I ordered my wedding cake from them, and it was exactly how I envisioned it. They also did a great job on the groom’s cake. I would highly recommend Bake My Day!
Rebecca Wood
I was visiting my Son and daughter in law to help take care of my granddaughters while my grandson was being born and in his first few weeks of life. My sweet Middle granddaughter had a birthday party on January 11th and had a special request, she wanted a strawberry flavored cake. Well obviously you can’t find these at your local retail stores and after trying a few bakeries we came upon Bake My Day. BEST FIND EVER! She was so helpful in suggesting how to decorate it seeing how we had the main toppers at home already. The cake was absolutely delicious, I mean, beyond delicious delicious! The price was amazing for the quality, only $5-10 above a basic store bought cake except fresh and custom. They have so many flavors and designs, also other things besides cakes. We have a “cake lady” here in Florida and now we have one for my little Green Bay family too! This will be our new birthday cake place for the kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Anna Sedlar
The best cupcakes I've ever had!! I stopped in and ordered a few boxes of cupcakes as goodbye gifts for my neighbors the weekend before moving. They were SO nice, and worked with my schedule so I could pick them up right at 9am on my moving day. I luckily ordered one extra box for myself to take and we ate them on the road (excuse the photos, they got a little jostled during the move). Each one was a work of ART, so detailed and beautiful and most importantly, tasted incredible. I will definitely be ordering more in the future! We're so lucky to have them in Green Bay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake
Ann Polzin
Best muffins ever!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaelynn Hauser
Super cute place, Katie was very helpful when I ordered 3 large sheet cakes for a company event, wayy in advance. The vanilla flavor is fantastic! We polished off all 3 cakes in one day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allison
Bake My Day recently made our wedding cake and it was phenomenal! We got SO many compliments throughout the evening. We did a "naked" cake, so minimal frosting, and they were totally on board with any crazy ideas we threw at them. We did alternating cherry and amaretto layers and they were AMAZING! (just to note, the fresh fruit we provided and added separately!)
Kayla Krueger
Bake my day was super easy to work with and they had the most delicious cake and frosting I have ever tasted!! We used them for our wedding and the cake was beautiful and everyone loved the flavors.
Elizabeth Buhr
Ordered a baby shower cake. The owner is nice but the worker was very rude. Cake itself wasn’t terrible but it was dry and the frosting was overly sweet. Decoration and flavor weren’t what I wanted but it wasn’t too far off, I wish they had an order summary via email to review instead of just over the phone.
Lynne Suchocki
They made the cutest emoji cupcakes for my grandsons birthday. They went above and beyond for two years straight! Love them and the cake was wonderful too! Thanks
Morgan Shannon
Holy cow. I cannot even begin to express how truly INCREDIBLE Bake My Day is. I got a beautiful cake for my husband and I to cut on our wedding day as well as an assortment of several different flavors- the cherry, amaretto, orange, and white cake are ridiculously delicious. The frosting is INSANE. All of it is. I tried several other bakeries in the area and all of them were awful compared to this. Bake My Day not only has easily the most delicious cake, but their staff is so lovely. They are kind, helpful, patient, flexible, and talented!! I absolutely recommend :)
Over all cakes did taste good frosting was nice. But the cupcakes looked like your mom made them at home not terrible just not great.
Morgan Johnson
Holy cow. I cannot even begin to express how truly INCREDIBLE Bake My Day is. I got a beautiful cake for my husband and I to cut on our wedding day as well as an assortment of several different flavors- the cherry, amaretto, orange, and white cake are ridiculously delicious. The frosting is INSANE. All of it is. I tried several other bakeries in the area and all of them were awful compared to this. Bake My Day not only has easily the most delicious cake, but their staff is so lovely. They are kind, helpful, patient, flexible, and talented!! I absolutely recommend :)
Anne Gustavson
They did such a wonderful job with our wedding cake!! So fun to customize the design and flavors on different cake layers. Service was excellent, Pick up was easy and efficient. So many guests complimented the great taste too. Highly recommend Bake my day!!
Qiana Ehrensperger
My new go to place. Drove by Bake my Day for months, and finally made the time to stop in. It was worth every second.I highly recommend the cheesecake and pineapple muffin.
scott hagerty
Just WOW...the cakes that were made for our twin 2 year olds were AMAZING. So many little details in the Shrek cake and the Moana cake is exactly what it's supposed to be. When we ordered these cakes it was exactly what we wanted and this bakery knocked it out of the park. Also on a side note...not only did they look good but it also tasted awesome. I would recommend Bake My Day 10 out of 10 times. Way to go!!!
