It took 4 years and I finally found a great little restaurant with the best Pizza around. The pizza crust (which is everything in terms of a GREAT pizza) was excellent, the toppings were really fresh and the sauce on it even better. The Hostess/server was CERY accommodating and was intent on making sure we understood the food and pricing options. I would have taken a picture, but all that was left was the plate it came on.
Thomas Hupf
Best pizza in the Fox Valley.
Peter Kramer
Great pizza. I miss having one in neenah and having the owner know my order as soon as i walk in.
Shawn Odell
OK. I moved to kaukauna last April. I have driven by many times, but never heard anything about it. So I decided to stop and LADIES AND GENTLEMAN!! hands down. The BEST Calzone I have ever had in my life!! I traveled across the cou try alot.and omg!! I only have one problem,,, PLEASE!! We need to advertise this place more !! So worth it!!
Phil Richardson
Excellent pizza! I got a thin crust with a pesto sauce and four toppings. Very unique. We also got a Sicillian 1/2 sheet. The inside portion of the pizzas was very tasty. The outside crust was a little crispier than I like, more like a cracker. I prefer a chewy outside crust.
Lilah Novak
Staff and service are wonderful! Highly recommend trying the Sicilian pizzas and the ranch.
Samantha Anne Erickson
Such an amazing place to eat; from the food to the service, I give them a 10/10!
George Sosnowski
Unbelievably friendly staff Excellent food Phenomenal hidden gem of a restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Colin Baltz
Great food and service. One of our new favorite places.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don Steiner
I've used Pagoni's 3 times now for large customer events. The food and service are outstanding. I would highly recommend Pagoni's.
I received a voucher in the mail for a free 14" cheese pizza (toppings cost extra) after recently moving to the area. Figured I'd give it a chance and try my favorite combo of toppings: pineapple, broccoli, and meatballs. The pizza is so flavorful. The crust is crisp, while also staying soft inside. Absolutely phenomenal!!
Josh Hayden
Pizza was great! Try to catch the buffet, great way to try multiple pizzas and affordable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madisen Ortner
We went on a Monday afternoon. Wasnt busy or anything. Staff was very very friendly. Food was perfect and they have lots of options on the menu. Will return to try more. Keep in mind the place is pretty small so be aware if you're planning to go if it's busy or with multiple people. Also as of October 2024 the buffet (10:30am-2pm) is 14.99. We had a hard time finding the price online but they advertised it inside. Also they have pricing specials. Today was 50% off all pizzas. ( If I'm incorrect on any pricing or discounts I apologize in advance please don't hesitate to double check with the business to be sure!!) Can't wait to return!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Alfredo, The Pizza
Genine Nowak
The most wonderful hostess that we’ve ever encountered! Super kind, warm, friendly and helpful. Truly made our experience so wonderful! The pizza was delicious! It was so refreshing and delightful being around such a friendly staff!!! Loved it here!
Betty Pingel
Had the lunch buffet, so got to try different things. All were good. Changed out the pizza regularly. Excellent place!
It took 4 years and I finally found a great little restaurant with the best Pizza around. The pizza crust (which is everything in terms of a GREAT pizza) was excellent, the toppings were really fresh and the sauce on it even better. The Hostess/server was CERY accommodating and was intent on making sure we understood the food and pricing options. I would have taken a picture, but all that was left was the plate it came on.
Best pizza in the Fox Valley.
Great pizza. I miss having one in neenah and having the owner know my order as soon as i walk in.
OK. I moved to kaukauna last April. I have driven by many times, but never heard anything about it. So I decided to stop and LADIES AND GENTLEMAN!! hands down. The BEST Calzone I have ever had in my life!! I traveled across the cou try alot.and omg!! I only have one problem,,, PLEASE!! We need to advertise this place more !! So worth it!!
Excellent pizza! I got a thin crust with a pesto sauce and four toppings. Very unique. We also got a Sicillian 1/2 sheet. The inside portion of the pizzas was very tasty. The outside crust was a little crispier than I like, more like a cracker. I prefer a chewy outside crust.
Staff and service are wonderful! Highly recommend trying the Sicilian pizzas and the ranch.
Such an amazing place to eat; from the food to the service, I give them a 10/10!
Unbelievably friendly staff
Excellent food
Phenomenal hidden gem of a restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and service. One of our new favorite places.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've used Pagoni's 3 times now for large customer events. The food and service are outstanding. I would highly recommend Pagoni's.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I received a voucher in the mail for a free 14" cheese pizza (toppings cost extra) after recently moving to the area. Figured I'd give it a chance and try my favorite combo of toppings: pineapple, broccoli, and meatballs. The pizza is so flavorful. The crust is crisp, while also staying soft inside. Absolutely phenomenal!!
Pizza was great! Try to catch the buffet, great way to try multiple pizzas and affordable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went on a Monday afternoon. Wasnt busy or anything. Staff was very very friendly. Food was perfect and they have lots of options on the menu. Will return to try more. Keep in mind the place is pretty small so be aware if you're planning to go if it's busy or with multiple people. Also as of October 2024 the buffet (10:30am-2pm) is 14.99. We had a hard time finding the price online but they advertised it inside. Also they have pricing specials. Today was 50% off all pizzas. ( If I'm incorrect on any pricing or discounts I apologize in advance please don't hesitate to double check with the business to be sure!!) Can't wait to return!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Alfredo, The Pizza
The most wonderful hostess that we’ve ever encountered! Super kind, warm, friendly and helpful. Truly made our experience so wonderful! The pizza was delicious! It was so refreshing and delightful being around such a friendly staff!!! Loved it here!
Had the lunch buffet, so got to try different things. All were good. Changed out the pizza regularly. Excellent place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce, The Pizza
Loading...