a large open space with all hard surfaces and a wooden ceiling in some places and metal ceiling in other places. I will not go back unless I hear they remodeled. At a supper club, I would like to be able to relax and have pleasant conversation with my friends.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I don't know what they were when they first opened, but they are NOT a supper club now. They are a crowded bar with a restaurant that is SO loud we had to yell to the person sitting next to us at the table to hear each other. It was headache inducing so I ate fast to get out of there. The only place I could hear myself think was the restroom, and once in there I didn't want to go back out in the chaos. A supper club provides a relish tray on the table. They provide a relish bar that costs extra if you want to go get stuff yourself. Disappointing.
Now to the positive.
The service was outstanding. I repeated our server's name in my head a few times, but have since forgotten it - we went Saturday night and it's now Monday morning. Probably ran from the noise...hehehe. He was charming, friendly, attentive, non-intrusive; all the things you want when spending money on a night out to eat. It was a full house, but we never had to track him down for anything. Would definitely want him as our server again.
The food was delicious. Among the five us, three had the Prime Rib, one had the New York, and I had the Glazed Ribs. Everyone enjoyed their food. The bread put on the table was warm and inviting. My pre-dinner drink was the Mudslide. Yummy. The first course salads were more than just a typical house salad of lettuce and tomato. Interesting ingredients that I've never had, but very good and made for a very well balanced flavor profile. The ribs were very tender and fell off the bone. It was a full slab so I took much home for lunch Sunday, along with half my baked potato which I ordered loaded. One thing needing to be improved here is that each person should receive their OWN butter and sour cream when ordered as we did have to continually request more.
Wheelchair accessibility: Main entrance has stairs. Unknown if there is another entrance accessible to chairs.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ribs
We were seated right at our reservation time, very friendly staff all around. Enjoyed delicious well made old fashions, onion rings appetizer (highly recommend), fish fry with potato pancakes and the schnitzel with mashed potatoes.....both entrees were delicious! Shout out to Becca, our server, who was very attentive and kind...treating my husband to a piece of carrot cake for his birthday 🎂.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Schnitzel, Onion Rings
The Thursday Special, Wiener Schnitzel with Spaetzle, was outstanding -- and a huge portion! My husband had the rack of ribs with the French Onion Soup. The ribs were fork-tender, and the soup tasty! Wide selection of beverages; I had the Alaskan Amber, which was so good! The beer garden next door was also open (55° in January!).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in for drinks yesterday evening. Beautiful atmosphere; very classy, clean and warmly decorated. Ashley and Michael were both professional, outgoing, and friendly. Husband had his first whiskey old fashioned made by Ashley - excellent drink! Reviewed the menu, looking forward to visiting in the near future for dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Food was very good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ribs, Cheese Curds
Loading...