I ordered my wedding cake from them, and it was exactly how I envisioned it. They also did a great job on the groom’s cake. I would highly recommend Bake My Day!
I was visiting my Son and daughter in law to help take care of my granddaughters while my grandson was being born and in his first few weeks of life. My sweet Middle granddaughter had a birthday party on January 11th and had a special request, she wanted a strawberry flavored cake. Well obviously you can’t find these at your local retail stores and after trying a few bakeries we came upon Bake My Day. BEST FIND EVER! She was so helpful in suggesting how to decorate it seeing how we had the main toppers at home already. The cake was absolutely delicious, I mean, beyond delicious delicious! The price was amazing for the quality, only $5-10 above a basic store bought cake except fresh and custom. They have so many flavors and designs, also other things besides cakes. We have a “cake lady” here in Florida and now we have one for my little Green Bay family too! This will be our new birthday cake place for the kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
The best cupcakes I've ever had!! I stopped in and ordered a few boxes of cupcakes as goodbye gifts for my neighbors the weekend before moving. They were SO nice, and worked with my schedule so I could pick them up right at 9am on my moving day. I luckily ordered one extra box for myself to take and we ate them on the road (excuse the photos, they got a little jostled during the move). Each one was a work of ART, so detailed and beautiful and most importantly, tasted incredible. I will definitely be ordering more in the future! We're so lucky to have them in Green Bay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake
Best muffins ever!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super cute place, Katie was very helpful when I ordered 3 large sheet cakes for a company event, wayy in advance. The vanilla flavor is fantastic! We polished off all 3 cakes in one day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bake My Day recently made our wedding cake and it was phenomenal! We got SO many compliments throughout the evening. We did a "naked" cake, so minimal frosting, and they were totally on board with any crazy ideas we threw at them. We did alternating cherry and amaretto layers and they were AMAZING! (just to note, the fresh fruit we provided and added separately!)
Bake my day was super easy to work with and they had the most delicious cake and frosting I have ever tasted!! We used them for our wedding and the cake was beautiful and everyone loved the flavors.
Ordered a baby shower cake. The owner is nice but the worker was very rude. Cake itself wasn’t terrible but it was dry and the frosting was overly sweet. Decoration and flavor weren’t what I wanted but it wasn’t too far off, I wish they had an order summary via email to review instead of just over the phone.
They made the cutest emoji cupcakes for my grandsons birthday. They went above and beyond for two years straight! Love them and the cake was wonderful too! Thanks
Holy cow. I cannot even begin to express how truly INCREDIBLE Bake My Day is. I got a beautiful cake for my husband and I to cut on our wedding day as well as an assortment of several different flavors- the cherry, amaretto, orange, and white cake are ridiculously delicious. The frosting is INSANE. All of it is. I tried several other bakeries in the area and all of them were awful compared to this. Bake My Day not only has easily the most delicious cake, but their staff is so lovely. They are kind, helpful, patient, flexible, and talented!! I absolutely recommend :)
Restaurantji Recommends
Over all cakes did taste good frosting was nice. But the cupcakes looked like your mom made them at home not terrible just not great.
Holy cow. I cannot even begin to express how truly INCREDIBLE Bake My Day is. I got a beautiful cake for my husband and I to cut on our wedding day as well as an assortment of several different flavors- the cherry, amaretto, orange, and white cake are ridiculously delicious. The frosting is INSANE. All of it is. I tried several other bakeries in the area and all of them were awful compared to this. Bake My Day not only has easily the most delicious cake, but their staff is so lovely. They are kind, helpful, patient, flexible, and talented!! I absolutely recommend :)
They did such a wonderful job with our wedding cake!! So fun to customize the design and flavors on different cake layers. Service was excellent, Pick up was easy and efficient. So many guests complimented the great taste too. Highly recommend Bake my day!!
My new go to place. Drove by Bake my Day for months, and finally made the time to stop in. It was worth every second.I highly recommend the cheesecake and pineapple muffin.
Just WOW...the cakes that were made for our twin 2 year olds were AMAZING. So many little details in the Shrek cake and the Moana cake is exactly what it's supposed to be. When we ordered these cakes it was exactly what we wanted and this bakery knocked it out of the park. Also on a side note...not only did they look good but it also tasted awesome. I would recommend Bake My Day 10 out of 10 times. Way to go!!!