Bake my day has the best muffins around with the friendliest staff and management. every Thanksgiving we get a blueberry crumble pie from them, which is amazing. We also get our Christmas cutout cookies from them unfrosted and frost them at home. so good.
Priyanka Reddy
Cake is very dry, base was like powder it didn’t even tasted like the flavor we ordered
Melissa H
This is our go to place for birthday cakes and cupcakes. Their cakes are moist and fluffy and very flavorful. I highly recommend the Amaretto flavor. Staff is super nice and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake
Jamie Lord
Ok I'm not usually one to stop what I'm doing and post about a product ..but this place WOW .. We just ordered a sampler for our up coming wedding to try their cakes... The flavor profile!! Wow for cake they are very flavorful and excellent texture... The buttercream...again on point. The owner took the time in her busy Saturday to show us all she had to offer and still handle her regular customers. She was very detailed and wanted to make sure we had all the options and pricing upfront no non sense.. we just sat down to do tasting and both us are blown away but the texture and flavor profiles... If you even on the fence i recommend you go there ...we even saw a special photo cake delivered to a very happy 12 year old when we were there again everything was perfect and I cannot wait to try to decide between the 5 flavors we got in the sample..it's going to be a hard decision!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon Margaret Brott
5/5 stars! I'm still raving about the incredible red velvet cake we ordered for my son's graduation party! The two-layer masterpiece was moist, addicting, and beautifully decorated with my son's name and a graduation cap in his school colors. The cream cheese filling and traditional frosting were the perfect complements. We ordered for 20 people, but had plenty of leftovers (despite some... creative cutting skills). The best part? The bakery was a dream to work with! Pro tip: call ahead to confirm what cake flavor you want and see if they have that in a cupcake available and try it before ordering. And, amazingly, you can order a simple cake on Tuesday and pick it up on Friday for a Saturday celebration! We'll be back for all future events - highly recommend!
5/5 stars! I'm still raving about the incredible red velvet cake we ordered for my son's graduation party! The two-layer masterpiece was moist, addicting, and beautifully decorated with my son's name and a graduation cap in his school colors. The cream cheese filling and traditional frosting were the perfect complements. We ordered for 20 people, but had plenty of leftovers (despite some... creative cutting skills). The best part? The bakery was a dream to work with! Pro tip: call ahead to confirm what cake flavor you want and see if they have that in a cupcake available and try it before ordering. And, amazingly, you can order a simple cake on Tuesday and pick it up on Friday for a Saturday celebration! We'll be back for all future events - highly recommend!
5/5 stars! I'm still raving about the incredible red velvet cake we ordered for my son's graduation party! The two-layer masterpiece was moist, addicting, and beautifully decorated with my son's name and a graduation cap in his school colors. The cream cheese filling and traditional frosting were the perfect complements. We ordered for 20 people, but had plenty of leftovers (despite some... creative cutting skills). The best part? The bakery was a dream to work with! Pro tip: call ahead to confirm what cake flavor you want and see if they have that in a cupcake available and try it before ordering. And, amazingly, you can order a simple cake on Tuesday and pick it up on Friday for a Saturday celebration! We'll be back for all future events - highly recommend!
Jenn Zoglman
I ordered my wedding cake from them, and it was exactly how I envisioned it. They also did a great job on the groom’s cake. I would highly recommend Bake My Day!
Rebecca Wood
I was visiting my Son and daughter in law to help take care of my granddaughters while my grandson was being born and in his first few weeks of life. My sweet Middle granddaughter had a birthday party on January 11th and had a special request, she wanted a strawberry flavored cake. Well obviously you can’t find these at your local retail stores and after trying a few bakeries we came upon Bake My Day. BEST FIND EVER! She was so helpful in suggesting how to decorate it seeing how we had the main toppers at home already. The cake was absolutely delicious, I mean, beyond delicious delicious! The price was amazing for the quality, only $5-10 above a basic store bought cake except fresh and custom. They have so many flavors and designs, also other things besides cakes. We have a “cake lady” here in Florida and now we have one for my little Green Bay family too! This will be our new birthday cake place for the kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Anna Sedlar
The best cupcakes I've ever had!! I stopped in and ordered a few boxes of cupcakes as goodbye gifts for my neighbors the weekend before moving. They were SO nice, and worked with my schedule so I could pick them up right at 9am on my moving day. I luckily ordered one extra box for myself to take and we ate them on the road (excuse the photos, they got a little jostled during the move). Each one was a work of ART, so detailed and beautiful and most importantly, tasted incredible. I will definitely be ordering more in the future! We're so lucky to have them in Green Bay
Super cute place, Katie was very helpful when I ordered 3 large sheet cakes for a company event, wayy in advance. The vanilla flavor is fantastic! We polished off all 3 cakes in one day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allison
Bake My Day recently made our wedding cake and it was phenomenal! We got SO many compliments throughout the evening. We did a "naked" cake, so minimal frosting, and they were totally on board with any crazy ideas we threw at them. We did alternating cherry and amaretto layers and they were AMAZING! (just to note, the fresh fruit we provided and added separately!)
Anne Gustavson Cruz
They did such a wonderful job with our wedding cake!! So fun to customize the design and flavors on different cake layers. Service was excellent, Pick up was easy and efficient. So many guests complimented the great taste too. Highly recommend Bake my day!!
Patti McKeefry
Family loved blueberry pie(especially the crust)and the amazing cheesecakes. Thanks Katie ?
