This place is one of a kind. I was doing some shopping downtown a few months back and seen this place. We went in to look and see what they had to offer. They do not disappoint. Delicious cheesecake friendly staff. Great place to grab some goodies.
Kaelyn Wilke
This cheesecake is absolutely delicious! We ordered a 9-in salted caramel vanilla bean, and everyone raved over it. 10/10 recommend for anyone looking for authentically good cheesecake.
kimberly vanpembrook
Stopped here while in green bay in 2025 and the best cheesecake ever! Make it a point to stop in and check them out you will not be disappointed.
Emily A
The cheesecake tacos and eclairs are my favorite
Alicia O'Donnell
Delicious, rich and creamy cheesecake. The tacos are to die for. The shell is delicious and crunchy, and so flavorful and the toppings and fillings were all different and delicious decadent.
Katrina Hinnefeld
So delicious and they are super friendly and helpful at the store!
Starfire
Love this place
Aimee Contreras
$52 for cheesecake might sound crazy at first, but one bite in and the price instantly makes sense. Definitely a splurge, but absolutely worth it.
Go Halainn
10/10 recommend! This was my first time in the bakery and I’m very impressed. The turtle cheesecake tacos were a huge hit with my friends. They were delicious and I can’t wait to try more. The gentleman who helped me even gave me a sample of their new grasshopper cheesecake and little did he know how much I love mint chocolate. I will definitely be back!
Amy Ludin
Oh My Goodness You Guy's Rock !! A. NICHE IN GREEN BAY, WISCONSIN ON BROADWAY. IS FANTASTIC, CHEESECAKE TACOS ABSOLUTELY 💯 AMAZING 💥💚❤️🧡💙💜 she's able to do speciality cakes 🎂 pies etc would be 10 Stars only wish calorie free 😋
Went yesterday. The lady working seemed very irritable, like she didn't want to even be there
Laurie bonney
The cheesecake tacos are creative and so yummy!
Hadley Mackenzie
My whole experience with FiveThumbsUp has been wonderful from start to finish. I gave the lady just a general idea of what I wanted and told her I trusted her judgement on this one. I wanted this because my boyfriend loves halloween and cheesecake. What better combo to have for a birthday cake? She set up a pick up date for a day she wasnt even open as well! (The birthday happened to fall on a day she wasnt open) Truly above and beyond service! Thank you so much and I will be ordering again in the future!
Jeri Fioramanti
Granddaughter loved the cheesecake
Kolt Retzlaff
Best Cheesecake Ever! That's one great baker, and the young man that works in there is great!
This place is one of a kind. I was doing some shopping downtown a few months back and seen this place. We went in to look and see what they had to offer. They do not disappoint. Delicious cheesecake friendly staff. Great place to grab some goodies.
This cheesecake is absolutely delicious! We ordered a 9-in salted caramel vanilla bean, and everyone raved over it. 10/10 recommend for anyone looking for authentically good cheesecake.
Stopped here while in green bay in 2025 and the best cheesecake ever! Make it a point to stop in and check them out you will not be disappointed.
The cheesecake tacos and eclairs are my favorite
Delicious, rich and creamy cheesecake. The tacos are to die for. The shell is delicious and crunchy, and so flavorful and the toppings and fillings were all different and delicious decadent.
So delicious and they are super friendly and helpful at the store!
Love this place
$52 for cheesecake might sound crazy at first, but one bite in and the price instantly makes sense. Definitely a splurge, but absolutely worth it.
10/10 recommend! This was my first time in the bakery and I’m very impressed. The turtle cheesecake tacos were a huge hit with my friends. They were delicious and I can’t wait to try more. The gentleman who helped me even gave me a sample of their new grasshopper cheesecake and little did he know how much I love mint chocolate. I will definitely be back!
Oh My Goodness You Guy's Rock !! A. NICHE IN GREEN BAY, WISCONSIN ON BROADWAY.
IS FANTASTIC, CHEESECAKE TACOS ABSOLUTELY 💯 AMAZING 💥💚❤️🧡💙💜 she's able to do speciality cakes 🎂 pies etc would be 10 Stars only wish calorie free 😋
Restaurantji Recommends
Went yesterday. The lady working seemed very irritable, like she didn't want to even be there
The cheesecake tacos are creative and so yummy!
My whole experience with FiveThumbsUp has been wonderful from start to finish. I gave the lady just a general idea of what I wanted and told her I trusted her judgement on this one. I wanted this because my boyfriend loves halloween and cheesecake. What better combo to have for a birthday cake? She set up a pick up date for a day she wasnt even open as well! (The birthday happened to fall on a day she wasnt open) Truly above and beyond service! Thank you so much and I will be ordering again in the future!
Granddaughter loved the cheesecake
Best Cheesecake Ever! That's one great baker, and the young man that works in there is great!
Loading...