Heritage Modern Supper Club

The Heritage Modern Supper Club is located in the Legacy Hotel and provides a modern, well-staffed atmosphere with a great wine list. The adjacent bar is a convenient spot for a pre-dinner drink.

The appetizers are the highlight here. Do not miss the fluffy, deep-fried cheese curds with ranch (their lightness was a great surprise). We also enjoyed the crisp, warm truffle fries and the togarashi tuna served with crisp radish and cucumber.

Mains showed promise but were inconsistent. The grilled ribeye had a rich, aged flavor, and the seasoning emphasized the natural beef notes, though the steak itself was a little dry. The roasted duck breast was cooked to a medium-rare with crisp skin, but the seasoning was uneven until the final bites.

Service was slow for a Sunday evening. To their credit, the floor manager noticed the delay and personally stepped in to take our appetizer order and deliver the food, which was appreciated.

Overall, this is a solid 4-star choice. It's a slightly pricey dinner option for the value and service, but the flavor combinations and strong appetizers make it a compelling stop. Consistency is key to taking this restaurant to the next level.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

The restaurant has a great ambiance. During the dinner time there live piano playing. I had the Duck Breast. Micro drop to the chef 🎤🙌🤙

Looking forward to the next meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food. Menu is riddled with typos and kerning issues.

We spent our anniversary at the Heritage Modern Supper Club inside the Legacy Hotel in Green Bay near Lambeau Field. The food was amazing with midwestern size entrees, outstanding service, and beautiful ambiance in a wonderful location. Our waitress helped us with recommendations, which were fabulous. My wife had the tomato basil salad which was two meals in itself. She said she definitely would come back for lunch and order this salad. She had the Risotto for her entree and raved about how good it was. I had the burger which was truly one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. The burger was huge and came with truffle fries which were delicious. I absolutely recommend this place, be sure to give them a try while in Green Bay!!! And by the way the sourdough bread and olive oil was awesome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered the steak which wasn’t bad, but not worth the price tag they have here. The cheapest being $50 to the most expensive being around $60. It was tender, but could’ve used a little more seasoning. They did offer complementary bread which was very nice. They also have a nice wine selection. I’ve seen mixed reviews, but wanted to try it for myself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

We had an amazing anniversary dinner last week! The Heritage restaurant is located on the first floor of the beautiful Legacy Hotel. The hotel staff were all friendly and helpful, and our server Joy was fantastic! We loved everything in our meal! Strongly recommend the burrata and tomato salad, tomatoes were so fresh! Other highlights include the bread service, lobster bisque, burger and truffle fries! Joy did a great job timing our drinks and food, while balancing several other tables. We will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Really classy atmosphere with a couple musicians playing dinner music as you walk in the door, and it just gets better from there.

The drinks were great. One of them had a fancy dust on the glass that changed the flavor of the drink as you sipped. We’d make the trip to the bar for those.

The food is excellent also. We tried quite a few different options and they were all delicious. It’s worth noting that the menu has some less expensive options like the bacon cheeseburger and also offers plenty of high end variety. Something for everyone.

The service was awesome. Very informative waiter who had plenty of tips about the food and drinks. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was very disappointed. The bar upstairs is great and the staff is very good. Decided to make it a full experience and stay for dinner versus going to the other side of Lambeau. The picture shows what $50+ got me. I ate the French onion soup which was good but the picture is of my untouched entre’ and side after I asked for it to go. Restaurant staff seemed very uninterested when asked about menu items.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We were staying at the hotel and decided to have a late dinner here, best decision ever. The service, food and atmosphere were perfect. The food was wonderful with large portions. Our meal was great and we will dine here again before leaving, would recommend giving them your business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Focaccia

This was a super pleasant surprise when we arrived at the legacy hotel late on a Friday night .. decided to get dinner at hotel because of traveling all day and tired .. the atmosphere was relaxing pleasant and service and food was excellent .. will definitely be back for dinner again even if I’m not staying at the legacy hotel ..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food has perfect blend of textures and flavours. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a quiet atmosphere, excellent service, and an upscale dining experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Decor is excellent and bar is top notch. Live piano music from a true virtuoso. Played bach , Rachmaninoff and jazz ...I would have paid to just listen to him.

Appetizers were definitely worthwhile The tartar was like none I've ever had although I found the large bowl somewhat bizarre,
Dinner disappointed. My broccoli was cold and the duck was tough and lukewarm. Things just proceeded to get worse The desserts were honestly terrible The chocolate cake was dry none of the desserts were good whatsoever was my daughter's birthday and they said oh she can pick out any dessert she would like she didn't get to but they comped us a cup of coffee begged them for candle he kept forgetting couldn't get our coffees refilled had to ask the waiter to clear our table we were party of six.
It just petered out at the end honestly service and the quality don't know when on that night it was a Friday night The restaurant was not that full however.
When I go back there for dinner probably not would I go there for appetizers in the bar and the piano music apps absolutely

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

We were there for dinner last night and had a wonderful experience! We had 8 adults in our party and every one of our dinners (2 Beef Braised Short Ribs, 2 Grilled Angus Ribeyes, 2 Salmon specials, 1 Filet Mignon, and 1 Legacy Burger) were absolutely delicious! The staff was very friendly, the restaurant setting was beautiful, and we will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The drinks at the bar were excellent.

The seared tuna appetizer was good.

The main course was significantly below standards of where they are pricing it. Ordered a ribeye entree medium rare. The entree came with mushrooms instead of fingerling potatoes as stated on the menu. Substitutions are acceptable, but the mushrooms were completely dry, cold and tough. The steak was so cold that the dollop of butter on top would not melt (butter melting temp is approx. 90 degrees F). Very disappointing experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

We went here for a nice dinner and Heritage delivered! The food was fantastic, the service was attentive and friendly, and the atmosphere was lovely. Totally recommend for a nice night out. My friends recommend the Steak Tartare, and I loved the mushroom risotto.

The Uncommon bar outside the dining room was also a great find - well-appointed and comfortable. Curtis was tending bar, and he was friendly and very knowledgeable. We had a wonderful time chatting with him.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mushroom Risotto