Came in for a couple beers and dinner and was so impressed by the friendly attention by server Alicia... she's a real asset to this restaurant!
Mr Patron
We came from Chicago to come visit here. First off the place reminds of an old outdated den. The NYE package was $60 per person which included a Ribeye steak with green peas and some nasty dark brown sort of sauce that was all over the food. The dinnerware was plastic the ones you bought from an old garage sale back in the 80s. I was served soup on a yellow bowl and my plate was blue and the dessert (cheesecake) came out before the main meal. The food was basically removed from a hungry jack box and sold to the public on NYE for $60. This steak opened up like a cinnamon roll it was the nastiest weirdest looking steak I ever seen. The love music which was a guy and a guitar was dis sorted and hard to listen to. I know small towns don’t always have the best streak but this was basically a robbery. I will not ever go back but I will say this #beardown.
Gerry Fitzmaurice
Gone downhill from previous visits.
NATALIE CASTILLO
Came I'm with my good friends and Alicia was amazing! The pickles, curds and Buffalo dip were fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara Burnham
4 of us enjoyed the barrel Chef curated dinner tonight. Chef Ben was amazing and created a delicious meal and experience we would highly recommend. Listening to him tell his story and reason for each Ingredient with each dish made it extra special! Thank you for an amazing experience and memory- we will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lazaro Ozuna
Alicia was the nicest person ever and brought my food out in a timely manner I got the brat burger!!!! and made sure my drinks were filled! And my mocktail went great with dinner
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Harmosa79 lynn
Alicia is one of the best bartenders in the area!!! She is a ton of fun!!
Service: 5
Rebecca Polheber
Alicia is the best bartender I have ever had! Like we’ve been friends forever! Great food great drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jaimie Bennett
Alicia is the best bartender. She is amazing 👏
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Damian J
Alicia took care of us. She was very nice and attentive and her recommendations were spot on!
If you haven’t tried the chili cheese fries, you’re missing out they are AMAZING! Come for the chili cheese fries and stay for the bartender Alicia! She’s the best!
Service: 5
Sarah Hill
A spot so good even locals go!! The owners have put a ton TLC into the building and the brand 👍👍 Casual and cool vibes. Best beer garden in Lake Geneva! All of the staff is super friendly! And the “bar food basics done well” menu is fantastic! It’s the BEST chicken sandwich I’ve had in LG since Hog’s had their Stink Pot chix. Longtime LG resident says check it out, buy a local a beer and enjoy a Wisco classic …. Cheers
Kid-friendliness: Very family friendly joint, I just wish they allowed dogs! But like any other bar/restaurant, expect mild debautchery the later the night goes.
We did their barrel experience. 4 course meal for $100 per person. It was phenomenal. Chef Ben came out and gave us a run down about him, his experience and the meal before it started. After we were escorted to our table. We had an amazing experience by McKinley and Shelby. Both were very professional and personal. After the amazing meal chef Ben and owner Anthony came into our barrel to debrief the dinner, service, and experience. We loved it so much we booked another in February. This meal blows every top dining experience away in Walworth county. Amazing experience, would recommend again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
larry bird
Background was popping and drinks wasn't stopping
Pooty tang
Alicia is a great bartender
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fredrik Wall
Just finished a lovely meal at magpies! We had Tayla as our server and she was just amazing! Both my wife and I have worked in the service industry and with that experience in mind Tayla was just amazing! Service with a smile, fast service, attention to details and super personable! Thank you!!!
Came in for a couple beers and dinner and was so impressed by the friendly attention by server Alicia... she's a real asset to this restaurant!
We came from Chicago to come visit here. First off the place reminds of an old outdated den. The NYE package was $60 per person which included a Ribeye steak with green peas and some nasty dark brown sort of sauce that was all over the food. The dinnerware was plastic the ones you bought from an old garage sale back in the 80s. I was served soup on a yellow bowl and my plate was blue and the dessert (cheesecake) came out before the main meal. The food was basically removed from a hungry jack box and sold to the public on NYE for $60. This steak opened up like a cinnamon roll it was the nastiest weirdest looking steak I ever seen. The love music which was a guy and a guitar was dis sorted and hard to listen to. I know small towns don’t always have the best streak but this was basically a robbery. I will not ever go back but I will say this #beardown.
Gone downhill from previous visits.
Came I'm with my good friends and Alicia was amazing! The pickles, curds and Buffalo dip were fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
4 of us enjoyed the barrel Chef curated dinner tonight. Chef Ben was amazing and created a delicious meal and experience we would highly recommend. Listening to him tell his story and reason for each Ingredient with each dish made it extra special! Thank you for an amazing experience and memory- we will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alicia was the nicest person ever and brought my food out in a timely manner I got the brat burger!!!! and made sure my drinks were filled! And my mocktail went great with dinner
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alicia is one of the best bartenders in the area!!! She is a ton of fun!!
Service: 5
Alicia is the best bartender I have ever had! Like we’ve been friends forever! Great food great drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alicia is the best bartender. She is amazing 👏
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alicia took care of us. She was very nice and attentive and her recommendations were spot on!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
If you haven’t tried the chili cheese fries, you’re missing out they are AMAZING! Come for the chili cheese fries and stay for the bartender Alicia! She’s the best!
Service: 5
A spot so good even locals go!! The owners have put a ton TLC into the building and the brand 👍👍 Casual and cool vibes. Best beer garden in Lake Geneva! All of the staff is super friendly! And the “bar food basics done well” menu is fantastic! It’s the BEST chicken sandwich I’ve had in LG since Hog’s had their Stink Pot chix. Longtime LG resident says check it out, buy a local a beer and enjoy a Wisco classic …. Cheers
Kid-friendliness: Very family friendly joint, I just wish they allowed dogs! But like any other bar/restaurant, expect mild debautchery the later the night goes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Maggie's Garlic Cheese Curds, Tater Tots, Fried Pickles, Hummus Plate, Pulled Chicken Sandwich, Smash Burger, BBQ Chicken Sandwich, Chicken Tenders, Caprese Sandwich
We did their barrel experience. 4 course meal for $100 per person. It was phenomenal. Chef Ben came out and gave us a run down about him, his experience and the meal before it started. After we were escorted to our table. We had an amazing experience by McKinley and Shelby. Both were very professional and personal. After the amazing meal chef Ben and owner Anthony came into our barrel to debrief the dinner, service, and experience. We loved it so much we booked another in February. This meal blows every top dining experience away in Walworth county. Amazing experience, would recommend again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Background was popping and drinks wasn't stopping
Pooty tang
Alicia is a great bartender
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just finished a lovely meal at magpies! We had Tayla as our server and she was just amazing! Both my wife and I have worked in the service industry and with that experience in mind Tayla was just amazing! Service with a smile, fast service, attention to details and super personable! Thank you!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Poke Bowl, Smash Burger
Loading...