Olde World Pastries Plus

1770 E Deerfield Ave A, Green Bay
(920) 227-1348

Recent Reviews

Laura Allen

UP pasties, Danish and pastries. No need to travel to the UP for original Dobbers pasties!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ariel Glassman

So hospitable! Friendly service. Caramel cashew kringle and cinnamon rolls were delicious. Can't wait for another visit!Edit: I have to agree with another review I saw that this kringle is definitely far superior to the others I've tasted. Flaky pastry with a little crunch, and not overstuffed or syrupy sweet. Wish they were open today so we could stop in for more on the way home.

Lisa Dambach

These are the most delicious pastries and their Danish Kringle is the best in Wisconsin. They are light, flaky and tender with multiple fillings to choose from, including some very yummy seasonal fillings. Our families favorite is the raspberry cream cheese! Today I bought a Brandy Old Fashion, which I believe is their most popular flavor. The caramel nut is amazing too! I live a few hours away, and call ahead my order when I come into town to ensure!! They ship too, which I will be doing when my daughter no longer attends college nearby? If any pastries are left at the end of the day they are donated to the local homeless shelter. The staff are very friendly!Parking: Plenty of parking always

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastries Plus, Bakery, Strawberry Rhubarb Kringle

Roger Madore

Strap in because I've got a lot to say about Olde World Pastries Plus.Spoiler alert - it's all good.Although I'm not from Wisconsin, I've had my fair share of Kringles from Racine to Green Bay over the years. I've had some good Kringles and some that were, well, sub-par. But when I stopped in Olde World Pastries Plus this past October and tried one of their Kringles, I knew I found something special.The pastry of their Kringle is light, buttery and flakey, and just dense enough to have a nice chew and mouth-feel. The pastry can make or break a Kringle, and this one is a homerun. Strike that - a grand slam. These folks have their pastry recipe dialed in.The fillings are of high quality, too. With or without cream cheese, each Kringle is sure to delight and satisfy. And the proportions are well executed. The filling to pastry ratio gives a wonderful flavor without overpowering the pastry. You can taste and enjoy each element.I've sampled the strawberry, cherry with cream cheese, caramel nut and the Brandy Old Fashion Kringles so far. There will be more in my future for sure.Sidebar - get the Brandy Old Fashion Kringle right now. Stop reading this and order one or stop in the bakery and get one. Just go do it. It won't change your life, but it will make your belly feel like it did.But wait, there's more!Recently I had ordered several Kringles to be shipped to my home, about 1,400 miles away. I had the pleasure of speaking with Wanda and the staff when they took my order. They answered all my questions and were most helpful. They are polite, courteous and easy to talk to, and they treat you like a friend or a neighbor.Unfortunately, there was issue with the shipper, and I called Wanda to let her know. She immediately took actions to make things right, even though there was no fault of Olde World Pastries Plus. She ensured that I was happy with their service as well as their product, and boy did she succeed. Thanks to her actions, my family gets to enjoy some delicious Kringles this holiday season.I would give Olde World Pastries Plus more than 5 out of 5 stars if I could. In fact, I'm not sure stars are even good enough of a rating system. All I know is that I'm one very satisfied customer, and a customer for life. (And I'm a hero in my family for bringing these home.) But don't just take my word for it, go get some Kringles from Olde World Pastries Plus. Oh, and tell Wanda I said hi.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roger Madore

Strap in because I've got a lot to say about Olde World Pastries Plus. Spoiler alert - it's all good. Although I'm not from Wisconsin, I've had my fair share of Kringles from Racine to Green Bay over the years. I've had some good Kringles and some that were, well, sub-par. But when I stopped in Olde World Pastries Plus this past October and tried one of their Kringles, I knew I found something special. The pastry of their Kringle is light, buttery and flakey, and just dense enough to have a nice chew and mouth-feel. The pastry can make or break a Kringle, and this one is a homerun. Strike that - a grand slam. These folks have their pastry recipe dialed in. The fillings are of high quality, too. With or without cream cheese, each Kringle is sure to delight and satisfy. And the proportions are well executed. The filling to pastry ratio gives a wonderful flavor without overpowering the pastry. You can taste and enjoy each element. I've sampled the strawberry, cherry with cream cheese, caramel nut and the Brandy Old Fashion Kringles so far. There will be more in my future for sure. Sidebar - get the Brandy Old Fashion Kringle right now. Stop reading this and order one or stop in the bakery and get one. Just go do it. It won't change your life, but it will make your belly feel like it did. But wait, there's more! Recently I had ordered several Kringles to be shipped to my home, about 1,400 miles away. I had the pleasure of speaking with Wanda and the staff when they took my order. They answered all my questions and were most helpful. They are polite, courteous and easy to talk to, and they treat you like a friend or a neighbor. Unfortunately, there was issue with the shipper, and I called Wanda to let her know. She immediately took actions to make things right, even though there was no fault of Olde World Pastries Plus. She ensured that I was happy with their service as well as their product, and boy did she succeed. Thanks to her actions, my family gets to enjoy some delicious Kringles this holiday season. I would give Olde World Pastries Plus more than 5 out of 5 stars if I could. In fact, I'm not sure stars are even good enough of a rating system. All I know is that I'm one very satisfied customer, and a customer for life. (And I'm a hero in my family for bringing these home.) But don't just take my word for it, go get some Kringles from Olde World Pastries Plus. Oh, and tell Wanda I said hi.

