23 Best American Restaurants in Hayward

“I ordered a meat and cheese tray and a roasted veggie tray from their catering menu for my baby shower. Everyone was impressed with the gorgeous presentation and of course the taste! I knew it would be wonderful as ordering off their normal menu is always divine as well. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“this place is amazing! fast service. courteous staff. great food. prices are good too. definitely stop in! small town feel.“

“Love 💕 views- like the people- friends“

“I am a repeat customer and make sure I hit that restaurant. Every time I go to hayward Wisconsin. It is delicious food at a great price everything I have ordered has come prepared. Awesome! I leave full every time I go there the meals typically are under $10 Large portions great flavor“

“We had a family gathering for my nephews birthday here during the week (about 25 people). Staff and owner were absolutely incredible hosts, attentive to the groups needs, and put out a fabulous burger and chicken sandwich spread (build your own) with sides. Staff was incredibly welcoming, professional, and fun. Yard games were appreciated for family and kids alike, and the food was top notch. Restaurant was clean and we were please to see that other customers were still able to dine in and enjoy the great menu as well, with no lack of service. Consistent service, food, and experience every time. This place doesn't disappoint.“

“I regretted the fact all these years I didn't come to this restaurant til about a year ago... I'm pretty set in my ways...but I will tell you this...I LOVE their menus!! The waitresses are awesome, always BUSY, a very good sign of quality food are being served... I highly recommend this place... YOU WON'T be DISAPPOINTED!!!!“

“Great breakfast, great service. Lots of leftovers! Highly recommend.“

“Outstanding food, service and drinks. Tom and family have created a place that is first on the list when family visits. A night at Tally Ho is a request that we gladly honor. The wonderful greeting by Tom makes us feel like family and is only surpassed by the variety of food and superior service. Once you have been here you will be back!“

“Went for breakfast. Food was fantastic, great portions. Great service. Impressive menu and prices. Table was absolutely stacked with condiments.

You just know it’s going to be fire when you hear spanish rap bumping from the kitchen.“

“fantastic food and great service. 10/10 will be going back again for more good food.“

“Excellent food and service. Prime rib was incredible (should've been called prime roast) queen was huge and incredibly tasty. Ribs were fall off the bone Excellent. Our waitress, server, bartender was amazing. Will definitely stop in when back in the area. I give it a 10 out of 10.“

“Great food at a fair price. Happy hour pricing is awesome“

“Great service. Delicious Ribs.“

“Diane is working by herself so don’t expect snappy service. She is absolutely delightful and a pleasure to talk to about anything. You can order whatever you want as long as it’s a burger and fries. And let me say that the half pound burger on a sourdough bun is among the BEST I’ve ever had. We enjoyed the quaint and cozy atmosphere as well. She only takes cash so be prepared and tip her well.“

“An all around excellent dining experience. The food was delicious and the staff was attentive. We had a great time! Thank you!!“

“Great establishment, great bartenders, just a fun atmosphere! Highly recommend Wayside Sports Bar and Grill.“

“An all around excellent dining experience. The food was delicious and the staff was attentive. We had a great time! Thank you!!“

“We have lived nearby for 45 years and have avoided eating at Trailways due to indifferent food and service. The new ownership seems to have reversed that situation. The menu is more interesting, the food is good, the service is great, and the prices are reasonable.“

“My husband and I had the best time at Phipps Tavern! You never really know if strip clubs outside of the city will be good or not, but we were already in the area and we decided it would be fun to at least check it out.The place is intimate, and so you’re able to see the stage from everywhere in the establishment. The women working were super friendly and personable, and clearly they were having as much fun as we were! You can actually see women with assets here vs in the city where every dancer is extremely skinny and seemed that they were practically forced to work. We loved the diversity of the dancers here too to be sure that everyone can find the type that speaks to them!Our only complaint, and this probably is some sort of rule that we didn’t know about, was that we asked several ladies for a dance after they went off stage (which they agreed to), and none of them came to get us from the stage after they were done. If this is some sort of rule where dancers can’t get you if you’re at the stage, then I only ask that in the future, they say so since we’ve never encountered such a rule at other establishments and didn’t know. We were really bummed that we left without a dance, and we wanted to support the amazing women working here who did such an incredible job. Oh, and guys who come to watch for free, don’t be a cheap jerk, you’re here to pay to see these amazing women, so don’t sit in the back expecting not to get called out!Shout out to Lollie, and I unfortunately didn’t get the other women’s names we saw, but you all are beautiful and we had so much fun getting to interact with you on Friday!We hope to be back to visit again!“

“Delicious meal, friendly service.“

“I was there last night with my fiance. I was so incredibly happy that there was options for good, clean food. Not just fried food that is all over near Hayward.
My fiance had the ribeye and I had a bowl. We were both so happy with our meals.
The staff and owners we so genuinely friendly and made us feel so welcome!
We will definitely be back!“

“Food was super good and the bloodys were *chef’s kiss* next time we’re in Hayward, we will be stopping in again!“