Lorelei Bittner's Bakery

495 Interchange N, Lake Geneva
(262) 248-2330

Recent Reviews

Sort by
lol

They have med a few cakes for me in the past few years the women there is extremely nice an always does an overly amazing job the cakes turn out great an they are loved by the people they are for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anya Payson

Cake decorating was phenomenal! Truly impressive! Wish I could say the same for flavor. The funfetti cake was dry and mediocre. I asked and paid for both cream cheese filling and frosting but the frosting was just buttercream. For a $110 cake I expected more. So that’s frustrating.

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Bedazzled Doc

Let them have creative control over this cause I just knew I wanted Harry Potter but didn’t know any design ideas. They did not disappoint. It was all 10/10. Also loved how excited they were about this cake 🥹❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Featherstone

Really enjoy the chocolate drop cookies, and very nice selection of cup cakes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Macaroon, Chocolate Drop Cookies

Rishi Patel

Great amount of bakery choices, including brownies, cookies, doughnuts, cheesecake bites, macarons, etc., and can't go wrong with any. Would recommend this place.

Marco Giese

Great product & great selection of gf opti9ns.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Sam Dzanic

Got the Too Good to Go deal. The deal is misleading because there were no pastries included but the donuts were fresh and tasty so 5 stars for that and speedy service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Trent Davidson

In town for a concert. Decided to check out the local bakery.

Service was fantastic. Woman behind the counter talked me through my decision making process. She was kind, patient and talkative. 5 stars

Atmosphere: kind of a strip mall mext to a gas station. Clean inside and out. No seating inside. Beautiful, well displayed goods. Easy to find and parking is sufficient. 4 stars

Baked goods: while not the best bakery i have been to (I have been to a few), this one had a very strong showing, especially for a very small town. I had a few things. 1. Small bite sized chocolate cake (don't remember the name). 5 stars. The best value and in a small package. Raspberry fold over. Fresh and light and tangy. I really enjoyed this one. 4.5 stars. Lemon bar was very solid but not anything exceptional. 4 stars. Pecan sticky bun was also solid but a little dry for me. 4 stars. A coconut dish that looked like an ice cream scoop of coconut on a bed of dark chocolate. I wish it had a higher chocolate to coconut ratio...maybe dipped in chocholate or poored on top? Other than that, it was really good. 4.5 stars. My friend enjoyed his cinnamon roll and also loved the bite sized chocolate cake. 4.5 stars.

Very well done.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isabelle Carter

Amazing bakery items, pastries, cookies, etc.. My office is near the bakery so I stop by frequently to grab a handful of goodies to take to my clients. The cinnamon rolls are always a hit! Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Guillermo Pedroni

My kids and I go here every weekend to pick up pastries and donuts. Everything is always fresh and delicious. The breads are nice and soft when they need to be. Can't go wrong for a local bakery. They have everything from gluten-free to glutinous. Donuts, pastries, cookies, cakes and more.

Aly E

I stopped here to get a cake for my husband's birthday. I was the only customer in the store, and it seemed an inconvenience to the person working that i was even there, weird. So I got a white cake with strawberry inside. The cake was so DRY and had no flavor aside from the minimal strawberry layer inside. I've had better tasting cakes from Walmart at a much lower price. I also grabbed a few macarons to try. They were all so, so dry and just not good. Sad, I was hoping to find a good new bakery to get cakes from ever since gooseberries closed. Unfortunately, this will not be the one.

Suman Deep

Amy was amazing! She delivered the cake on time with so much care. Super friendly and professional—highly recommend her! Delicious cake and excellent service , highly recommend for any occasion❤️

Taylor Crandall

I ordered 1 6” cake & 30 red velvet cupcakes for my daughters “you’re two sweet” birthday party, & not only did they respond to my inquiry within hours on a Monday (on their advertised day off!) & was able to get my order prepared by that Saturday. They were exactly what we wanted & more! The service was cordial & the treats were exceptional. Will be definitely using them again for any special occasions!

Hannah Sheppard

We were so excited when we bought the delicious looking Swedish flop with buttercream on display, only to be so disappointed. It was obviously not fresh. No one finished their piece. What makes me most disappointed is that I'm sure the counter lady knew it was beyond its prime. Why would you want to sell old products to your customers? Now we're dessert-less and sad!

Kelly Grum

Went today to try their Paczki’s, they are perfect! I will definitely be back!

Loading...