Timber Creek Pizza Co

134 E Lake St, Lake Mills
(920) 648-4277

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joe Sponseller

By far, the best salads in town. They are always friendly and accommodating even if they are closing soon. I love coming here. I can wait to try the ice cream! Suggestion: put your chips where people ordering can see them. I guarantee you will sell more. Works with your pop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Shagam

I wanted to love this place. The pizza was good, but grossly undercooked. Had to cook it more at home. The people working the counter seemed to preoccupied. The front door was wide open and it was a really cold night so it made it uncomfortable to sit in the store. The soda machine puts out very warm soda and it’s very dirty.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Brian Nesthus

I ordered a pizza on line for pickup and when I got there to pickup the food they were closed. Very disappointed 😞

Ellen Erdman

Pizza was overly salty, ice cream was very good.

Joshua Garity

Ever since the new ownership took over our orders have been either delayed or wrong. One night they brought the wrong order 2 times. I haven’t tried dining in so it may be a better experience. The ownership was very nice and they mean well, but paying so much for a pizza and not knowing if it will be correct or on time isn’t great as a customer. I wish them well but can’t recommended.

UPDATE: for clarity, this was about more than a missing lemonade that the owner mentioned. This was after numerous issues with orders over the course of a few months. A mistake happens and not a big deal at all. But a mistake each order? Not so much.

Jordan Hensler

Be cautious placing orders online. Put an order in to have ready at 6pm. Arrived around 605 and it hadn’t been started but the employee made it seem like they had it and it was going to be ready in 15-20. Let that time go by and went back in and they had no idea where the order was.

Carla Morris-Robinson

UPDATE - Went in today at owners invitation. He was very gracious and made us delicious beef and cheddar melts on fresh baked Italian bread. Not sure how the mix-up with the hot dog buns happened last time, but we will be back! Thank you!
Been here many times for pizza. Recently ordered some hot beef and cheddar subs, description said they were on Italian bread. They were on hot dog buns, so tiny, so disappointing. Wonder if they would have pulled this trick if we were dining in?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary Hebl

My husband and I and one of my granddaughters had stopped and got ice cream after Jefferson County fair. We were greeted by friendly staff We ordered our ice cream. My husband got a two scoops of ice cream and a waffle cone and my granddaughter and I each just got single dishes of ice cream. The price was reasonable. I think it was around $16 like everybody was nice friendly. The ice cream was wonderful. We would come back again and we have. we’ve come for pizza and then had ice cream and have always enjoyed it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MAS Rueth

Only had 2 people working. They weee swamped! Got our malts but they were melted by the time we got our sub
Been here many times before. Usually good food & food

Theresa Frey

Ice cream board states $4.29 for single cones. Ordered 2 cones. Price was over $11.00. When we questioned it, we were told that was an old price, and the register has the updated prices.
You can keep your ice cream cones. We will not be back
If I could give zero stars, I would.
*Review addition, to address comment from Business owner*
*We did not order waffle cones, we had just plain cones. So the issue is that this business is false advertising their prices, and not honoring said posted price.
If it was stated by employees that waffle cones were ordered, that is false. I was handed a plain cone, and refused it when total price of the ice cream cones was given. How many other customers were overcharged for their ice cream cones? *
*So there is my issue with this business.*

Elisha Vandewalle

Ordered delivery and the order was not correct and both looked awful!

T E

Walked in around 615 on a Friday night. Were greeted at the door, Placed our order and when it was ready they brought it to our table. Subs were very good, service too, the young Staff was very polite.

Peggy Perry

Cute place. Food was delicious, workers are young so the service isn't great. Order was a bit wrong but its easy to take tomatoes off as long as it isn't an allergy issue. It Did take a long time for 2 subs. Then she presented me with 2 baskets, not wrapped to go. I was alone and stood at the register the entire time, , I wrongly assumed she would understand they were to go. Then another several minutes to wrap them. Again, good food, very nice girls but slow.

Jon Hubbard

Drove here from a half hour away. Google and their website and their signs on the door said they were open. This was 1215pm on a Sunday. Several cooks inside, but the door was locked and people inside wouldn't even acknowledge us knocking. Trash.

Matt Colosky

Good food but very slow. Just waited 20 minutes for 1 sandwich and they hadn’t even started making it yet.

Loading...