Roger M.

Strap in because I've got a lot to say about Olde World Pastries Plus. Spoiler alert - it's all good. Although I'm not from Wisconsin, I've had my fair share of Kringles from Racine to Green Bay over the years. I've had some good Kringles and some that were, well, sub-par. But when I stopped in Olde World Pastries Plus this past October and tried one of their Kringles, I knew I found something special. The pastry of their Kringle is light, buttery and flakey, and just dense enough to have a nice chew and mouth-feel. The pastry can make or break a Kringle, and this one is a homerun. Strike that - a grand slam. These folks have their pastry recipe dialed in. The fillings are of high quality, too. With or without cream cheese, each Kringle is sure to delight and satisfy. And the proportions are well executed. The filling to pastry ratio gives a wonderful flavor without overpowering the pastry. You can taste and enjoy each element. I've sampled the strawberry, cherry with cream cheese, caramel nut and the Brandy Old Fashion Kringles so far. There will be more in my future for sure. Sidebar - get the Brandy Old Fashion Kringle right now. Stop reading this and order one or stop in the bakery and get one. Just go do it. It won't change your life, but it will make your belly feel like it did. But wait, there's more! Recently I had ordered several Kringles to be shipped to my home, about 1,400 miles away. I had the pleasure of speaking with Wanda and the staff when they took my order. They answered all my questions and were most helpful. They are polite, courteous and easy to talk to, and they treat you like a friend or a neighbor. Unfortunately, there was issue with the shipper, and I called Wanda to let her know. She immediately took actions to make things right, even though there was no fault of Olde World Pastries Plus. She ensured that I was happy with their service as well as their product, and boy did she succeed. Thanks to her actions, my family gets to enjoy some delicious Kringles this holiday season. I would give Olde World Pastries Plus more than 5 out of 5 stars if I could. In fact, I'm not sure stars are even good enough of a rating system. All I know is that I'm one very satisfied customer, and a customer for life. (And I'm a hero in my family for bringing these home.) But don't just take my word for it, go get some Kringles from Olde World Pastries Plus. Oh, and tell Wanda I said hi.

Chanda F.

Wonderful service, amazing danish and reasonable price. Love this place!! Definitely worth a stop, on a daily basis and beats the heck out of that other Suamico bakery!

Michelle G

I just cannot say enough about the customer service or the amazing wedding cake they created for us. Planning a wedding from another state, I took a chance and called OWPP based on the reviews online. I was nervous because none of them reviewed a wedding cake, but I assumed if they received such high praise for their other baked goods, chances were good they knew how to make a cake. ? Such friendly and helpful service; they helped us navigate ordering without ever tasting or even seeing any of their products in person. We dropped off the flowers to adorn the cake the day before the wedding and kept our expectations in check. I never, ever write reviews, but when we walked into the reception and saw the absolutely stunning cake, I was beyond impressed. When we tasted it...oh my word! Almond wedding cake with Italian buttercream frosting that was so delicious! Many guests commented it was the best cake they had ever had at a wedding! Thank you to everyone who making this part of our celebration absolute perfection!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bakery, Simple Wedding Cake, Three Tier Wedding Cake

Samantha Dzwigalski

Woah baby these people know how to bake! We went with olde world pastries after trying some.. uh.. less than appetizing bakeries for our wedding and immediately knew we found a hidden gem with them. The owner and her staff were so kind and understanding of a scatterbrained bride. We ended up getting cupcakes and kringle for our wedding and it was almost all gone by the end of the night! We will definitely be going to them for all of our kringle needs from now on as you really cannot beat the flavor of real butter and love. Good job team!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buttercream Wedding Cake, Halloween Cupcakes

Peg Kinziger

They have the best bakery around....fine ingredients & Oh, so tasteful! Small Family business & She aims to please! Everything I have purchased is DELISH! Try this place you will be glad you did!

Ann Griffin

They're just a little shop along Highway 141 in the Green Bay area. We had stopped here before and knew the Kringles and cake were awesome. We took home a Turtle Kringle and a piece of carrot cake. They also had fresh baked bread and we took home a sourdough loaf.

Kelly Pauls

Danish, Kringle, and crowns are hands down the best around. The pastry is light and flaky. And none of them are loaded down with sugar or overly sweet. Spectacular

Joe LaLuzerne

This particular place has legendary Kringle and cinnamon rolls. Highly recommend the turtle Kringle. Better than a specific ne wisco place based out of de Pere that is usually rated as the best. 10/10 would recommend

Darla Dykstra

Fabulous selection of Danish kringle. Try the Bavarian Cream. We told the owner we were first-timers and she gave us each a free mini kringle ?

Betsy S.

Yum yum yum yum yum yum. Did I say yum? We stumbled upon this gem on our way to the U.P. and have stopped every year since. Staff is super nice and the pastries are out of this world!

Load More