Not a great experience. The guy at the counter wasn’t the friendliest. I think he was the owner. Thankfully the guy who handed us our food was very nice. Ordered chili cheese dog. Not sure I’d call it a hot dog. More like a small beef stick. I appreciated the price and variety of the menu but the end product was quite a disappointment.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Linda Hofslien
Love Coney Island!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ann Schoen
Food good as usual but looking around was afraid to eat it. Walked in just after they opened. Counter horrific and messy. Cashier's shirt full of bleach stains and hat backwards which isn't very professional. Same guy sat behind Counter on phone then started eating something in a big container behind Counter in front of customers. 5 mins after opening!! Seating dusty and what looked like smeared food by Counter in front of windows. I went out of way to come to this one and totally regret it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 2
Brian D
Great history on this place. Awesome dogs!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chili Cheese, French Fries, Gyro, Chili Dog, Plain Hot Dog
kelli smith
Went in tonight for dinner with some friends and their kids. Realized we only had 30 minutes before close so we were conscious of that and actually hurried with the kids. I'm not sure if it was my rainbow hat. The fact that we ordered 20 minutes before they closed the fact that it was night out in Holman. Or maybe the owner was just crabby. I've been in there four times in the last two months he has been friendly the first three times. Of course it wasn't right before closing time those other days. He was Not friendly from the second, I walked in to the second we walked out. Now if you're upset because of my hat, don't take my money. If you're upset because we are 20 Minutes before closing time then tell us we are out of hotdog and you're just about to close. If you're upset because there were kids that we brought then don't have high chairs and don't take our money. If you're upset because we left a piece of paper on the chair and the highchair over there then don't take my $30. If you're upset because you wanna Go Out and enjoy the night out in Holman then close early you clearly own the building you own the restaurant you have the opportunity to close it whenever you want. Do not be crabby with your customers don't walk away from them with your backs to them when they walk in to order don't shake your head at your son or your employee whichever it was don't avoid eye contact and don't shake your head after we leave because you have to wash some trays that we had two of them in that stack And if you don't wanna clean up after us don't own a business. We spent money in there. We expect some good customer service. I've had it in the past if you're not happy with any of those things don't do it say no say we're closing say anything, but don't be rude. Have your son or your Employee take the order if you're crabby. Either way look at what your Employee or son learned about customer service tonight. I think you should've been grateful that we bought the last year hotdogs before you closed so you didn't have to throw them away and waste them. I'm very disappointed and like I said, I've been there four times in the last two months so I clearly like Coney Island, but I won't be back because of this one experience ,that was uncalled for.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Gwynne
Employees are often in a bad mood and orders are often made incorrectly. Great food, but service could be a lot better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Nathan Mitchell
Best hotdog in the tri-state area...hands down! Worth the drive out to Holmen. (Bummer that the downtown La Crosse location is still closed)
Julius Juna
I think the owner has given up. He seems defeated. Apathetic, and not very friendly. That attitude is how the whole place feels. They even use a booth for unkept storage instead of using it for customers.
Angie Zumach
Counter person is always rude. The place does not seem very clean. The are often closed.
Anthony Wood
7 meals ordered, all ordered with EVERYTHING! 2 were missing items, one missing cheese, one meal missing mustard and onions (you can see the packets and cup of onions in the picture to remedy the mistake) We cant checkthe receipt because we dont get an itemized, only a paper with a grand total. Owner gets rude and confrontational with me because i mentioned its ridiculous i have to pay for something i already paid for, that they messed up on. Owner continues to argue with me after paying the dollar for cheese on the hotdogs we asked for. Absolute worst restaurant and ownership ive partonized and the food isnt very good. Dogs are thin and dry, theres very little chili on them. Our family wont be back, this is the worst experience ive ever had at a restaurant and ive been to restaurants all over the country
There was 1 person in line when I entered the restaurant. After helping the customer in front of me, he ignored me and began doing odds and ends behind the register.He even glanced in my direction a few times giving me the stink eye. He made me feel like I made a mistake choosing their restaurant. After a few minutes he finally came up to take my order. From reading the other reviews it seems like they don't have any real customer service skills, and that was definitely my experience.I initially forgot why I stopped eating there years ago, but this visit reminded me. I decided I'd leave a review so I don't forget this time ;)
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
James Lethlean
I don’t even know where to start. The way they treated my son and his mother for stopping in for dinner at 6:50pm unaware they closed at 7pm was completely out of line and I’m very thankful I wasn’t there or the outcome would have been different. . They both left in tears. Not a good way treat customers in a small town. Specially being the owners. We Will never be back and will not recommend this place as their customer service was unacceptable.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
James Boardman
Owner and his brother were extremely rude. They saw me see them reheat fries that had already been cooked. Mocked us as customers and started a verbal altercation about us asking counter worker for light on the chili on our hot dogs of all things to be disrespectful about. Worker also went out back door to do whatever and never washed his hands when he returned. I do not recommend this establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Plain Hot Dog, Chili Dog
Robert Shields
Would be nice if you were open,It would s 530 on a Saturday nightYou are closed. At least 5 other people were trying to get some food as well.Weekends are when people go out.
Mike Holzer
Was looking forward to going to Gino’s for a Chicago dog but they were closed. Came here instead and what a difference. Place was dirty, bathroom disgusting, condiments in the back corner near the janitors closet. Screwed up order and staff was rude. 80% of the fries were less than 1” long. Will never go back!
