Wow. Cheesecake....Kringle....chocolate eclair ring....bagels.... everything. Try everything! I've been to a lot of places that advertise the best dessert but fivethumbsup takes the cheesecake. Atmosphere is great as well. Thank you to the owner, Jill for taking time to chat and ask for my feedback!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Rutten
We just picked cinnamon rolls and a cheese cake. This review is for the cinnamon rolls only as we have not tried the cheese cake yet. Let me say I hope the cheese cake is better than the cinnamon rolls. These are the worse cinnamon rolls I have ever had. They were super dry and hard almost like a rock. Never, in my 75 years, have I had cinnamon rolls so bad and they werenot cheap! I will never purchase these again. I swear they must be a month or more old and have just been sitting out. Matter of fact I think I could bounce them on the floor but don’t want to crack my tile. Sorry Five Thumbs Up but they are that bad’.Wheelchair accessibility: Did not see accessibility entrance. The steps outside are not wheelchair freindly!.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Andrew Brehmer
My wife and I went here for their cheesecake, and it did not disappoint. Best cheesecake in Green Bay, hands down. The prices are a little high, but you are getting what you pay for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Anjali Oleksy
Great service. Great food. Amazing dessert & cheesecake. As of winter ‘23, they’re in the cute hall in the first floor of the titletown taproom (the cannery) there’s places to sit and you can order online, as well as look at all the vendors menus from a QR code, and have delivered to your table. Love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Rott
Each new monthly flavor is better than the last! Try them all! Sweetness is very balanced, not too sweet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John P.
Had a chance to sample the cheesecake offerings from this new eatery in the Canary. We ordered a flight of cheesecake. Who gets a chance to have a flight of cheesecake? Oreo cookie, pumpkin, peanut butter, and berries. Excellent. A nice place for a first date - - a drink and a little dessert. A great place to find your Holiday desserts. Ask about the bourbon cheesecake! Bonus: new Colombian restaurant also in the cannery. There are empanadas were delicious.
Anna Conard
Our cake pops and cheesecake balls for my baby shower turned out amazing! Excellent flavor and presentation! Super easy customer service and very customizable to our theme! Highly recommend and will be back for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becky Conard
Can’t say enough about Jill and her cheesecakes! I ordered 4 different flavors of cheesecake ball’s and cake pops for my daughter’s baby shower and they were a hit! My daughter’s theme was “locally grown”. Jill did an amazing job to make that happen and she went above and beyond to have all the different candy veggies for toppings. She was professional and easy to work with. We would highly recommend her for any occasion. Especially with the busy holiday season coming up. Give FiveThumbsUp a try. You won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Hepner
I've special ordered cupcakes multiple times and am never disappointed in the flavor and appearance. They are amazing. Always a hit at our birthday parties. I buy extras to keep in the freezer for later.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jen Mankovecky
We tried Five Thumbs Up cheesecake for the first time this evening and our whole family agreed that it is the best cheesecake we have ever had. I visited the cannery for the first time hoping to buy a full cheesecake, and Jill was so friendly and happy to accommodate my special request. I would highly recommend Five Thumbs Up for anyone looking for exceptional cheesecake!
My family loves cheesecake so we have to have the best. I have other local brands in my area and I drive a hour and a half round trip to get this cheesecake for holidays. It is the absolute best!!
Illishia Sterr
Jill makes the best cheesecake! Normally I do not care for cheesecake, but Jill's is amazing! The lemon curd cheesecake balls are my favorite, and her berry cheesecake.--YUM!Her custom bakery items are just as delicious.
Ann Rusch
My favorite cheesecake by far! So many great flavors to decide on! Highly recommend! Jill does a great job!
Rachel Menon
Best cheesecake I've ever had! Haven't been to the downtown Green Bay location yet, but can't wait to try it out! I love the sampler cheesecakes to try different flavors.
Sara Roloff
The chocolate covered cheesecake balls are to die for!!
Wow. Cheesecake....Kringle....chocolate eclair ring....bagels.... everything. Try everything! I've been to a lot of places that advertise the best dessert but fivethumbsup takes the cheesecake. Atmosphere is great as well. Thank you to the owner, Jill for taking time to chat and ask for my feedback!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just picked cinnamon rolls and a cheese cake. This review is for the cinnamon rolls only as we have not tried the cheese cake yet. Let me say I hope the cheese cake is better than the cinnamon rolls. These are the worse cinnamon rolls I have ever had. They were super dry and hard almost like a rock. Never, in my 75 years, have I had cinnamon rolls so bad and they werenot cheap! I will never purchase these again. I swear they must be a month or more old and have just been sitting out. Matter of fact I think I could bounce them on the floor but don’t want to crack my tile. Sorry Five Thumbs Up but they are that bad’.Wheelchair accessibility: Did not see accessibility entrance. The steps outside are not wheelchair freindly!.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
My wife and I went here for their cheesecake, and it did not disappoint. Best cheesecake in Green Bay, hands down. The prices are a little high, but you are getting what you pay for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Great service. Great food. Amazing dessert & cheesecake. As of winter ‘23, they’re in the cute hall in the first floor of the titletown taproom (the cannery) there’s places to sit and you can order online, as well as look at all the vendors menus from a QR code, and have delivered to your table. Love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Each new monthly flavor is better than the last! Try them all! Sweetness is very balanced, not too sweet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a chance to sample the cheesecake offerings from this new eatery in the Canary. We ordered a flight of cheesecake. Who gets a chance to have a flight of cheesecake? Oreo cookie, pumpkin, peanut butter, and berries. Excellent. A nice place for a first date - - a drink and a little dessert. A great place to find your Holiday desserts. Ask about the bourbon cheesecake! Bonus: new Colombian restaurant also in the cannery. There are empanadas were delicious.
Our cake pops and cheesecake balls for my baby shower turned out amazing! Excellent flavor and presentation! Super easy customer service and very customizable to our theme! Highly recommend and will be back for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Can’t say enough about Jill and her cheesecakes! I ordered 4 different flavors of cheesecake ball’s and cake pops for my daughter’s baby shower and they were a hit! My daughter’s theme was “locally grown”. Jill did an amazing job to make that happen and she went above and beyond to have all the different candy veggies for toppings. She was professional and easy to work with. We would highly recommend her for any occasion. Especially with the busy holiday season coming up. Give FiveThumbsUp a try. You won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've special ordered cupcakes multiple times and am never disappointed in the flavor and appearance. They are amazing. Always a hit at our birthday parties. I buy extras to keep in the freezer for later.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We tried Five Thumbs Up cheesecake for the first time this evening and our whole family agreed that it is the best cheesecake we have ever had. I visited the cannery for the first time hoping to buy a full cheesecake, and Jill was so friendly and happy to accommodate my special request. I would highly recommend Five Thumbs Up for anyone looking for exceptional cheesecake!
Restaurantji Recommends
My family loves cheesecake so we have to have the best. I have other local brands in my area and I drive a hour and a half round trip to get this cheesecake for holidays. It is the absolute best!!
Jill makes the best cheesecake! Normally I do not care for cheesecake, but Jill's is amazing! The lemon curd cheesecake balls are my favorite, and her berry cheesecake.--YUM!Her custom bakery items are just as delicious.
My favorite cheesecake by far! So many great flavors to decide on! Highly recommend! Jill does a great job!
Best cheesecake I've ever had! Haven't been to the downtown Green Bay location yet, but can't wait to try it out! I love the sampler cheesecakes to try different flavors.
The chocolate covered cheesecake balls are to die for!!