Their food (everything on the menu) is out of this world! I just wish sauce was on their to-go and delivery menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cody Sevcik
I went to D'Eli Pizza yesterday after a sporting event and ordered an extra large pizza with the double dough crust. Not only was I upcharged for that type of crust (which I should not have been because the cheesy crust is only one that is on the menu at a higher price) but when we received the pizza, it was actually the extra thin crust. The pizza itself was okay but it was not at all what we ordered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Joey Nielsen
The pizza and sides were great! Everything was as ordered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brent Goodson
There are a lot of pizza options available in the area… a lot of which are pretty good. Somehow, D’Eli Pizza is better than all of them.
Being a big pizza fan, any time I see a new pizza place around I’ll make it a point to try it.
It’s really hard to find a pizza where you fall in love with every component (crust, sauce, cheese, toppings) - this is one of the rare times where each part exceeds expectations. The sauce is well balanced and delicious, the crust is packed with a stellar flavor profile, and the cheese (and applicable toppings) are just as good.
Even something like their dough nuggets seem elevated compared to other places like Rosati’s.
We ordered pasta with our pizza for the first time tonight. It was perfectly cooked, well portioned, and just as solid as the pizza is.
We tried this place for the first time about 3 months back, and it’s been our go to ever since. (We’ve been there 6 or 7 times already)
Not only has their food been great each time we’ve gotten it, the service has been consistently top notch as well.
There are a lot of places you can spend your money. This is a locally-owned, 1 location business. If you’re in the mood for some solid Italian, I’d recommend spending it here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christina Corrao-Pavelchik
We’re new to the area and had been really looking forward to trying D’Eli Pizza as we search for a go-to neighborhood spot. The restaurant design and aesthetic are really well done, and we were excited to bring our order home.
Unfortunately, the experience didn’t go as hoped. We placed our order through the website and were told it would be ready at 6:32 PM, but it wasn’t finished until 7:05 PM, which meant quite a long wait in-store. When we got home, a few things were off: • The garlic dough nuggets were undercooked and missing mboth the garlic butter and marinara sauce that were listed. • The cheese and onion pizza, which we requested well done, was barely baked. • The Chicago-style pizza had very little sauce, and what was there had pooled in the center. It was also underbaked and had to be finished in our own oven.
I sent an email on June 22 with this feedback in hopes of connecting directly and giving your team a chance to respond. I haven’t heard anything back, which is disappointing. That said, we’d still love to support a local business and are hopeful for a better experience next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
ImJus SumGuy
Ordered pizza nearly 2.5 hours before we needed to pick it up. We arrived 15 minutes late, and it still took nearly 20 minutes, meaning they were 35 minutes behind in having it ready! We got no communication at all saying it would be late. We won’t be back.
Anna Mulshine
The pizza is so good! Loved the deep dish. They even have homemade sauce for the pastas! Very friendly employees and such a cute place! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K R
Great pizza!! Was driving home and saw this place decided to try it. Very glad I did!! This pizza was great! I love the crust (ordered thin) and the sauce! I will definitely be back for more! They also had a lot more on the menu than I thought they would! A lot of pasta dishes as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zach Nold
First time there. Thin crust pizza was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Rose-Rankin
This place is a total waste of time- go to Falbo’s or order Papa Murphy’s to save yourself from the shear disappointment.
Drive from Milwaukee to eat the best pizza in Wisconsin 100 ?recommended
Juliann
First time here. This is a 14 inch large pizza?? Barely measures 12 inches. Cost over $21. Which is over $2.50 for this slice of pizza. Are you kidding me? My husband and I are still both hungry. Don’t call it a large if it’s not a large. Pizza was just OK.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Kim Glasenapp
A random recommendation for a pizza place, but I highly recommend their tacos!!! Authentic tacos and heftily filled! I ordered chicken tacos….filled to the brim with quality chucks of breast meat, onions, cilantro, and green salsa. Im so incredibly excited to find a unique healthier take-out food option for myself.
The pizza is great too! My husband will be sticking to that, while I eat tocos ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Hughes
Pizza and the crust are fantastic. Love the wide variety of food as well. Highly recommend! Excited that we have another great pizza option in the Lake Country.