Not a great experience. The guy at the counter wasn’t the friendliest. I think he was the owner. Thankfully the guy who handed us our food was very nice. Ordered chili cheese dog. Not sure I’d call it a hot dog. More like a small beef stick. I appreciated the price and variety of the menu but the end product was quite a disappointment.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Love Coney Island!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Food good as usual but looking around was afraid to eat it. Walked in just after they opened. Counter horrific and messy. Cashier's shirt full of bleach stains and hat backwards which isn't very professional. Same guy sat behind Counter on phone then started eating something in a big container behind Counter in front of customers. 5 mins after opening!! Seating dusty and what looked like smeared food by Counter in front of windows. I went out of way to come to this one and totally regret it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 2
Great history on this place. Awesome dogs!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chili Cheese, French Fries, Gyro, Chili Dog, Plain Hot Dog
Went in tonight for dinner with some friends and their kids. Realized we only had 30 minutes before close so we were conscious of that and actually hurried with the kids. I'm not sure if it was my rainbow hat. The fact that we ordered 20 minutes before they closed the fact that it was night out in Holman. Or maybe the owner was just crabby. I've been in there four times in the last two months he has been friendly the first three times. Of course it wasn't right before closing time those other days. He was Not friendly from the second, I walked in to the second we walked out. Now if you're upset because of my hat, don't take my money. If you're upset because we are 20 Minutes before closing time then tell us we are out of hotdog and you're just about to close. If you're upset because there were kids that we brought then don't have high chairs and don't take our money. If you're upset because we left a piece of paper on the chair and the highchair over there then don't take my $30. If you're upset because you wanna Go Out and enjoy the night out in Holman then close early you clearly own the building you own the restaurant you have the opportunity to close it whenever you want. Do not be crabby with your customers don't walk away from them with your backs to them when they walk in to order don't shake your head at your son or your employee whichever it was don't avoid eye contact and don't shake your head after we leave because you have to wash some trays that we had two of them in that stack And if you don't wanna clean up after us don't own a business. We spent money in there. We expect some good customer service. I've had it in the past if you're not happy with any of those things don't do it say no say we're closing say anything, but don't be rude. Have your son or your Employee take the order if you're crabby. Either way look at what your Employee or son learned about customer service tonight. I think you should've been grateful that we bought the last year hotdogs before you closed so you didn't have to throw them away and waste them. I'm very disappointed and like I said, I've been there four times in the last two months so I clearly like Coney Island, but I won't be back because of this one experience ,that was uncalled for.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Employees are often in a bad mood and orders are often made incorrectly. Great food, but service could be a lot better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Best hotdog in the tri-state area...hands down! Worth the drive out to Holmen. (Bummer that the downtown La Crosse location is still closed)
I think the owner has given up. He seems defeated. Apathetic, and not very friendly. That attitude is how the whole place feels. They even use a booth for unkept storage instead of using it for customers.
Counter person is always rude. The place does not seem very clean. The are often closed.
7 meals ordered, all ordered with EVERYTHING! 2 were missing items, one missing cheese, one meal missing mustard and onions (you can see the packets and cup of onions in the picture to remedy the mistake) We cant checkthe receipt because we dont get an itemized, only a paper with a grand total. Owner gets rude and confrontational with me because i mentioned its ridiculous i have to pay for something i already paid for, that they messed up on. Owner continues to argue with me after paying the dollar for cheese on the hotdogs we asked for.
Absolute worst restaurant and ownership ive partonized and the food isnt very good. Dogs are thin and dry, theres very little chili on them. Our family wont be back, this is the worst experience ive ever had at a restaurant and ive been to restaurants all over the country
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
There was 1 person in line when I entered the restaurant. After helping the customer in front of me, he ignored me and began doing odds and ends behind the register.He even glanced in my direction a few times giving me the stink eye. He made me feel like I made a mistake choosing their restaurant. After a few minutes he finally came up to take my order. From reading the other reviews it seems like they don't have any real customer service skills, and that was definitely my experience.I initially forgot why I stopped eating there years ago, but this visit reminded me. I decided I'd leave a review so I don't forget this time ;)
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
I don’t even know where to start. The way they treated my son and his mother for stopping in for dinner at 6:50pm unaware they closed at 7pm was completely out of line and I’m very thankful I wasn’t there or the outcome would have been different. . They both left in tears. Not a good way treat customers in a small town. Specially being the owners. We Will never be back and will not recommend this place as their customer service was unacceptable.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Owner and his brother were extremely rude. They saw me see them reheat fries that had already been cooked. Mocked us as customers and started a verbal altercation about us asking counter worker for light on the chili on our hot dogs of all things to be disrespectful about. Worker also went out back door to do whatever and never washed his hands when he returned. I do not recommend this establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Plain Hot Dog, Chili Dog
Would be nice if you were open,It would s 530 on a Saturday nightYou are closed. At least 5 other people were trying to get some food as well.Weekends are when people go out.
Was looking forward to going to Gino’s for a Chicago dog but they were closed. Came here instead and what a difference. Place was dirty, bathroom disgusting, condiments in the back corner near the janitors closet. Screwed up order and staff was rude. 80% of the fries were less than 1” long. Will never go back!
Loading...