The food and ambiance at Johnny Manhattans never disappoints. The service provided by Nicole is amazing. She simply knows how to take care of her guests and enhances the experience at this wonderful establishment. Highly recommended!
Thomas M.
Went there to pickup a pizza it was ready at the time scheduled the pizza it self is the best I can find in the area and I tried just about everyone around. The only negative thing I can say is they only have one size and it's a large being single the only time I go there is when I have company over (once a month). I would have given them five stars but, due to just having one size I gave them four stars. If they had a medium pizza I would probably be eating there at least once a week if not more.
Walt
Everything was wonderful, this place never disappoints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua0 Trewhella
Had the New York strip was very good!The only thing that was understandable but they ran out of Prim rib special.Maybe next time on that.We went there to celebrate my body Richs Birthday. Happy birthday! ? bro
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Schmidt
My wife and I visited Johnny Manhattan's for the first time tonight and we will definitely be back!!!!! From the captivating ambiance, to our most attentive waitress, Rebecca, to the reasonably priced entrees and the large portions of exquisitely prepared food, the restaurant did not miss a beat. My wife's pork chops were HUGE (she now has take home meals for all of next week). My champagne battered cod was the best I have ever had (sorry, Culvers, you are now in second place). But, all that aside, it was Rebecca that raised our experience to another level. She was knowledgeable, attentive and, above all, most pleasant. As I wrote earlier, "We will be back" and we will be sure to ask for Rebecca.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bourbon Peppercorn Sauce, Fish Fry
Dan W
I’ve always had great food and a great experience here. It would be a 5 star review, but tonight we just stopped in for a couple drinks at the bar and I was charged $52 for two pours of Buffalo Trace. That’s just criminal. I know nice places mark up bourbon, but charging $52 for 2 pours from a $24 bottle is ridiculous. I’ll return for the food, but I’ll get my drinks elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ra Na
Crazy sizes, but super nice service!Wheelchair accessibility: Access with wheelchair possible
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
SteveO
Fantastic first-time experience. Amazing ambiance, reasonably priced menu items, our server, Rebecca, was tremendous, Great shrimp cocktail, pork chops were huge and delicious and the champagne battered cod was superb. We will definitely be back.
SureShot
The only fine dining we have been to where the steaks are consistently cooked correctly. Great flavor, excellent service, and terrific sides. Nice bar with a great little area by the fireplace.
We enjoyed a very good dinner here. Spiedini, prime rib, scallops, and a rack of ribs were our main dishes.Like all restaurants today, quite expensive at $76 per person, but our waitress Laura provided exemplary service and the food was delicious.The atmosphere and setting here is wonderful as well. Definitely will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had another wonderful experience at Johnny Mahattans. Nancy was our server and she was wonderful. Food was delicious. Dined with our 4 children and all of us loved our meals and appetizers.
LynetteM
Our first visit was a memorable experience. Our request for a quiet table to accommodate hearing challenges was perfect - made conversation so enjoyable. All our meal choices were fantastic- both steak and salmon dinners done just right. Our server, Alex, made the night especially fun - she was delightful! We look forward to going back soon.
Had an amazing experience! Very knowledgeable staff which was attentive to our group. The food was amazing!!! Some of the prices are a little ridiculous, but I guess that's to be expected in this day and age. All in all, an excellent spot to spend some time and money!
DebbeL
Reservations were made online. When we arrived they appeared not to find them and finally decided to seat us. We were a party of four and we were the first two to arrive. As we walked into the dining room our dinner partners were already seated at another table. That was a bit confusing and concerning. The other thing that bothered me was I ordered fillet and asked if I could have mashed potatoes - to which I was told no. Yet one of the other people in our party ordered a veal dish and she was given the choice of mashed potatoes. Otherwise our waitress was wonderful and dinner was good.
Fantastic food, service and ambiance!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and ambiance at Johnny Manhattans never disappoints. The service provided by Nicole is amazing. She simply knows how to take care of her guests and enhances the experience at this wonderful establishment. Highly recommended!
Went there to pickup a pizza it was ready at the time scheduled the pizza it self is the best I can find in the area and I tried just about everyone around. The only negative thing I can say is they only have one size and it's a large being single the only time I go there is when I have company over (once a month). I would have given them five stars but, due to just having one size I gave them four stars. If they had a medium pizza I would probably be eating there at least once a week if not more.
Everything was wonderful, this place never disappoints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the New York strip was very good!The only thing that was understandable but they ran out of Prim rib special.Maybe next time on that.We went there to celebrate my body Richs Birthday. Happy birthday! ? bro
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I visited Johnny Manhattan's for the first time tonight and we will definitely be back!!!!! From the captivating ambiance, to our most attentive waitress, Rebecca, to the reasonably priced entrees and the large portions of exquisitely prepared food, the restaurant did not miss a beat. My wife's pork chops were HUGE (she now has take home meals for all of next week). My champagne battered cod was the best I have ever had (sorry, Culvers, you are now in second place). But, all that aside, it was Rebecca that raised our experience to another level. She was knowledgeable, attentive and, above all, most pleasant. As I wrote earlier, "We will be back" and we will be sure to ask for Rebecca.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bourbon Peppercorn Sauce, Fish Fry
I’ve always had great food and a great experience here. It would be a 5 star review, but tonight we just stopped in for a couple drinks at the bar and I was charged $52 for two pours of Buffalo Trace. That’s just criminal. I know nice places mark up bourbon, but charging $52 for 2 pours from a $24 bottle is ridiculous. I’ll return for the food, but I’ll get my drinks elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Crazy sizes, but super nice service!Wheelchair accessibility: Access with wheelchair possible
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Fantastic first-time experience. Amazing ambiance, reasonably priced menu items, our server, Rebecca, was tremendous, Great shrimp cocktail, pork chops were huge and delicious and the champagne battered cod was superb. We will definitely be back.
The only fine dining we have been to where the steaks are consistently cooked correctly. Great flavor, excellent service, and terrific sides. Nice bar with a great little area by the fireplace.
Restaurantji Recommends
We enjoyed a very good dinner here. Spiedini, prime rib, scallops, and a rack of ribs were our main dishes.Like all restaurants today, quite expensive at $76 per person, but our waitress Laura provided exemplary service and the food was delicious.The atmosphere and setting here is wonderful as well. Definitely will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had another wonderful experience at Johnny Mahattans. Nancy was our server and she was wonderful. Food was delicious. Dined with our 4 children and all of us loved our meals and appetizers.
Our first visit was a memorable experience. Our request for a quiet table to accommodate hearing challenges was perfect - made conversation so enjoyable. All our meal choices were fantastic- both steak and salmon dinners done just right. Our server, Alex, made the night especially fun - she was delightful! We look forward to going back soon.
Had an amazing experience! Very knowledgeable staff which was attentive to our group. The food was amazing!!! Some of the prices are a little ridiculous, but I guess that's to be expected in this day and age. All in all, an excellent spot to spend some time and money!
Reservations were made online. When we arrived they appeared not to find them and finally decided to seat us. We were a party of four and we were the first two to arrive. As we walked into the dining room our dinner partners were already seated at another table. That was a bit confusing and concerning. The other thing that bothered me was I ordered fillet and asked if I could have mashed potatoes - to which I was told no. Yet one of the other people in our party ordered a veal dish and she was given the choice of mashed potatoes. Otherwise our waitress was wonderful and dinner was good.