Bake my day has the best muffins around with the friendliest staff and management. every Thanksgiving we get a blueberry crumble pie from them, which is amazing. We also get our Christmas cutout cookies from them unfrosted and frost them at home. so good.
Cake is very dry, base was like powder it didn’t even tasted like the flavor we ordered
This is our go to place for birthday cakes and cupcakes. Their cakes are moist and fluffy and very flavorful. I highly recommend the Amaretto flavor. Staff is super nice and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake
Ok I'm not usually one to stop what I'm doing and post about a product ..but this place WOW .. We just ordered a sampler for our up coming wedding to try their cakes... The flavor profile!! Wow for cake they are very flavorful and excellent texture... The buttercream...again on point. The owner took the time in her busy Saturday to show us all she had to offer and still handle her regular customers. She was very detailed and wanted to make sure we had all the options and pricing upfront no non sense.. we just sat down to do tasting and both us are blown away but the texture and flavor profiles... If you even on the fence i recommend you go there ...we even saw a special photo cake delivered to a very happy 12 year old when we were there again everything was perfect and I cannot wait to try to decide between the 5 flavors we got in the sample..it's going to be a hard decision!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
5/5 stars! I'm still raving about the incredible red velvet cake we ordered for my son's graduation party! The two-layer masterpiece was moist, addicting, and beautifully decorated with my son's name and a graduation cap in his school colors. The cream cheese filling and traditional frosting were the perfect complements. We ordered for 20 people, but had plenty of leftovers (despite some... creative cutting skills). The best part? The bakery was a dream to work with! Pro tip: call ahead to confirm what cake flavor you want and see if they have that in a cupcake available and try it before ordering. And, amazingly, you can order a simple cake on Tuesday and pick it up on Friday for a Saturday celebration! We'll be back for all future events - highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake, Wedding Cake & Cupcakes, Sheet Cake
5/5 stars! I'm still raving about the incredible red velvet cake we ordered for my son's graduation party! The two-layer masterpiece was moist, addicting, and beautifully decorated with my son's name and a graduation cap in his school colors. The cream cheese filling and traditional frosting were the perfect complements. We ordered for 20 people, but had plenty of leftovers (despite some... creative cutting skills). The best part? The bakery was a dream to work with! Pro tip: call ahead to confirm what cake flavor you want and see if they have that in a cupcake available and try it before ordering. And, amazingly, you can order a simple cake on Tuesday and pick it up on Friday for a Saturday celebration! We'll be back for all future events - highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake, Sheet Cake
5/5 stars! I'm still raving about the incredible red velvet cake we ordered for my son's graduation party! The two-layer masterpiece was moist, addicting, and beautifully decorated with my son's name and a graduation cap in his school colors. The cream cheese filling and traditional frosting were the perfect complements. We ordered for 20 people, but had plenty of leftovers (despite some... creative cutting skills). The best part? The bakery was a dream to work with! Pro tip: call ahead to confirm what cake flavor you want and see if they have that in a cupcake available and try it before ordering. And, amazingly, you can order a simple cake on Tuesday and pick it up on Friday for a Saturday celebration! We'll be back for all future events - highly recommend!
I ordered my wedding cake from them, and it was exactly how I envisioned it. They also did a great job on the groom’s cake. I would highly recommend Bake My Day!
I was visiting my Son and daughter in law to help take care of my granddaughters while my grandson was being born and in his first few weeks of life. My sweet Middle granddaughter had a birthday party on January 11th and had a special request, she wanted a strawberry flavored cake. Well obviously you can’t find these at your local retail stores and after trying a few bakeries we came upon Bake My Day. BEST FIND EVER! She was so helpful in suggesting how to decorate it seeing how we had the main toppers at home already. The cake was absolutely delicious, I mean, beyond delicious delicious! The price was amazing for the quality, only $5-10 above a basic store bought cake except fresh and custom. They have so many flavors and designs, also other things besides cakes. We have a “cake lady” here in Florida and now we have one for my little Green Bay family too! This will be our new birthday cake place for the kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
The best cupcakes I've ever had!! I stopped in and ordered a few boxes of cupcakes as goodbye gifts for my neighbors the weekend before moving. They were SO nice, and worked with my schedule so I could pick them up right at 9am on my moving day. I luckily ordered one extra box for myself to take and we ate them on the road (excuse the photos, they got a little jostled during the move). Each one was a work of ART, so detailed and beautiful and most importantly, tasted incredible. I will definitely be ordering more in the future! We're so lucky to have them in Green Bay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake
Restaurantji Recommends
Best muffins ever!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super cute place, Katie was very helpful when I ordered 3 large sheet cakes for a company event, wayy in advance. The vanilla flavor is fantastic! We polished off all 3 cakes in one day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bake My Day recently made our wedding cake and it was phenomenal! We got SO many compliments throughout the evening. We did a "naked" cake, so minimal frosting, and they were totally on board with any crazy ideas we threw at them. We did alternating cherry and amaretto layers and they were AMAZING! (just to note, the fresh fruit we provided and added separately!)
They did such a wonderful job with our wedding cake!! So fun to customize the design and flavors on different cake layers. Service was excellent, Pick up was easy and efficient. So many guests complimented the great taste too. Highly recommend Bake my day!!
Family loved blueberry pie(especially the crust)and the amazing cheesecakes. Thanks Katie ?
Loading...