Their food (everything on the menu) is out of this world! I just wish sauce was on their to-go and delivery menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went to D'Eli Pizza yesterday after a sporting event and ordered an extra large pizza with the double dough crust. Not only was I upcharged for that type of crust (which I should not have been because the cheesy crust is only one that is on the menu at a higher price) but when we received the pizza, it was actually the extra thin crust. The pizza itself was okay but it was not at all what we ordered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
The pizza and sides were great! Everything was as ordered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There are a lot of pizza options available in the area… a lot of which are pretty good. Somehow, D’Eli Pizza is better than all of them.
Being a big pizza fan, any time I see a new pizza place around I’ll make it a point to try it.
It’s really hard to find a pizza where you fall in love with every component (crust, sauce, cheese, toppings) - this is one of the rare times where each part exceeds expectations. The sauce is well balanced and delicious, the crust is packed with a stellar flavor profile, and the cheese (and applicable toppings) are just as good.
Even something like their dough nuggets seem elevated compared to other places like Rosati’s.
We ordered pasta with our pizza for the first time tonight. It was perfectly cooked, well portioned, and just as solid as the pizza is.
We tried this place for the first time about 3 months back, and it’s been our go to ever since. (We’ve been there 6 or 7 times already)
Not only has their food been great each time we’ve gotten it, the service has been consistently top notch as well.
There are a lot of places you can spend your money. This is a locally-owned, 1 location business. If you’re in the mood for some solid Italian, I’d recommend spending it here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’re new to the area and had been really looking forward to trying D’Eli Pizza as we search for a go-to neighborhood spot. The restaurant design and aesthetic are really well done, and we were excited to bring our order home.
Unfortunately, the experience didn’t go as hoped. We placed our order through the website and were told it would be ready at 6:32 PM, but it wasn’t finished until 7:05 PM, which meant quite a long wait in-store. When we got home, a few things were off:
• The garlic dough nuggets were undercooked and missing mboth the garlic butter and marinara sauce that were listed.
• The cheese and onion pizza, which we requested well done, was barely baked.
• The Chicago-style pizza had very little sauce, and what was there had pooled in the center. It was also underbaked and had to be finished in our own oven.
I sent an email on June 22 with this feedback in hopes of connecting directly and giving your team a chance to respond. I haven’t heard anything back, which is disappointing. That said, we’d still love to support a local business and are hopeful for a better experience next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered pizza nearly 2.5 hours before we needed to pick it up. We arrived 15 minutes late, and it still took nearly 20 minutes, meaning they were 35 minutes behind in having it ready! We got no communication at all saying it would be late. We won’t be back.
The pizza is so good! Loved the deep dish. They even have homemade sauce for the pastas! Very friendly employees and such a cute place! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza!! Was driving home and saw this place decided to try it. Very glad I did!! This pizza was great! I love the crust (ordered thin) and the sauce! I will definitely be back for more! They also had a lot more on the menu than I thought they would! A lot of pasta dishes as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time there. Thin crust pizza was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a total waste of time- go to Falbo’s or order Papa Murphy’s to save yourself from the shear disappointment.
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent pizza and calzones!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drive from Milwaukee to eat the best pizza in Wisconsin 100 ?recommended
First time here. This is a 14 inch large pizza?? Barely measures 12 inches. Cost over $21. Which is over $2.50 for this slice of pizza. Are you kidding me? My husband and I are still both hungry. Don’t call it a large if it’s not a large. Pizza was just OK.
Food: 2
Service: 3
A random recommendation for a pizza place, but I highly recommend their tacos!!! Authentic tacos and heftily filled! I ordered chicken tacos….filled to the brim with quality chucks of breast meat, onions, cilantro, and green salsa. Im so incredibly excited to find a unique healthier take-out food option for myself.
The pizza is great too! My husband will be sticking to that, while I eat tocos ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza and the crust are fantastic. Love the wide variety of food as well. Highly recommend! Excited that we have another great pizza option in the Lake Country.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: D'Eli Pepperoni Special 16
Loading...